Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

Posts

OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

#1

OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Last night, I turned on the fluorescent tube fixture over the bathroom sink. This is a high-efficacy, instant start fixture.

It flashed brightly and immediately went out. This is a failure mode I've never seen in a fluorescent light before; the behavior was like the dramatic death of an incandescent bulb.

I'm going to test the tube receivers for voltage (AC, right?), but can a tube "blow?"

Re: OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

#2

Clint Searl

Re: OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

Clint Searl

It's either the tube or the ballast. Install a new premium tube to determine which. It'll either work or it won't. If it won't, replace the ballast. If it works and fails after a while, replace the ballast.

When we moved into our home 19 years ago, there was a two-tube four foot fixture in the service hallway. After thousands of cycles and hours, it continues to function as new with the original T-12 tubes. Of the 25+ T-8 fixtures I've installed in the house and shop since then, two thirds have needed new ballasts.

Clint

Re: OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

#3

Results of direct experimentation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It was indeed the tube. Apparently some fixture designs do have a filament in the tube. All happy now; I can see my ugly mug to shave.

Re: OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

#4

Re: OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

Howard

I'll bet they were made in China. I have US made fluorescent fixtures that are over 30 years old and still working. Ones bought in the last ten years or so last about 3 years.

Howard

Re: OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

#5

Not surprising

Dan Donaldson

The old ballasts were basically just transformers. Wire wrapped around a core. Not a whole lot to go wrong. The newer ones have electronic ballasts with a lot more parts which are also more likely to fail than a simple coil. The newer ones have some advantages: They run at much higher frequencies which minimizes the strobe effect and some headaches in susceptible people. Also, they are a bit more efficient and except for the ballast, simpler. With the cost of copper these days, it is a lot more cost effective to use the electronic ballasts and good ones should have a long life. Most of the electronic ballast failures I have seen were the cheap imported fixtures. I have replaced these with high quality ones with no further problems.

Re: OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

#6

A couple a things

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

The "quality" of the power coming to you can make a big difference. In one building I maintain one brand of ballast didn't last very long in another the same ballast, t-8 electronic, (a year newer) has lasted 15 years. In the first building I changed brands and have very few problems since. Also,it seems to me that the OEM ballasts don't seem to last as long as replacement ballasts even with the same maker and p/n. Of course when the "Electromagicans" start playing with our back-up power generators and switching back and forth, all bets are off. ;-0

Re: OT - fluorescent fixture dies - ?

#7

Fluorescent lamp design

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Most fluorescent tubes do in fact have an incandescent filament inside that initially lights up just like a regular incandescent lamp. This filament serves to heat up the mercury and they can fail with a dramatic flash.

Lee