Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

Posts

Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

#1

Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

Bill Tindall

It seems that the most reoccurring problem that gets addressed here involves finishing. During this last round it struck me that these problems usually involve some product that isn't used by professionals, or a product used in a novel way. People are striving for a "professional looking finish" using material or techniques different from what professionals use, or even different from directions on the can.

Perhaps the most reliable, and certainly the quickest, route to a "professional looking finish" is to use materials and techniques that professionals commonly use.

The impediments to using professional materials and techniques are, in most cases not great, except for shellac. Flexner was bold enough to title his recent article in Popular Woodwlrking "Shellac: A Challenging Finish". I agree, but that is another discussion topic.

By far the most common professional finishes are lacquer and conversion varnish, depending on the application. These products are readily available any anywhere in the US. Their application requires a small air compressor and a spray gun but these are not huge capital purchases compared to table saws, for example. And, an air compressor is a handy multi-tasker around the shop. (note: conventional spray guns are significantly easier to learn to use so if you don't require HVLP don't buy it).

Learning to spray many object shapes is not difficult, flat being the easiest. I have a daughter that likes me to build her stuff and when she is around I get her to finish it. With a 5 min lesson she was able to spray simple objects with lacquer. (note: solvent based lacquer is formulated to be easy to spray) Chairs require more experience.

The bottom line is if you can justify a table saw over a hand saw to speed up making stuff, you can consider buying a spray gun over a brush to speed up finishing.

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

#2

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

Chuck Jurvelin

Bill, I agree 100% with your thoughts on finishing. I have sprayed finishes for over forty years, and can't imagine trying to brush or wipe a finish on a large project. I have seen very skilled woodworkers spend days or weeks on a project, only to apply a very poor finish that totally diminished the quality of the piece. For some reason, many think that you need a huge commercial setup and some magical talent or knowledge. Spraying material is far better than it used to be and the equipment available is definitely superior to what it was in the past. A very minimal amount of practice and a few tips from the texts that are available can make all the difference in the world to the finished project. Don't be afraid to try it !!!

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

What about...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...how the finish interacts with the wood?

As a painter, I tend towards the KISS principle when it comes to finishing wood, and quick-drying and spraying are definitely part of that. However, whether it's a site-finished trim package, or factory cabinets, most of what I see isn't all that impressive. Sure, those factory-applied conversion varnishes, catalyzed lacquers or even ceramic coatings are top-rate in terms of their durability and their lack of defect. What they lack, however, is the chatoyancy and depth of finish that a fine piece of furniture deserves (and I have seen posted by the wonderful folks here on this board).

Care to weigh in on this?

Jason

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

#4

So what is your gold standard transparent finish?

Bill Tindall

I certainly agree that the optical properties of the finish are next most important to getting it on uniform and smooth. Most would claim nitrocellulose or butyrate lacquer to be the standard to compare finishes to. I can't tell a quality lacquer job from shellac. For damn sure solvent based lacquer beats any of the water based products.

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

#5

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

Steve Schoene

Sounds nice, but there are serious drawbacks. All of those finishes are potentially explosive, requiring more expensive spray ventilation equipment to avoid risk. With NC lacquer, a shade tree is often satisfactory,

But, and more importantly, when you move past ordinary NC lacquer, you start getting into seriously toxic solvents. Things that both require more personal protection while spraying, and which shouldn't be dumped into your neighborhood environment. The shade tree represents a hazard. Just read a MSDS sheet for a conversion varnish. One call from a neighbor will put the kabosh on that. Only some of us live so far in the country to not worry about the neighbors blowing the whistle on us.

But there are finishes for Amateurs to use. One route is to shift toward waterborne finishes. These solve lots of problems as far as safe ventilation and excess toxicitity. Unfortunately, not quite stand up as well in use as solvent conversion varnish, nor even as much as the amateurs saviour, oil based varnish.

The other is to learn to use the products at hand. Water soluble dyes work great. Pigmented wiping stains complement that dye, though are better made yourself than bought in a can. Shellac has a learning curve, but it's really not an insurmountable challenge for most, and can yield some of the most beautiful results obtainable with any finish. And, oil based varnish, though slower and requiring extra effort, gives a very durable finish. And of course, for casual looks nothng beats the simplicity of an oil/varnish finish.

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

#6

A follow up tale from SAPFM meeting on looks

Bill Tindall

I was at a Society of American Period Furniture Makers meeting a few years ago. This is a gathering of the finest period furniture makers in north America (as well as some lesser mortals like me). One of the Cartousch winners was in the "gallery" area with a pie crust table he had made. A gaggle of onlookers was admiring the table which was of course superbly crafted. Someone asked the leading question of how it was finished, expecting the answer of French Polish. "Polyurethane varnish" was the reply. A hushed gasp could be detected. Its owner went on to explain that this was the table they used each day and the finish needed to be durable. There are several lessons to be learned from this tale, not the least of which is that most people, even expert period furniture makers, can't tell the difference among expertly applied finishes from a distance of 4 feet.

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

#7

disagree on one point

Bill Tindall

"you start getting into seriously toxic solvents."

I use conversion varnish when I need a durable finish, such as kitchen cabinets. I use lacquer or varnish or shellac for "fine furniture".

The solvents recommended for the conversion varnishes I use are toluene and/or xylene. A large part of gasoline are these, and closely related, solvents. And, these solvents are widely used in industrial processes because they are the safest among the common solvents. I don't consider the solvents any less a problem than lacquer solvent, which often contains toluene. I would recommend treating any spray finish with equal care in terms of flammability and exposure to the aerosol material.

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: So what is your gold standard transparent fini

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I wouldn't say I have a "gold standard" finish, but I do have a system that I fall back on in most cases.

A typical finishing job for me means stain, SealCoat, WB poly (usually Sherwin's Wood Classics, because it's almost as thick as a WB enamel paint, so it builds quickly, and mitigates grain-raise). Since I'm usually finishing base/case and doors or windows, sanding is minimal up front--enough to knock off sharp edges and clean it up, then a quick once-over with a drywall sanding sponge before the final coat of poly to knock off any nibs. Whether or not I spray any or all of the steps is wholly determined by the size and scope of the job and the ability to do so on- or off-site.

Most of the time, though, I'm finishing on-site, and since I don't do much new construction anymore (economy made it too cutthroat years ago, what's left of it), it's often at a residence that is still occupied. Thus the waterborne finishes where possible. Unfortunately, staining is still split between Minwax (convenient, but yuck) or Sherwin's BAC Wiping Stain (better, and much more sprayable). It's almost always red oak or pine of some sort.

From a personal perspective, however, I hate stain. I like the natural colors of various woods. Want a different color? Get a different wood. At some point, I'd like to re-do the trim in my 1974 house. Right now it's all pine stained "walnut"--i.e., dark '70s trim. I would probably go with red oak (availability and price), but I would want a finish that mitigates the pinkish hue, would try for straighter grain vs. the typical cathedral grain, and I want a finishing schedule that lends depth to the wood (chatoyancy) without looking like it's heavily coated in plastic. I also hate finishes that yellow over time, particularly when they go orange-yellow or brown-yellow.

Right now, just as a starting point for future experimentation, I'm thinking about going with several coats of shellac, starting very thin, maybe even as low as a 1/2-lb cut, then topping that with some sort of matte WB poly for protection without much sheen, since glare obscures grain when viewing it.

Jason

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

#9

Clint Searl

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

Clint Searl

There ought to be a Twelve Step Program for woodworkers who, after spending 300 hours on their magnum opus, think that they have to apply a dozen different concoctions over three months to finish the project, when a solvent lacquer or poly is all that's needed to achieve a flawless result. Now and then a project will call for a drying oil finish, but in the main, a lacquer or poly will both "seal" and top to produce sheen and protection to the desired degree for any use short of a skateboarding surface.

Clint

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

#10

Re: Some philosophical thoughts on finishing

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Bill,

I don't claim to be as expert as the majority of reponders. I do enjoy finisheng, probably because of Jason's kiss method, which appeals to me. I do use shellac in nearly 100% of my projects, normally as a seal coat over aniline dye, or a glaze/overcoat of oil based poly, normally minwax. I have been fairly successful at matching color and shade, and occasionally do work for my contractor son when new stuff must look like old stuff. To me, its play. Experimenationt and fuss yields success.

Overcoating is never sprayed because of my wife's aversion to mess and smell, and limited shop space. I use polyurethane mixed with 50%naptha. It is fool proof, dries fairly quickly, builds nicely, and can be rubbedf out for nubs and sheen when completed. Then paste wax. My army of kids, and now grandkids were not known to treat good furniture more carefully than a jackhammer on cracked pavement. Poly is rugged, and suits my needs. Further, It suited my customers' needs. If it looks good, it is good.

George