Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Problems with General Finishes HP WB Poly

Posts

Problems with General Finishes HP WB Poly

#1

Bart Goldberg

Problems with General Finishes HP WB Poly

Bart Goldberg

I recommended to my brother to use the General Finishes HP Water based poly to refinish his kitchen bar. He applied about 5 coats using a foam brush. The finish looked great when done. However, a day later when he got a drop of water on the finish, it left marks in the finish. Not sure what is going on, cause this product should be very resistant to moisture. Any ideas whats wrong??

P.. He did sand the existing finish (Bartley's gel vanish that is several years old) with 600 grit before applying the General Finishes product.

Thanks

Bart

Re: Problems with General Finishes HP WB Poly

#2

Re: Problems with General Finishes HP WB Poly

Phil In Connecticut

I think the problem is when you get to the part where you say "a day later". I've used similar products, and I believe all finishes in this class have a curing time that can be measured in days, if not weeks. I'm sure one of the experts will chime in with a more definitive explanation of what happened and what can be done to recover from it.

Re: Problems with General Finishes HP WB Poly

#3

5 coats!! A discussion of how these finishes work

Bill Tindall

How water based finishes work: These products consist of tiny micron sized balls of polymer(finish) swollen with solvent and suspended in water. When applied, the water evaporates and the mushy, solvent swollen balls coalesce into a film. Eventually, the solvent evaporates and the film hardens. The smell these produts emit is the solvent evaporating. Five coats applied in a day will yield a film thickness that will take days if not weeks for the solvent to diffuse through to escape. Until the solvent is gone the film is not cured.

Re: Problems with General Finishes HP WB Poly

#4

Re: Problems with General Finishes HP WB Poly

Howard Acheson

As already mentioned, when waterborne finishes feel "dry" to the touch it only means that the water component has evaporated. But now the real drying/curing begins. With most waterbornes, this second step can take 1-4 weeks before the finish has developed full protective qualities and full adhesion.

Sanding with 600 grit paper is not the appropriate grit to use for this application. It's not aggressive enough to provide a good "tooth" for the application of a poly finish. Poly has relatively poor adhesion and 320 grit would work better.

Finally, although there have been big strides made in improving one part waterborne finishes, a good oil based finish is still more chemical, detergent and water resistant. This means that you must properly apply a waterborne finish and allow sufficient time for it to fully cure.

Re: Problems with General Finishes HP WB Poly

#5

"Dry" vs "Cure"

Bill Tindall

The removal of solvent "dries" the finish and it can feel "dry" to the touch. But many finishes continue to "cure" either by additional solvent removal or chemical reaction to render them durable-hard, solvent resistant, etc. The cure will typically take several days to complete for many finishes. I have seen the statement on many products that warn that it will take days for the finish to attain its final durability. Hence, it is good practice to not challenge the finish's durability for some days after application.