Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Hard or Soft Maple?

Posts

Hard or Soft Maple?

#1

Hard or Soft Maple?

Todd Nebel

I don't use much maple in my projects, other than if I see a particularly nice figured piece at Home Depot and it follows me home. My local sawyer only carries white and red oak, cherry, black walnut, pine, poplar, ash, and elm. Which is fine because I like to work with them. My youngest daugther has asked me to build her a nightstand out of maple. The store bought bed and dresser is maple. She wants it to match. So, here's my questions not knowing the differences with maple: (1) what kind does Home Depot carry (just curious), and what should I use for the nightstand if it makes any difference? I located a nearby lumber supply that carries both hard and soft.

Thanks.

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#2

Hard or Soft Maple explained

Bill Tindall

Hard maple is harder and the growth rings are sharp and distinct. It stains better with dye stain than oil stain. I don't like working this wood and avoid it when possible.

Soft maple is similarly white though it can have a pinkish cast to it (heartwood of each is brown to gray. The growth rings are more diffuse. Stained it can look remarkably like cherry. It is a bit harder than most poplar lumber. Easy to work.

Most people would not know the difference.

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

Moses Yoder

Hard maple is better if you are going to stain it to match. If the bedroom is stained and 30 or 40 years old it is probably hard maple. If it is 10 years old there is a good chance it's soft maple because most companies used the absolute cheapest material they can find. Soft maple is fine for painting, but will stain really blotchy and uneven. Even if you use hard maple I would suggest using a dye stain first to get an even undertone then use a wiping stain over the top, combining the 2 to match the existing color. To see the difference between hard and soft I would go out to your lumber supplier and ask to see two planed pieces side by side. It is easy to see the difference but pretty hard to describe in writing. Most soft maple is quite a bit softer than hard maple but boards vary. The figured wood you have been getting at box stores is most likely soft maple. Soft maple is more apt to have a tiger figure in it than hard maple is.

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#4

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

Jesse Cloud

I wouldn't worry a lot about hard or soft maple. Decide what kind of grain and figure you want and look for that. I would look for nice straight grain for the legs and maybe some figure for the top and aprons, depending on the figure in the dresser. Save all your scrap for experimenting with stains/dyes, etc. to try to match the store bought pieces, not easy to do.

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#5

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Todd,

I agreewith each of the above responses. I wouldn't sweat out differences, I would use aniline dye in lieu of a stain, and over coat with a glaze to unify any disparity. I personally like maple, especially birds eye and tiger. You can make magic with it.

George

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#6

Re: Hard or Soft Maple Hijack

paul in AZ

Maybe not the best manners to hijack a thread but here goes anyway.

I am starting on a cabinet using some very fine fiddleback [tiger] soft maple that I don't want to botch with a lousy finish. Building it is not my problem. Having read dozens of articles on finish, I'm now thoroughly confused, I thought I'd ask y'all what you use. I want a somewhat light honey color that will accentuate but not make the stripes garish. Something along the lines of a mellow 150 year old look.

Which dye? +/- what?.

I'd be grateful if you can provide some details and maybe even some photos of finished work.

TIA

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#7

Re: Finish

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

What you appear to be looking for is a light ambering. Easy to get with straight oil-based gloss poly. Put 4 coats on a piece of scrap and see if you like it.

If you warm it a bit more, but without getting into stain or dye, try some Waterlox Sealer for two coats and then poly over that. Attached is 4-5 coats of Waterlox on the top of hard maple.


Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#8

Thank you!

Todd Nebel

I'll pick out the better looking boards from the lumber supplier and not be concerned with soft or hard. Figured for the top and drawer fronts, straight grain for the legs. As luck has it the existing furniture in the room is not dyed or stained. So, I'll use a clear varnish finish like Minwax Wipe-On Poly or General Finishes Arm-R-Seal.

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#9

Re: Thank you!

Jesse Cloud

One more little nit, even though I said don't worry about hard or soft, I would pick all my wood from one of the two types and not mix. They will probably take the finish a little differently and that just makes it harder to get a good match with the store bought pieces.

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#10

Re: Thank you!

Steve Schoene

I would also choose another place to find the maple. I too have, in the past, picked up some of those figured boards from HD racks. But I soon discovered that many had drying defects--boards that wanted to close after the cut when ripping. Boards that suffered from honeycomb, even. Boards that want to warp a bit when moved into the shop or when planed. And, which, since they are strictly s4s have no extra meat to deal with a little warp.

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#11

Clint Searl

NC Lacquer

Clint Searl

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#12

Ellis Walentine

An option

Ellis Walentine

I posted pictures of some bedside tables recently that might be of interest. Here's one of them:


As I explained in the post, I used General Finishes Amber dye stain followed by General Finishes Candlelight Oil Stain. I top-coated with varnish.

The amber stain is a pretty shocking yellow color, but the pigment stain brings the color down nicely into the genuine antique look. For some reason, applying the dye stain first seems to inhibit the pigment stain's penetration into the curly figure, so you don't get that garish, high-contrasty look.

Worked for me.

Ellis

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#13

Re: An option

paul in AZ

Thanks and some Q:

The top is somewhat more orange and the drawer a bit paler than the honey color than I had in mind.

Is the drawer front finished differently or is that the lighting angle?

What strength did you mix the dye at? How many applications? Sand down between coats? Top finish?

I was about to go out for some Waterlox which sounds like the most foolproof route but am in no hurry to charge off in all kinds of directions.

Re: Hard or Soft Maple?

#14

Ellis Walentine

Re: An option

Ellis Walentine

The top is somewhat more orange and the drawer a bit paler than the honey color than I had in mind. Is the drawer front finished differently or is that the lighting angle?

The drawer front has no stain on it. That was a design decision I made.



What strength did you mix the dye at? How many applications? Sand down between coats? Top finish?

The dye was straight from the can, as was the pigment stain that followed it. One solid application of each, with just the lightest touch of fine sandpaper on the dye stain, as I didn't want to rub through to bare wood. The top finish consisted of two wiped coats of thinned varnish, sanded very lightly with 320 grit paper and wiped over with a clean rag dampened with General Seal a Cell.



I was about to go out for some Waterlox which sounds like the most foolproof route but am in no hurry to charge off in all kinds of directions.

Waterlox is a thinned varnish with a rather amber cast and excellent "handling" properties, which makes it so attractive to many woodworkers, though its formula has changed significantly since it was reformulated to comply with VOC regulations. Alone, Waterlox would have made the entire table look approximately like the drawer front in my earlier photograph, maybe a tad darker but not much. Old maple, which is what you originally were talking about, has a deep pumpkin color, more on the order of the look I was able to get with the two-stain process.

Ellis