Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

Posts

Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#1

Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

doug f, san clemente, ca

I'm in the market for a medium shoulder plane and I'm looking for a very high quality tool. Primary use would be fitting mortice and tenon joints and flattening dado bottoms. I work mostly in walnut, cherry and maple.

I'm looking for opinions on the Lie-Nielsen and Lee Valley planes. I have two of each, but unfortunately not the shoulder plane nor do I have a dealer near me to try out either one.

My gut tells me either would be an extraordinary tool, but I'm looking for the intangibles like feel in the hand, heft, ease of adjustment, etc.

Opinions anyone?

Doug

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I have both :D

I reach for the LV medium almost all the time, it fits my hand and is easy to use for long periods of time.

Take care,

Jim ;)

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#3

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

Jim Dillon

Doug,

Another vote for the LV medium shoulder plane. I am a hand-tool klutz, but this plane is sure handy and fits my hand well. Now, if someone were to offer me a LN version, I sure wouldn't turn it down, but I am happy with what I have.

Jim

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#4

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley? *LINK*

David Hay Denver

If you're looking to adjust tenons and clean out the bottom of dados, you might consider a router plane such as the Veritas Router Plane, which is an updated version of the Stanley #71.

The router plane ensures a consistent depth for dados, and I've seen suggestions that it might be a better tool for adjusting tenons as well.

David


Veritas Router Plane

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#5

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

Bill Tindall

I have the large LN and it is the least pleasant tool in the shop to hold. but it works. I can not imagine the LV could be worse in any way. Its weight is an advantage for the tasks you describe. Inertia is handy for these tasks.

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#6

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

I don't have a medium shoulder plane, (it's on the list) But I do have a LV Large shoulder plane and chose it over the LN for it's fit and feel in my hands.

I was able to try them both at a WW show and the LN looks nice, but the LV fit and functioned better in my hands.

Hope this helps.

Bob in NJ

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#7

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

doug f, san clemente, ca

David - I've got a #71 of my Dad's that I restored. It works well for dado work, but to clean up longer tenons and tune up shoulders, it's just not the tool of choice.

Thanks for the suggestion, though.

Doug

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#8

another vote for the Lee Valley medium

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've had it for several years now and find it superb in every aspect.

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#9

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

charlie belden

LN seems to take existing, "tried and true", hand tools and make their versions out of superior materials. machine them to tighter tolerances and create beautiful tools - that do their job. And to protect the look of the tool - they also have nice looking velvet bags/socks with draw strings for each of their planes.

Vertias, on the other hand, starts with a blank piece of paper and a set of criteria for what each plane is intended to do. They then come up with the design for each plane, building in the things needed for the tool to perform its intended purpose, build in user adjustment options to personalize the tool - AND - make the tool feel good in hand, with more gripping positions overlooked by Tried & True designs. This change from the idea of the user adapting to the tool - to adapting the tool to the user - while still having it do what it's supposed to do - is a key difference between LN and Veritas.

With shoulder planes, having multiple ways of holding the plane and being able to push AND pull the plane comfortably and still with control means you don't have to flip the part when the grain changes directions. Now the Tried & True shoulder plane design has ONE good gripping positiion - for pushing the plane. Trying to grip it to pull it to cut is awkward as hell.

I haven't used the LN shoulder plane, but I do have and have used a Clifton that has the same Push Only arrangement. The Veritas medium shoulder plane provided several different, intuitve and comfortable gripping positions that make using their shoulder plane easy and efficient to use. And if you're a sharpening phreak - getting the iron back where it should be seems easy enough - 'til you spend more time that seems reasonable getting the iron back where it belongs. With the Vertias shoulder planes there are set screws. Get the iron set the way you want it - set the screws and after sharpening pop it back and and set the depth of cut where you like it.

Given the choice. and for the reasons given above, I'd stick with Vertias. And the bang for the buck ain't bad either.

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#10

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

Jesse Cloud

I have used both, and you are absolutely right, they are both excellent tools. I can't find fault with either one. For what its worth, I own the LV.

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#11

Happy with my Lee Valley

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Both LN and LV are excellent makers. I went with the Lee Valley medium shoulder. It along with my low angle block plane are the most frequently used planes in my shop. The LV fits the hand well and holds an edge remarkably well. Worth every penny.

Tom

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#12

Another vote for Lee Valley?

Dave Paine

I have the LV medium shoulder plane. It is one of my favourite planes.

The design means it will be thin and relatively tall.

Despite the dimensions required for the design, I find the LV to be feel good in the hand. The brass swivel works well for use in either hand.

Adjustment is easy. I have only taken apart once in the few years I have owned.

I am tempted to get the larger model as well. I have a LV gift certificate waiting to be consumed.

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#13

Thanks, folks

doug f, san clemente, ca

That's exactly the kind of feedback I was looking for. Next stop will be the LV website. Birthdays are finally good for something besides getting older!

Doug

Re: Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley?

#14

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Da Plane!

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I will share with you that I saw this plane as did some of us from the Halton Furniture Makers Society before it was available in the LV stores. We invited Rob Lee to be a speaker at one of our meetings, Rob accepted, then turned the tables, invited us to the newly opened Burlington Lee valley location, locked the doors and fed us and even brought in Tim Hortons Coffee for us. AT that meeting he unveiled the many prototypes of the medium shoulder plane, several were created with their 3D modeling printer as I remember. The plane was a visionary work, so different than any shoulder plane than I had seen, yet so basically simple and efficient. May of our members that night had lights go On, and, I am sure like me, had one within the first month they were available.

Take care,

Jim