Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

Posts

Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#1

Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning Friends,

The Tilt Box thread below set me wondering how extensivcely used are rechargeable batteries in the shop. I refer to the 9 volt, AA, AA D and C cells used to power flashlights, laser beams on saws, and accessories like "on Point"router bases. My smaller tools require frequent battery replacement. Buying blister pack replacement copper top/Everready are an irritation, sometimes delaying the work, and can be expensive in terms of time in use and cost per unit.

I note HF is selling battery chargers and rechargeable batteries at reasonable cost. I plan to get a unit and batteries to power some of the smaller tools like my Tilt Box, and digital camera. Seems I may save some time and money in the long run. Experience and comments, Please. Thanks,

George

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#2

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

Galen Vetterick

I've had two types of chargers for rechargeable batteries. The current one is presently packed away in a box somewhere. It allows all combinations of battery sizes to be charged at once. I purchased name brand rechargeables but frankly never seemed to get a very long life out of them. For the units that needed power most often I found I needed two set of batteries for the period the other was charging.

I gave up that whole plan and just buy good quality batteries. I do pay close attention to the expiration dates on the packages as I find a lot of older batteries still on display for sale.

With the lower power drain of LED and electronic devices the regular batteries last a lot longer. I do try to avoid electronics that take special batteries or ones I know cost more to replace.

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#3

Colonel, the main thing I use them for is,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

my camera and flashlights and head-lamps. I did try a HF many years ago, but it was not worth having. Maybe they are better now though.

I have bought the little Duracell, Kodak, and Ever-ready consumer versions. They were less than satisfactory, in that the length of time was long.

Well, moving along, the best that I have found was from Radio Shack. They sell a charger with a set of both AA and AAA, which can plug either into AC or 12V lighter, and also has a USB plug on the side. This will take care of anything like smart phones that will plug into that outlet.

Even though it is sold as a 15 minute, mine charges the 4 AA batteries in 5 ~ 7 minutes, and will show a light indicating a problem or status for each individual battery.

It only cost around $30, which seems very reasonable to me. It is enercell 23-788. Make sure that you get one which has the LED over each battery. I think they may have others similar.

This is for Ni-MH batteries only.

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#4

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

FredD

Colonel. I use a little charger to charge AA batteries for my Keyboard Mouse and anything else that takes a rechargeable AA battery>

Well worth the small cost of the charger which is a Sony about the size and shape of a small Digital Camera.

The latest cheap source of AA batteries I have seen is this.

Buy a six volt lantern battery and take off the label and the top and you will find 30 AA batteries inside.

Nest time I am in the Hardware , I am going to try this.

FredD

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#5

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

Barry Irby

Colonel, I have not looked at them lately but a few years back I looked at them for the flashlights I use on inspections. what I found was that "regular" batteries put out something like 1.5 volts and the rechargeables put out 1.2 volts. I was trying to run krypton bulbs and they were very sensitive to the number of volts. If you run three cells or four, the "error" multiplies and you could be off by a volt or more. I tried using a 6 volt bulb in a four cell light and it would barely glow. Then I tried it in a five cell light and it blew instantly. Turns out 5 X 1.2 is not 6. They actually put out something like 1.24 when fresh and that was apparently enough to blow the bulbs.

My point is to double check the actual voltage and see if it is good enough. the laser may not laser if the volts are too far off. Or it might take off a finger.

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#6

A short course on batteries

Bill Tindall

Alkaline batteries: cheap per unit of energy provided, long storage life ( nearly forever in the frig. and at least years at room temperature). Poor short burst of energy capability. The rechargeable version have short life. Best for intermittent low power needs like an emergency flashlight or smoke detector or tools that are occasionally used.

Nickel metal hydride- rechargeable, high initial cost, exceptional energy density and exceptional peak power capability, ordinary versions discharge quickly when not in use(poor shelf life) but this loss of energy is recovered by recharging, require a sophisticated (expensive) charger to obtain optimum useful life. The better version do not suffer "memory effect". Poor choice for a smoke detector or emergency flashlight that would sit unused for months. They power the Prius. Designed to deliver about 500 recharge cycles but when optimally maintained can deliver nearly 10,000 discharge/charge cycles. China has the market monopoly for a critical component of this battery (the rare earth anode).

Lithium Ion- These are hugely complicated batteries and they come in many subtle varieties. In their most optimum form they deliver more energy per battery than Nickel metal hydride but in the cylinder form they are about equivalent. Don't require sophisticated charger. Typically designed for 1000 charge /discharge cycles. Better shelf life than Nickel metal hydride.

All these batteries entail complicated chemistry and engineering. The best and hence most expensive batteries are made with better materials and better packaging which will lead to longer useful life and more energy per battery. Especially with Nickel metal hydride, a cheap charger will lead to short battery life. Expect to pay about $40 for a quality Nickel metal hydride charger.

Heat kills batteries as does overcharging. Over discharging kills batteries but many devices have low voltage cut-offs that prevent over discharging.

Most of the recent battery developments have been out of Japan. I would expect Japanese and US made batteries, and maybe Korean, to be of best quality and hence best life.

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#7

PS  buying tip

Bill Tindall

When buying Nickel metal hydride batteries look to see if their capacity is on the label. If not avoid them.


Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#8

your problem explained

Bill Tindall

Alkaline batteries have relatively high internal resistance, so when you use them to deliver a high current like to power a high intensity lamp, the current sags (I = E/R) because much of the available voltage is dropped across this internal resistance.

Nickel metal hydride batteries excel in low internal resistance so they can deliver higher voltages at high current like when you are looking for snakes in the basement with your Night Piercer flash light.

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#9

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

Howard Norman

George, I have owned and used several rechargeable battery systems in the past. I have never been happy with any of them. I haven't purchased any in the last five years so they may be better now. I just buy the large packages of Duracell batteries at Costco. Seems to be less hassle for me. YMMV

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#10

Me too

Tony - Memphis

I ran into that same issue. You'd think I'd know better becasue I work with handhelds and batteries every day (we have ~150k units with batteries out there - all Li). I have had issues with a few devices no caring for the 1.23v cells. I have also found some fit issues.

The only thing I use the smaller cells for in my shop is the dust collector remote (X10 - AAA) and the temp sensors. Oh, and the clocks. Funny, for years I refused to have a clock or a phone in the shop. Then someone gave me a sawblade clock, then I found a boat porthole clock, then I bought a neat retro Rockler clock... And my wife got tired of going out in the rain and/or cold if she needed to talk to me. Not a bad idea for safety either of course.

I have been buying AA and AAA at Walgreens when they are on sale. I have an Everready charger I also got on sale. I use them for LED candle lights around the house and yard, weather monitors, etc. It's rare now that I use a non-rechargeable battery. I do think they have paid for themselves.

Now don't get me started on my cordless drill battery...even after a rebuild.

Tony

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#11

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I use no tools in my shop that are battery operated, even my smoke detector is hard wired. The whole battery operated tool thing has never been an interest to me.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#12

Another tip (maybe)

John T

You can also buy plastic sleeves that fit over AA cells, and make them the same size as C Cells. That way, you only need AA rechargeables and recharger, and not have to lay out for a more expensive C cell charger and rechargeable batteries.

These seem to work fine in some of the low-power applications I've used that need C cells, but all I have are rechargeable AA's..

YMMV.

-John-

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#13

Free chargers and batteries...I don't use them

Tom Dunlap

I've got a couple of chargers and some AA /C cell batteries that I'd give away to anyone who wants them. After using them in for a while I got really tired of their performance.

If anyone wants the whole lot, it's yours. Not a great sales job but maybe my expectations are different than others. Send me an email, I'll ship 'em.

I just buy big packages of AA's from Costco now.

Tom

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#14

Batteries

iew

Lately, I have found that batteries from The Shack" have been the best. I buy the black ones in the brick. The Duracells I bought in the past now seem to leak after awhile.

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#15

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

George, I use rechargables in my digital camera and they work great. However, as noted in other posts pay close attention to the mAh output rating on the side of the battery. Get the highest rating you can find. If they don't list the rating it probably means there isn't much output capability and I wouldn't buy them.

Voltage sensitive devices like smoke detectors don't play well with rechargeables.

A big mistake made by many is leaving the batteries on the charger when not in use so they have fresh ones. Charge them and take them off the charge when it indicates they are charged. We killed several (4 in 6 months) Innotek dog collars for our invisible fence by always leaving the unused collar on the charger so we could be assured that we would have one for the dog. Once we learned to leave the collar on the charger only until it showed it was charged and only charging them when they indicated they needed charged, our two collars are now 3 years old and still going.

Lee

Re: Rechargeable Batteries Use in Shop

#16

Re: Another tip (maybe)

Bill Howatt

Modern AAs probably have more capacity than old Cs and usually work very well especially if the device used carbon-zinc C cells.

I make my own sleeves on the lathe but you can probably make them with a suitable piece of dowel and a drill press. Don't know if it is worth the bother though.

Bill