Honing Oil
JP in 'rural' Festus
Is there an alternative honing oil that I can use on my Arkansas stones? Mineral Oil perhaps?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Honing Oil
JP in 'rural' Festus
Is there an alternative honing oil that I can use on my Arkansas stones? Mineral Oil perhaps?
Re: Honing Oil
Moses Yoder
James Krenov wrote about using kerosene so I started using it on my oil stones since it was relatively cheap and plentiful and I like it.
Erl
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Most any non-drying oil is fine. I use mineral oil on my Arkansas stones. I know others who use thinner oils (kero or MS), but I don't care to have the smell in the shop. Do wipe off your stone.
If, however, you're doing Scary Sharp on glass, use water.
WD-40
Doug Reynolds in Seattle
Larry Williams in his videos uses WD-40.
Re: Honing Oil
John Lucas
I use a mix of Kerosene and regular motor oil about 50/50.
Re: Honing Oil
Joe Mohnike
My barber, who is also a woodworker, put me onto useing water mixed with a little liqued dish soap. I found that it works much better than oil or oil mixes. He pointed out the liqued is not to lubricate but to float the metal particals away from the surface of the stone. When I finish sharpening I wash my stone off with a little water. I use a red Arkansas stone, a Washita stone and a white Arkansas stone, never any problems and excellent results. I also use it on an India stone.
Good Luck
Joe M.
Re: WD-40
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Would not be my choice as it would tend to dry in the stone's pores.
Re: Honing Oil
Steve Schoene
I like a mix of mineral oil and paraffin oil (nearly kerosene). I get the "Ultra Pure" lamp oil which has virtually no odor. I want just enough body to suspend the swarf, but no lubricate the stone too severely.
Re: Honing Oil
JP in 'rural' Festus
Thanks, all. Tried to buy the 'real' thing at Home Depot, but when they looked at me like I had a hoof growing out of my forehead I decided to come here for an alternate. I've some mineral oil lying around for cutting boards and the like, so I'll use than and see if I like the results.
JP
I use 3-in-1 oil.
Don Orr
I have a bunch of it, it's cheap and readily available. Works great for me.
Re: Honing Oil - ATF
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
Automatic Transmission Fluid - the cheaper, the better. Been using it for about forty years. Nearly thru my second quart already! 
Re: Honing Oil
Larry Clinton at Frankfort (central) Indiana
I use a mixture (about 50/50) of paraffin lamp oil and mineral. I add this & wipe my stones to clean them as they get black during sharping, then reapply and continue to sharpen. Works great for me.