Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Question for Chair Makers

Posts

Question for Chair Makers

#1

Question for Chair Makers

Thomas Norton

I just ordered our Shaker Dining Room Chairs from Shaker WorkShops. And I have a question. Since these are kits and I will need to glue the rungs to the legs is there a preferred glue? I was reading that hide glue is reversable should repair/reglue be necessary down the line.

Thanks!

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#2

yellow and white glue is also reversible

Bill Tindall

Liquid hide has a longer working time which could be useful for a complex assembly like a chair. Yellow does some better in a less than perfect joint.

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#3

Clint Searl

Re: Question for Chair Makers

Clint Searl

Under what circumstances would they have to be disassembled? I don't think reversability should be a consideration. Use yellow glue.

Clint

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Question for Chair Makers

Moses Yoder

Unless the joints are through morticed and wedged, the chair will probably only last about 50 years. Chairs have tremendous stress put on the joints, and the wood movement always makes the joints fail in the end. I would email Steven Shepherd from the hand tools forum and ask him what he thinks about using yellow glue on chairs. I think he has fixed a lot of chairs, and if I remember right he is the one who refuses to fix them if yellow glue was used. Either that of get some steel bars and weld chairs together.

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#5

Re: Question for Chair Makers

Jesse Cloud

Kicking the hornet's nest eh? We quibble about this a lot on this forum.

My short answer, that will probably pi** off just about everyone is that if you want to make a multi-generational heirloom that will need to be dissembled and repaired fifty years from now, go with hide glue. Otherwise, yellow is fine if you can get it done in the relatively short open time.

In any case, do a dry run or two, consider making some custom clamping cauls - chairs are notoriously hard to glue up due to the angles used.

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#6

Careful Consideration Woukd Leave Me Wrung Out

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Happy Sunday Moses,

I've repaired dozens of chairs and have used yellow glue. It has provided a tight bond. I always told the customer that nothing is forever, especially if their were teen agers present to lead my work to rack and ruin. Chairs should be sat upon.

Frequently I'd have to turn a replacement spindle or leg on my lathe: always put in place with yellow glue and clamps.

Ever imagine what a chair would look like if our knees bent forward? 8)

George

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#7

JL

I'll argue w/ that..

JL

I've seen Windsors dating from the late 1700s - some still in decent shape.

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#8

JL

Re: Question for Chair Makers

JL

I have made over 20 chairs of various styles. My favorite style is Windsor rather than Shaker - but so what.

When I first started, I just used hide glue. Now I use yellow glue for the legs, stretchers and tenons into the seat. I use hide glue or yellow glue for gluing spindles into the spindle deck (chair seat) as well as arm posts. I use hide glue for gluing all of the other parts (hoops, crests, backs or whatever) because I don't want to feel stressed out when I'm assembling the upper parts - I also sometimes have to adjust and measure.

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#9

Re: I'll argue w/ that..

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Hi JL,

I love to work on Windsors, but neber worked on one that old. I'd agree to wait another century to personally evaluate my yellow glue repairs/replacements.

George

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: I'll argue w/ that..

Moses Yoder

These were glued with hide glue, and probably repaired multiple times.

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#11

Clint Searl

An unfounded assumption

Clint Searl

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#12

Moses Yoder

Re: An unfounded assumption

Moses Yoder

Do you think they were using yellow glue in the late 1700's? You can talk to any museum curator about how furniture was repaired and refinished in the 17-1800's. Shellac and milk paint is not as durable as conversion varnish, and hide glue is not as durable as yellow glue according to accepted speculation. Titebond has not been around long enough yet to know for sure how long it will last. My speculation is an educated guess, not an unfounded assumption. I have a lot more evidence to back my theory than Darwin had to write the "Origin of the Species." I have probably repaired 2 or 3 dozen chairs in the last 20 years and that is what I am basing my speculation on.

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#13

Clint Searl

Re: An unfounded assumption

Clint Searl

How did my hero, Darwin, get involved in repairing Windsor chairs?

Clint

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#14

JL

Re: I'll argue w/ that..

JL

I live in a rural area. I recently had to help clean out a house were an older gentleman had lived. He had a glued, wedged and pegged rocking chair. It was (judging by the wood and the finish) at least a hundred years old. I cleaned it up for his heirs. There is a possibility the chair was repaired. I just don't see how you could remove the pegs and wedges without showing a visible sign. I don't think they had many types of glues back then - so I'm presuming they used hide glue.

The rocking chair was "rustic" in that it was not elegant or refined. But it had held together for quite a few years - and looked good for a few more.