Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Completely OT: Solar Power questions

Posts

Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#1

Completely OT: Solar Power questions

Barry Irby

I see the ads for "Solar Generators" And am wondering how much power they can actually produce. I know that is related to the size of the collector panel, but it appears the market it with a panel that is about 4' by 30". I'm thinking that can't produce a lot of electricity. So, where can I get good info? I went to the Solar Generator site and was instantly accosted with all kinds of crap.

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#2

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions *LINK*

John in NM

Google is your friend... "solar panel output" came up with this link among others.

I'd be extremely dubious of any advertisement that sent you to a website with "a bunch of crap" by which I assume you mean tons of pop ups and such :D


tutorial

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#3

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

Larry Clinton Sr.

Imho at this time solar panels are just toys - The only practical applications I have seen are the units used to power hand held calculators etc. My son likes to play around with them - his wife bought him a 45 watt panel for a Christmas present. The obvious issues are 1) cost: The 45 watt panels run anywhere from $200 to $400 - 2) These panels normally put out 13 - 15 Volt DC - ok to charge a battery - but not usable in normal household use without an (expensive) power converter to convert the battery power to 120VAC. 3) Usability: The wattage given for the panels are the Maximum they will put out with "direct" sunlight. (The only way to have direct sunlight is to provide a mechanism to track the sun with the panel face.) Obviously the panels do not work as well on cloudy or rainy days and not at all at night or covered with snow. 4) in order to have usable power for a furnace, freezer, etc., you need to have some massive batteries for storage. These are both very expensive, limited in life and require some maintenance. 5) If you plan to recoup some your investment by selling power back to the power company you have to buy some (very expensive) phase matching inverter equipment to "feed" power back into the grid. The only people I have heard of that installed solar that completely powered there home were very wealthy individuals that built "retreats" that were far off the grid. I feel sure that measures were taken to eliminate any high energy appliances, and no heat (clothes dryers, toasters, irons, ranges) producing appliances were installed in these homes. To put it in perspective, I have a 7000 watt peak - 6000 run gas generator for emergency power - I paid less than $1000 for the generator and motorcycle battery (electric start) - this will not power more than the essential equipment in my home. (no electric clothes dryer - electric range etc.). The solar panels to put out the equivalent power (in Bright sunlight only) would cost over $40,000 + batteries + inverter - If you wanted the power 24 hours a day (as I do) you would have to at least double the cost - ending up with well over 100,000 - and still limited to less than the power from my generator. (And praying for sunny days) :>) The only other practical application is for people with boats or equipment that have batteries that are difficult to charge (no power available in the area and boats equipment not used often enough to keep batteries charged). There the cost of the panel and (charger required) can be justified.

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#5

Solar powered mini lathes

Craig Daymon

I've been told by several folks in my turning group that people power mini lathes with solar panels. If I remember correctly, they are the variable speed minis and I doubt they are turning 10" bowls, but it's still pretty impressive. I've done some recent searches on what panels were used/what wiring needs to be done, but haven't found any write-ups as of yet.

-Craig

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#6

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

Barry Irby

Pretty much what I thought.

I'm in Central VA, near Richmond. We have a lot of sort of dreary weather particularly in winter. Not terribly unpleasant, just a little gray and over cast. I am assuming that if you don't have bright clear sunlight the collectors are not going to collect much. I bet the government has charts that reveal the amount of available sunlight somewhere.

The local Building Official is telling us that every house in the use built after 2030 (?) (whatever the date was, it was not that far down the road) will have to be completely off the grid. that will be interesting.

The local power company had some experimental stuff that included photovoltaic cells on remote things like bathrooms in parks. I called to discuss it and the guy that ran the program basically said it was a flop and that the next thing they were going to do was going to be thermal collectors, not photovoltaic.

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#7

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

Howard Norman

Solar produced electricity does not currently make sense for someone living in a city other than as a toy. Now if you live out in the woods and are not able to connect to the electrical grid that is another story. There are homes around here, within 5 miles, that are on private land and surrounded by National Forest. If the electrical lines were not there several years ago you don't have a snowballs chance in hell of getting them run now. So those homes are off of the grid and must supply their electricity onsite. Most are using generators but a few are using solar. Those using solar will greatly cut back on their electrical usage so that the necessary amount of solar panels is within their budgets. No electrical refrigerators, no electrical toasters or microwave to give you some idea how they do it.

howard

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#8

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

Barry Irby

Yes, things were popping and I got redirected to a site that would not let me go. I think I had to shut down my browser to get away. I am not really very computer savvy and did not want to get tangled up in that kind of stuff again.

Ill check that site more closely when I am not so tired.

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#9

So they're making shavings while the sun shines?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#10

Not quite our experience

Mark

Solar power can be much more practicle

To run a complete home with all the usual electrical toys and applicances.....yes, very expensive, not really efficient to do so.

However there is lots of middle ground.

Our Boat access only cottage and two guest cabins are completely powered by Solar.

Three stationery (no tracking system) correctly angled and South West facing solar panels each about 2' by 4', collect the sunlight, and four normally priced deep cycle marine batteries store the electricity generated.

An inverter converts the electricity to AC, and this Solar system easily and continuously powers the cottages low watt light bulbs, stereo, laptop, cordless power tool re charging, and portable DVD for weeks at a time, providing we don't get a 3-4 day run of overcast conditions and don't waste the elctricity we have by just leaving lights on.

We are unfortuantely not rich we have expanded the system a bit over the years providing more capacity, replacing one or two batteries, and I would estimate over 15 years the total costs have now reached $4K - 5K.

We could easily expand the system to run a TV / sattelite system , coffee makers, water pump , as many people on our side of the lake have done, but we dont want the cottage experience to become a TV video game one.

It's a simple function of expanding collection ability (panels) and storage capacity batteries.

Not for everyone but it can be quit effective and affordable.

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#11

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

Jesse Cloud

Solar probably works as well here in the New Mexico desert as it does anywhere - and the utility is required to 'buy back' power generated in excess of power used. Even so, the payback in the analyses I've seen tend to be about 8 years. So the people who are doing it aren't doing it just for economic reasons. Don't know anyone running a tablesaw off solar ;) .

On the other hand, China is getting into it in a big way now, so the price will probably go down and there are lots of things in the pipeline that could make the manufacturing process cheaper, so maybe some day.

The one aspect of solar that truly pays off today is "passive solar" design which involves location of windows and heat sinks to capture the energy from that solar heated floor, thoughtful orientation of the house, appropriate summer shading, etc. Costs are minimal. I know a couple of woodworkers out here who have passive solar shops that stay comfortable down to 20 degrees without supplemental heat.

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#12

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

Dave Paine

Solar electric panels are based on different technologies. The cheapest panels have low wattage output. Typically as the price goes up so does the output.

As other replies mention the output is DC and is normally connected to batteries and then an inverter to get AC out to the house.

A house down the road from me has a set of panels on their roof. I have not gone over to talk about how it is working.

I see a house on my way into work with a larger array.

In the mid-80's I installed a passive solar system to heat hot water. Cost a few thousand back then. 2 @ 4ft x 8ft panels. Heats a glycol solution which is pumped through a coil in an 80 gal tank. Pre-heats the water going into the 80 gal electric water heater.

The system is still going strong. Had to replace the pump due to capacitor failure, but otherwise no maintenance.

I live in eastern PA, and even in middle of January if we have a sunny day, the system can heat the tank to over 130 F. In summer if we do not use enough hot water, the tank can get to over 212 F as seen by the relief valve doing its job.

I think electric solar panels are more popular in Europe where energy costs are much higher. Someone told me lots of German houses have panels, but these would be the high output style due to smaller roof area in Europe.

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

#13

Re: Completely OT: Solar Power questions

Jerry Nicholson

With bright summer sunshine, the sun provides about 1000 watts per square yard. Unless there have been some recent major breakthroughs, solar cells have a maximum conversion efficiency of about 12% to 15%. That, of course, is when they are new, clean, and oriented in the right direction. Cheap solar cells would be a lot less efficient. So it would take about 6 square yards of high efficiency solar cells to run my old Craftsman table saw.

Jerry