Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

Posts

Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#1

Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

Keith Inscho

I am building a small table to support an entertainment center, 31" H x 47" W x 27" D. The legs are 3.5 x3.5" with the lower 15" being turned. The front apron will be 4" wide and the sides and back will be 14" wide. Question: What would your preferred method for attaching the aprons to the legs be? I am looking for something simple but effective.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#2

mortise and tenon

Bill Tindall

Almost every table ever built is made with this joinery because it is best suited for the task.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#3

McKinneyMike

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

McKinneyMike

Mortise and tenon. The strongest and nicest looking joinery for that purpose IMO.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#4

Agree on the M-T...

John in NM

But it might not be what you want for whatever reason - don't have a mortiser, etc, etc. M-T joints are well worth learning to make if you have the time and inclination.

Alternatively, a lot of factory tables are made with the apron attached to the top, and braces at 45 degrees across the gaps for the legs. The leg is then bolted through this brace such that tightening the bolt pulls the leg tight to the ends of the apron. They're done this way for easy shipping in a big flat box. The legs need occasional tightening, but other than that the system seems to work ok.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

Moses Yoder

If the sides and back are 14" wide I would make them a frame and panel construction and attach to the posts with tongue & groove. If you glue the horizontal grain aprons to the vertical grain posts the aprons will get a big crack in them when they shrink. If you mortise & tenon them I would only glue the top 6" or so and allow the bottom to float with a pinned m&t joint. You could also make the top apron 4" all the way around and add a shelf with aprons about 6" off the floor to provide stability. If you don't have a shelf under the table you will probably end up setting stuff on the floor under the table.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#7

Ellis Walentine

Define the problem

Ellis Walentine

I concur with Bill Tindall about mortise-and-tenon joinery being the best way to join table legs and aprons. If we assume that the table will be freestanding -- not anchored to a wall or other supporting structure -- and that it will reside in a relatively genteel environment (as opposed to the frat-house table that JL discussed here last week), you might be able to get away with a different solution, but I wouldn't.

SO, that leaves you with the choice of the proportions of the mortises and tenons and the method of making them. I'll leave that to you. I'm fond of loose tenons, but conventional ones are even more time-honored.

Ellis

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#8

how do you make loose M&T?

Bill Tindall

I would use loose M&T if I had an inexpensive handy way to do it. The commercial devices cost hundreds and for the number I make each year the slowness of chopping them or cheap drill press attachment I already have is compelling.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#9

Duct Tape

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#10

Re: how do you make loose M&T?

Jesse Cloud

I know you asked the question of Ellis, but here's a shot at it.

I use a router to cut the mortises. I usually use 3/8 thick tenons, so a 1/2 inch OD guide bushing fits nicely. I set up to route a few dozen (a few year's worth) of 1/2 slots of varying length (usually mortises are somewhere in the 1 1/2 to 2 1/2 inch width) in 1/4 inch MDF. Draw the mortise on a workpiece or a mockup, clamp the mdf, clamp a piece of hardwood scrap on the edge of the workpiece and shoot a few pins through the MDF into the hardwood fence. Tenons are made just by cutting stock to width and planing down, maybe with a glue release slot from the TS. I usually leave the tenons a little thick if I'm not using them soon. If the mortising jig will be used often on a project, e.g. a set of chairs, I try to build in a stop to ensure the jig will always be on the same location on the workpiece.

Once you have the slotted mdf and the tenon stock down, the rest is just a few minutes worth and the results are almost foolproof and very fast. I did about 200 tenons and 400 mortises last year. I much prefer this to trying to make a once-size-fits-all adjustable jig. If you need extra deep mortises, get an end mill and turn your router to the slowest speed.

Hope this helps.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#11

Steven Antonucci

Traditional M&T... pin the tenon

steven antonucci

I think that the traditional tenon joinery is the strongest, and you can certainly cut mortises a number of ways, but when you pin them, you've created something that is never going to move.

One little extra step, and you can't have the joint fail. Ever.

Steve

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#12

JL

Re: how do you make loose M&T?

JL

I built my router jig. It works well. I can cut mortises all day long.

I usually use a 3/8" bit. I have a bunch of stock that I've trimmed to 3/8". I cut it to width and round it over.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#13

Re: how do you make loose M&T?

Hal

The April '04 issue of PopWood has an article on buillding a mortising jig. You can build it with a few bucks worth of oak or similar. Accomodates mat'l of various thicknesses. V. good at mortising ends of rails. Bill Hylton's book "Router Magic" (he also wrote the PopWood article) has plans for the original version which would be a big help in building the "improved" version. Loose tenons are a breeze. Every so often, I mill some stock down to 1/4" & 3/8", and when I want some tenons, I cut strips of appropriate width and roundover the edges with a half round round router bit - quarter round bits work too. Just an extra pass. Another option is to forget the roundover. Just size the tenons to fit in the straight side portion of the mortise. After all, it's the long grain that provides the strength. I made my jig some 7 years ago and use it regularly. Hal

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#14

Thanks Everyone

Keith Inscho

Thanks for all the kind replies. It seems that M & T is the most popular so will look at incorporating that into the design. But, I might just use Duct Tape. ;)

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#15

A couple of more thoughts Keith....

Barry Irby

There has been discussions here trying to sort out facts from opinions. Many people think their opinions are facts. Not always so. As was stated below, many of us sort out the options and find one that we can do, its within our skill set and the range of things we can do with our tools, we use that procedure, and it works for us. Thus its a FACT that that must be the way to do it when actually, some other method or procedure may work just was well for someone else that has a different set of skills and tools. And then there is the lust for MORE TOOLS. (Perhaps you have been looking for an excuse to buy a mortising machine and a tenoning jig for the TS, or maybe a TS itself? Or a router, a versatile tool that will do many things.

So, I agree with the M&T joint for this. It is time honored and has demonstrated countless times it will do the job, both for me personally and for many other wood workers. So, rest assured that if you do a good job of M&T joints and they fail it will not be because you invented a whole new and idiotic way of attaching table legs.

I personally prefer to cut the tenons onto the rails the old fashioned way. I know that works for me. I have no experience with loose tenons and am slightly skeptical. It seems to me that you are now relying on two glue joints instead of one. Intellectually I know that modern glues are "stronger than the wood" but i still have nagging doubts. (what if the mortise bursts?) I am sure there are others here who have actual real world experience with them and will tell you they are fine. I just went the other way and my OPINION is it works for me.

Ellis is right though. consider the design. If this is a light duty table and there is little danger of it being racked or if it is attached to the rest of the entertainment center and really does not need the strongest leg attachment then some other method might work as well. There are thousands of tables around that have the corner brackets and they are generally serving the purpose and are much easier than M&T. The work needs to be appropriate for the circumstance.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#16

Ellis Walentine

Couple ways

Ellis Walentine

Depending on how many loose tenon joints you plan to need, you could either invest in a dedicated horizontal mortising machine or jig up to use a router. The router method works fine as long as the mortises aren't too wide or deep to be routed safely. There are myriad jig plans in print for routing mortises. I've made and used versions of quite a few of them and I've made others that I suspect are unique, usually for a particular job.

Ellis

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#17

Re: A couple of more thoughts Keith....

Larry Clinton Sr.

You are absolutely correct Keith, if this message had been posted on the Hand Tools board, I would imagine the mortise and tenon would be recommended - however the only tools needed would have been a mortise chisel and mallet, a tenon saw and a shoulder plane. I am sure many other types of joints have been made and have held up for many years. The mortise/tenon has a proven history and is pretty easy to make. I do have an aversion -probably dumb- against rounded mortise and tenons. To me they are too much like factory massed produced furniture. Even though no one will ever see the joint (I hope), I kind of feel like I am cheating :>). I do have a mortise machine and a tenon fixture for my table saw, and sometimes still use planes and chisels for final tweaking of the fit.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#18

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

Jim Dillon

Keith,

While this thread kinda drifted into the mechanics and merits of fixed or loose tenons, unless I'm missing something, the concern that Moses raised regarding your 14-inch wide rear apron has merit IMHO. I think it would be a mistake to make a really wide tenon (fixed or loose), then glue the whole thing in place. This problem arises when constructing beds with very wide side rails. Split the tenon into several parts, then just glue the top tenon and allow the remainder to float or peg into an elongated hole in the lower tenon. Your table will be plenty strong. You could also do a frame and panel as Moses suggested using less wide rails, but gluing both tenons. Hope this makes sense.

Jim

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#19

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

Steve Schoene

Make sure you also read the Jim Dillon post further down. It is important to give room for the 14" wide aprons on side or back to shrink and swell with the seasons. Fram and panel works, but the method of splitting up the tenon, gluing only the top, and leaving enough vertical space in the lower mortises for the wood movement is a common method as well. But some method must be used to deal with the problem Moses pointed out.

Re: Attaching table legs: Preferred Method

#20

now that is an idea I can use

Bill Tindall

For the number I made in a year I can' t justify purchase of a machine or commercial jig. Maybe they are not when You get into them but the home made "universal" jigs look boggling complicated to make, the kind of thing one needs to make two of to get it right.