Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )
Gary Smyth
Be glad you�re in the U.S.
In Europe and in the art world , for example, the gouging gets deeper. Say that you successfully bid �100 for a vase (which was the price the auctioneer called out as he knocked it down to you). In the end you will end up having to pay �110 to the auction house if the buyer's premium is set at 10%. If it's 15%, then you'll pay �115, and so on. In the big houses Christie's now charges an amazing 17.5%, and Sotheby's a truly astonishing 20%! But sadly that's not all...
In many cases, you'll pay more than the buyer's premium because while some salerooms include VAT (Value Added Tax) in their buyer's premium (ie. the 10% you are charged includes a proportion to pay the VAT - they call this the Auctioneer's Margin Scheme) some don't, so then that is 10% plus VAT (meaning it is almost 12% extra to pay, and so on). The Christie's 17.5% is not including VAT and that also does not include crating, shipping, and insurance.
Locally one of the auction houses around here (Western PA) attempted to charge a 20% Auction Fee on every sale. To say there was opposition is putting it mildly. That lasted two months. It took one sale with the auction fee to produce a boycott and I haven�t seen an ad for their sale several months now.
By far, the more difficult to swallow are the Estate Sale companies. Around here they take a minimum $500.00 fee applied to 30% of the total sale right off the top. Of course they do pennysaver advertising, record keeping, staffing, pricing, and cleanup, but anything not sold at the end of the sale is bundled in boxes and sold in bulk�sometimes donated to Goodwill. They want nothing left�period. Literally after a sales 3:00PM close, the (regulars, known to the estate company people) wholesalers can get a truck full of boxed stuff � linens, bedding, kitchen do dads, pictures, garden stuff, for $5-$10 at the days end. Furniture, appliances, rugs go for 10% of what the sale advertised. The seller nearly always feels cheated.