Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

Posts

Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#1

Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant  )

John in NM

Obviously I don't sell much on ebay, but I found out yesterday that their cut is 9%, add the 3% or whatever paypal takes and they're getting 12% of your sale price. I'm still glad to have sold the item I did for the price I did, but man..... what a buncha gouging SOB's!

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#2

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant  )

Ralph Lipeles

I started selling vintage woodworking tools on eBay 13 years ago. Then, they were nice people and had reasonable rates. I believe that the sales commissions averaged under 5%. PayPal didn't exist then. So you made arrangements with the buyer to pay by check, money order or cash.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#3

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant  )

Barry Irby

I've never sold anything on E-bay. Recently bought a bunch of stuff there to fix my car. Have no idea what the sellers Paid.

Ebay has to be, if not THE success story to come out of the Dot Com boom, then certainly one of the top two or three. They have established a "market place" for those of us who don not have a bricks and mortar facility to reach a world wide audience. They deserve something for that. Not sure its 9%, but something. They bought PayPal and they deserve something for maintaining a safe way to conduct business over the Internet. Not sure it's 3% though.

And to think it started with a guy selling Pez dispensers.

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant  )

Moses Yoder

In my area most auctioneers and salespeople work on 10% commission. Just because ebay is an internet based company doesn't mean they don't have expenses.

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#5

That's more like what I remember

John in NM

I do believe they deserve some comission for what they do, and I would have listed the item I sold in any case, because it's not an easy sell, so I needed the huge audience. But the fee increase is just one more way they're making themselves the venue of last resort for a lot of casual sellers. Its certainly now the last place I would ever sell something for which I had another market. By comparison, I find the paypal fees to be downright reasonable :D

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#6

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant  )

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

I totally agree. I also think it's a pain to list items. Selling stuff on Amazon is much easier, and I'm willing to pay Amazon's higher fees for the ease and convenience (although I still gripe! :D ). That said, the first place I try is Craig's List. I can sell cheaper and still come out the same without all the fees.

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#7

sell your work in a gallery, they take 50%.....

Dick Coers

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#8

David Barnett

Sure, if you consign

David Barnett

Consignment really sucks. Either the gallery wants it, values it, knows they'll sell it and buys it outright or forget about it -- they don't have enough skin in the game. I'd never consign. Never have, never will.

If you have to worry about placement and positioning, turnover rate, how (and whether) they care for and promote your work, and finally, actually getting paid, it hardly seems worth it, especially if you do one-of-a-kind and high-dollar work. Way too many artisans get burned, too many galleries go out of business and leave consignees hanging. Contracts too often aren't worth their paper. I've heard some real horror stories.

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#9

Auctioneers, E-bay and Kijjiji

GolfSteve in Calgary

My uncle is an auctioneer (yes, one of those old-fashioned auctioneers where he yodels off prices as fast as the Ukrainian farmers who are bidding can grunt or twitch an eyebrow so the spotter can yelp acceptance of the bid)....much more fun than e-bay.

Anyway a "physical" auctioneer has an auction fee that the buyer always pays (on top of any fees that might be charged to the seller). From memory the buyers fee is usually around 7%. The seller is usually charged a flat fee based on how much time the auctioneer puts into organizing the stuff for sale.

I've sold a bit of stuff on e-bay, but truthfully I'll only use it for higher value items where I want a larger or international audience. E-bay and paypall are a PITA, but I like to have them around for when they're useful.

If I can get a decent price on the local market, I much prefer using Kijjiji, which is more analagous to classified ads. Very efficient, you get to deal directly on the price, and there's no hassle with paypal or shipping. But, you do have to deal with a lot of losers who come to your house to check out the goods...and I don't like having people I don't know see what I have in my shop.

If you advertise ANYTHING onto Kijjiji for free, it will be gone within seconds. Literally seconds. The vultures and wolves must be sitting in front of their computer 24 h/d looking for the word "free" and they'll pick up anything. I've been meaning to do an experiment where I post a bucket of dirty diapers available for "free" and see if I get any takers, but I'm afraid some deviant will actually come by to pick them up. :(

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#10

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant  )

Gary Smyth

Be glad you�re in the U.S.

In Europe and in the art world , for example, the gouging gets deeper. Say that you successfully bid �100 for a vase (which was the price the auctioneer called out as he knocked it down to you). In the end you will end up having to pay �110 to the auction house if the buyer's premium is set at 10%. If it's 15%, then you'll pay �115, and so on. In the big houses Christie's now charges an amazing 17.5%, and Sotheby's a truly astonishing 20%! But sadly that's not all...

In many cases, you'll pay more than the buyer's premium because while some salerooms include VAT (Value Added Tax) in their buyer's premium (ie. the 10% you are charged includes a proportion to pay the VAT - they call this the Auctioneer's Margin Scheme) some don't, so then that is 10% plus VAT (meaning it is almost 12% extra to pay, and so on). The Christie's 17.5% is not including VAT and that also does not include crating, shipping, and insurance.

Locally one of the auction houses around here (Western PA) attempted to charge a 20% Auction Fee on every sale. To say there was opposition is putting it mildly. That lasted two months. It took one sale with the auction fee to produce a boycott and I haven�t seen an ad for their sale several months now.

By far, the more difficult to swallow are the Estate Sale companies. Around here they take a minimum $500.00 fee applied to 30% of the total sale right off the top. Of course they do pennysaver advertising, record keeping, staffing, pricing, and cleanup, but anything not sold at the end of the sale is bundled in boxes and sold in bulk�sometimes donated to Goodwill. They want nothing left�period. Literally after a sales 3:00PM close, the (regulars, known to the estate company people) wholesalers can get a truck full of boxed stuff � linens, bedding, kitchen do dads, pictures, garden stuff, for $5-$10 at the days end. Furniture, appliances, rugs go for 10% of what the sale advertised. The seller nearly always feels cheated.

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#11

Interesting....

John in NM

People want to make the obvious, and I think erroneous, comparison to a live brick and mortar auction business. There is no comparison to live brick and mortar auctions. The point of all this online crap is that the overhead should be low as the auction "house" handles no merchandise, pays no auctioneers, does not have to rent an exhibition space to house the merchandise and bidders, does not have the insurance premiums associated with housing merchandise and bidders, and so on ad nauseum. Ebay's overhead is some office space, a lot of servers, and staffing that can handle thousands of auctions to the brick and mortar auctioneer's one.

Another interesting facet, this is the way they will likely lose their strangle hold on the online auction format. At the rates of usery they are rising to, it will not be long before someone starts up a competing business to do it cheaper. The same thing happened when ebay banned firearm and associated sales and there are now three competing online auction sites that handle them. The one I've used charges vastly lower fees than ebay incidentally - 5% up to $25, 2.5% from $25.01 to $1000, and 1.25% on anything over $1000. On what I just sold the final value fee would have been 3% using this scale.

While I think that a competing across the board auction site would be a great thing for both sellers and consumers, I marvel that ebay is apparently blind to losing their niche. If any competing businesses do manage to get going, with any luck ebay won't have the $$$ to buy them out.

Re: Did ebay always take 9%? (yes, a rant )

#12

Yes, but

Henry Higginbotham

eBay has to pay its CEO enough so that, after she retires, she can feel free to plunk $160 million or so of her own money into running for political office. You can help: buy some stuff! :D