We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Does Ibuprofen or Aspirin or Acetaminophen or any of those things actually cure what ails you or do they just mask the pain?
If I get aches and pains I normally don't take anything. I just hobble around or limp or gripe until they go away. I was thinking that all they did was mask the pain and did not speed the healing process and there could be some side effects. But, the other day I dropped a treated 2x10 on my foot. That night I took some Ibuprofen. Not only did it help the pain, but the foot was pretty much well the next morning. Better than I expected. Might be a coincidence or maybe not?
Barry - while I'm not a doctor, I've spoken to several about this very question. The two medications, Tylenol and Ibuprofen, have two different mechanisms. Tylonal will reduce pain and fever while Ibuprophen and asprin will reduce inflammation at the injury point thereby also reducing the pain.
Do they cure the problem; not really, they just help it go away a bit faster and make you feel comfortable in the process.
"I am neither authorized nor qualified to practice medicine in the Continental United States
Hope you heal quickly, with or without the medication.
They are all analgesics (pain relief) and anti-inflammitories. Ibuprofen and aspirin are blood thinners as well. If you have a soft tissue injury, reducing the inflammation can speed the body's self repair functions by increasing blood flow to the area by thinning the blood and reducing swelling.
Ibuprofen, Aspirin, Naproxen, and many others are non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID's). They have two functions: reducing pain and reducing inflammation. It is the reduction of inflammation that hastens healing because it helps your body get out of it's own way. The swelling that often accompanies injuries ends up compromising your ability to deliver nutrients and oxygen to the site and to remove waste products from the site. My analogy is the efficiency of UPS drivers in New York City and in most other little towns in this country. Because of the traffic congestion in NYC the deliveries are less efficient. Reducing congestion improves your ability to heal. Ice also helps reduce swelling and is often helpful but it also reduces blood flow.
Tylenol = acetaminophen only decreases fevers and reduces pain. It has no anti-inflammatory activity.
BTW, the anti-inflammatory effect of NSAID's also reduces fever. Studies demonstrate that they do it better than acetaminophen so they are recommended more often (not aspirin in children because of Reye's syndrome).
One more thing: just limping around and 'ignoring' the injury can lead to additional injuries secondary to the limping.
Are you saying that limping could cause another injury? Perhaps joint pain or spinal misalignment? I assume this would have to be over a fairly long period of time and a pretty severe limp?
Also, then taking a few NSAIDs for brief periods would have little or no side effects? There is no long term cumulative effect?
And here I thought the limp was stylish. I was designing a cane. Perhaps a sword cane with sterling silver fittings?
I have a small container of Vitamin I---buprofen in my pants almost all of the time. There are containers stashed around with spare cheaters too incase I can't see.
If I've had a hard day at work or some strenuous physical activity I take some Vitamin I. When I hike for a day I take 2 at breakfast, 2 at lunch and two at about 3 or so. It is really hard to limp along the trail when both knees are aching. This isn't my normal routine though, only when hiking on rough trails, not walking on paths or sidewalks, etc.
I've seen folks with fairly mild injuries that, because of a limp, ended up with additional injuries -- usually muscle strains from using muscles in an unaccustomed manner. Some of these injuries can be more disabling than the original. Often-times I am able to prevent the limp by merely advising that they shorten their stride considerably. Many are surprised that this little change really helps a lot.
Regarding cumulative effect of sporadic use -- I don't know of any.