Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

The Zen of the edge joint

Posts

The Zen of the edge joint

#1

The Zen of the edge joint

wilbur

Like the BBE, or maybe in conjunction with the BBE, a non sprung joint is supposed to prevent some calamity when boards are joined together by ensuring that the edges match. In the olden days it was a gotta-do before gluing up a panel. There are still adherents to the practice. I think it had something to do with experience showing that the joints at either end of the glued panel had few issues with possibly pulling apart even though the end grain would dry and shrink faster than the interior of the boards. But that can't be right because a poster on the BBE thread asserted that hide glue from the local abattoir wouldn't have failed.

Anyway, let's see if I have the drill correct. After selecting all the boards for a table top, which have been S4S jointed and planed so that they're all the same thickness and the joints are all a perfect match, and are all at 6-8% moisture, I'm supposed to then hand plane the interior edge(s) of each board so that every joint will be perfectly matched along its length. Then I can do the glueup and pull everything together with massive clamping, or is it cramping, pressure. That's what FWW tells me.

I hope someone can explain why I would want to do that when I've never taken the time to do it before and have never had a problem with quickly making a sprung joint.

Next time we'll explore the Zen of the dovetail joint.

==========

Before I get inundated with replies, I am not being serious at all with the above passage. There are advantages and disadvantages to making a sprung joint. The same holds true for edge joints that are not sprung. Both will yield excellent results, and it would be impossible to tell which method was used to glue up a panel by examining the panel afterwards.

I just wanted to point out that the existence of one method of work for a given task does not invalidate other methods of work for the same task. Otherwise, we'd all be using Japanese woodworking tools. ;)

Re: The Zen of the edge joint

#2

poke poke poke

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hey Wilbur,

As has previously been pointed out in some other thread, these 'arguments' about techniques and methods are simply modes of communications through which people pass on tidbits of information about how they do stuff and their personal OPINIONS/experiences of why they do it that way.

There are no magic bullets in any of man's fields of endeavor, (otherwise we'd all be using western tools:)

It's Caveat emptor as far as any info one picks off the internet on WW. One needs to be able to evaluate the quality of the source. Or make your own experiments and then decide what works for you.

Bob in NJ

Re: The Zen of the edge joint

#3

Re: poke poke poke

wilbur

"these 'arguments' about techniques and methods are simply modes of communications through which people pass on tidbits of information about how they do stuff and their personal OPINIONS/experiences of why they do it that way"

Sure, Bob, but there's a difference between saying "This is what I do and this is why I do it," and saying "I hope someone can explain why I would want to do that when I've never had to do that before." The first is explaining how and why they do something a certain way. The second is disparaging other methods of work.

Poke poke poke pokity pokity poke. ;)