Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

The Zen of the sprung joint

Posts

The Zen of the sprung joint

#1

Clint Searl

The Zen of the sprung joint

Clint Searl

Like the BBE, or maybe in conjunction with the BBE, a sprung joint is supposed to prevent some calamity when boards are joined together. In the olden days it was a gotta-do before hide gluing a layup. There are still adherents to the practice. I think it had something to do with the joints at either end of the glued layup possibly pulling apart because the end grain would dry and shrink faster than the interior of the boards, making the glue fail. But that can't be right because a poster on the BBE thread asserted that hide glue from the local abattoir wouldn't have failed.

Anyway, let's see if I have the drill correct. After selecting all the boards for a table top, which have been S4S jointed and planed so that they're all the same thickness and the joints are all a perfect match, and are all at 6-8% moisture, I'm supposed to then hand plane the interior edge(s) of each board so that every joint will be subtly gapped toward the center. Then I can do the glueup and pull everything together with massive clamping, or is it cramping, pressure.

I hope someone can explain why I would want to do that when I've never (intentionally) done it before and have never had a problem with a layup coming apart.

Next time we'll explore the Zen of the dovetail joint.

Clint :b

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#2

what is a BBE?

paul in AZ

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#3

Bread board end

Dan Donaldson

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

Moses Yoder

If every piece is purely functional and it is not necesssary to have fun building something nor for it to look good when finished there is no reason to use any joint besides the pocket screw joint. Is this now the Red Green Woodworking forum, or what happened?

My teacher in 10th grade shop class taught me how to make a sprung joint. That was close to 30 years ago. I would agree that in today's climate controlled home the sprung joint is not a necessity. After I joint boards on a power jointer I clean up the edges with a hand plane called a jointer and it is very easy while doing so to take a few extra passes in the center of the board.


I think we should be encouraging people to do the finest work they are capable of, not telling them to take up welding or duct tape as a hobby.


Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#5

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

Barry Irby

We are talking Zen here aren't we? I am not a hand tool guy and don't own a jointer plane and in fact only have a block plane which apparently is not very sharp because I don't own water stones and don't get into a trance sharpening it.

I have done sprung joints. My 6" Delta jointer (noisy one with a black tail) was doing them quite nicely for a while. I glued up a number of table tops. Found that the clamping pressure was not "massive". In fact it seemed to simplify the clamping. A six foot long top only required 3 clamps. Actually one did the job but I couldn't stand it and put two more on out of habit or the irresistible urge that more is better. The joints were consistently open less than a hundredth at the center and the boards were 5/4 x 6.

Once I tuned up the jointer I got boards that were straight and the joints matched up without the gaps. I ended up using five clamps.

I struggle with the Zen thing. Is what we are doing, having fun and demonstrating a mastery of skills or are we producing furniture? Is it the journey or the end result? Does anyone really care if the top was produced in near silence and with Eye hand coordination or with noisy loathsome power tools? Does someone look at the table top and think---"The maker was a master of the art" or "I'm glad I did not live next door and have to listen to the tools."? Is it an insult to say "Wow, he had really nice wood"?

As far as I can tell both types of tops I made function identically and I would defy anyone to tell the difference. Even I have forgotten which was which.

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#6

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

Steve Schoene

The pocket screw joint? That works fine on cabinetry, but cabinetry is supposed to last two or three decades. Quality furniture is expected tohave a time span measured by generations. Wood moves constantly with humidity. Screws don't. Eventually that means the screws loosen. It's not a long term joint. Dovetails and M&T joints will last much longer, and be more repairable when they fail.

Sprung joints have a more intesting history, at least the way I have put it together. I don't think it was commonly used before the era of factory furntiture. But then again cabinet makers certainly avoided edge joins. Wide boards mark the furniture of the period. And heavy clamping seems not to be the hallmarks of the period. In fact much gluing was done with the rubbed joint, much more feasible with hot hide glue. Hide glue shrinks as it dries pulling joints together.

Later, however, as furniture moved in to factories, houses coincidentally began to get central heating, which without summer air conditioning means wider swings in interior seasonal humidity. More joints began to fail, and the sprung joint was developed to counteract this observation. Some of the high end jointers had an adjustment mechanism to shift the outfeed table just enough to get a sprung joint. For that matter, when I got my Hammer Jointer/Planer combo the manual indicated the factory settings gave a small sprung joint. During that era it probably had more value than today. Hide glue continued as the glue of choice well into the twentieth century. (Still is for highest quality furniture, in my opintion.)

Today of course, with houses that for the most part have much less humidity swings than those of yore, the sprung joint has less functional purpose, and using it is certainly not a necessity.

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#7

another opinion

Bill Tindall

I think it is an artifact left over from the days when lumber of higher and more variable moisture content was used to build furniture. I always imagine the cabinet maker of old having a better year than expected, or alternatively barely surviving, unable to afford much inventory, and then getting an order for a table. Dang! fresh out of lumber dried to the standard of the day "1 year per inch". What to do? Well I have some lumber dried 0.9 year per inch. I'll bet if I hollow out the middle of each piece to be glued it will compensate for how much more it will dry when it gets set by the fireplace in January. And so the sprung joint was born. I think KD lumber made obsolete the sprung joint.

If one plots a graph of fraction of sprung joints vs time I think the graph will near zero in the next generation. If non-sprung joints were a problem experienced by joint gluers the graph would not be headed downward.

I don't see where the piddly amount of extra pressure exerted by the sprung joint is going to add significantly to the huge adhesive force provided by modern glue, a force that exceeds the yield strength of wood.

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#8

Ellis Walentine

Back to design

Ellis Walentine

These discussions of breadboard ends and sprung joints underscore several things for me. One is that people are passionate about their beliefs and willing to protect them against naysayers. Another is that woodworking literature and lore is filled with conflicting views of just about everything. Toshio Odate once complained to me that magazines are like children without a parent, that is, there is no unified theory -- every article (this goes for books, too) is necessarily the viewpoint of the author and may or may not coincide with anyone else's viewpoint, certainly not across cultures. As consumers of this information, we tend to follow the authors and practitioners who are most convincing to us. I see it all the time.

To me, design is the common denominator. As the designer, you can choose to use any aesthetics and any materials and techniques you see fit, for whatever reason. The only important thing is whether your choices solve the design problem to your satisfaction. On individual issues, there may be compelling objective evidence that one technique or engineering solution is superior in some or all regards, but it still needn't be mandatory because of it. We're all free to do things the way we prefer, for whatever reasons.

Ellis

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#9

Another place for sprung joints

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I think a sprung joint may be of some value in making cutting boards. I know that I have had to rework some old cutting boards because the joints opened at the ends and the cracks became traps for food particles. A sprung joint might have prevented these failures.

Lee

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#10

beware Clint

Bill Tindall

I have my pen sharpened in readiness to support the dovetail joint, the only way to hold case goods and drawers together.

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#11

What's zen about these threads?

John in NM

My pet peeve is people who camp out in the left lane on the freeway :D

If you don't want to spring your joints, fine, don't do so. For those who do wish to do so, just remember it's not as much trouble as a BBE and it doesn't do any harm. I spring edge joints because I find it trivially easy to do so.

I think the reality of the practice lies in what Bill and Steve have said, and incidentally, I have seen a case just like what Bill describes - here in the modern world, in a shop using lots of mesquite lumber, dried by the shop, and quite likely rushed into use trying to meet a deadline.

I've also fixed 40-50 year old factory tables where most of the edge joints were failing, apparently oblivious to the conventional wisdom that all this bother is un-necessary and pva never degrades. Whatever, there are absolutely no guarantees in woodworking, and nothing lasts forever.

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#12

Clint Searl

I can hear.....

Clint Searl

....the sound of one hand clapping.

Clint

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#13

Not that simple why we argue

Bill Tindall

The intended audience for these arguments are not the people arguing. Indeed as you point out, if it works it works and there is no argument about success. And most of us realize that experienced woodworkers are exceptionally conservative about changing anything that works be it sprung joints, bevel down planes or hide glue. So it is pointless to advocate change to someone comfortable in success, and we realize this fact.

Rather, the target audience for these arguments are those who haven't achieved success either because they are beginners or because some approach is not working for them.

As you point out, for many woodworking things there are two or more successful approaches/techniques/ materials. To take some example: if someone says use "possum hide" glue because I successfully use it, useful information is provided to Forum readers by someone else saying "purple glue" is best because it is just as strong, it is more convenient and it smells like grapes instead of dead possum. The possum advocate may rebut with additional data to support her use of possum glue, and back and forth. In the end the undecided have a body of data from which to make their more informed choice.

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#14

Well said

paul in AZ

Two thoughts come to mind when I hear people arguing.

In the context of our craft it usually means that both are correct in as far as their experience has shown them a technique that works -if only for them. A novice can try ideas and select.

In all too many other contexts it means that neither party knows what they are talking about and there is no "correct" answer.

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#15

The Zen of Answers

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

There are many paths to success; some longer, some shorter, but all leading to the same place.

One neither detracts from nor refutes any other.

Be happy with your chosen path.

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#16

Re: The Zen of Answers

Jesse Cloud

Glad to see some 'wisdom' seeping into the discussion.

I think part of it is just that there is so much to learn in woodworking that once we find something that works for us, we accept it as The Way and move on to learning something else.

I have been fortunate to take several courses at a local community college with some really outstanding instructors. They all produce breathtakingly good work, but no two get there in the same path. Find your own path, but don't insult others by claiming its the only path.

Now, down to the details, Bill where can I get some of that "Dead Possum Glue?"

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#17

answer

Bill Tindall

Any roadway in TN has lots of raw material this time of year which can be collected early mornings.

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#18

Better Make  It Real Early

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Before the cooks wake up. :D

Re: The Zen of the sprung joint

#19

Re: Zen so this is a buddist forum now?:)

Bob Entwisle in NJ

zen and this or zen and that, who gives a ???