Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Opinion questions (A or B)..

Posts

Opinion questions (A or B)..

#1

JL

Opinion questions (A or B)..

JL

On the rolling pins:

Knob ends or tapered ends?

On the boxes:

Taller and "more square" or shorter and rectangular?


I'm making things for the church "arts and crafts" sale. I have the cherry (and ash).

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

Moses Yoder

Nothing to do with your questions but I would use thinner wood for those little boxes, I would make the corner posts pretty dainty, and I would kind of taper the feet to match the top but leave enough flat in the center to attach to the posts. On the rolling pins I would put traditional handles on them; I can find a pic if you want. The knob on the end is too close to the same diameter as the center and would get into the dough.

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#3

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

A. Knob ends, always.

B. 1. Samo as long as you make the lids extend out beyond those corner blocks. My tendency would be to the same outside dimension as the feet.

2. Smaller handles, if not post and bar handles. Look at Japanese roof architecture.

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#4

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

GolfSteve in Calgary

Rolling pins - tapered ends. You might want to experiment with a longer taper. Take a look at the pictures here:

http://www.easykitchenaccessories.com/2010/11/rolling-pin-dough-and-husband-most-hated-enemy/

You might also consider changing your knobbed rolling pin design to look a bit more like the one shown in that link - it looks a bit more refined.

Boxes - longer (more rectangular) is better, but the boxes are too heavy - consider reducing the thickness of the pieces to 1/4" instead of the 1/2"+ that you are currently using. These are small boxes, so keep the thicknesses proportional to the box size and I think they'll look better.

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#5

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

My wife is into artisan bread baking. (I have a waistline to prove it). She prefers the tapered. I think that is the classic form in French bakeries.

Tom

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#6

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

John E in SC

A. Either tapered ends or more traditional, fatter body with smaller diameter handles. I think the "knobs" would get in the way.

B. Pretty wood, but your design looks too "chunky" for my tastes. The handle on top is too large. Maybe leave off the corner blocks and feet and consider splined or keyed miters? (Could use the ashe for contrast.) Very simple to make with a homemade jig, and would look much more refined, IMHO.

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#7

Alan Young

Tapered-there is better chance you'll survive a

Alan Young

rolling pin attack if the ends are tapered-Just maybe there'll be a bit of flour or oil on the pin and it will slip out of the hands before it hit's your head.

Remember: Safety comes before style.

-Alan

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#8

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

steve mackay

I like rolling pins with something I can "hook" my thumbs on. Better control. I've heard it from Seniors also.

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#9

Re: Opinion questions (A or B).. *LINK*

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Good evening JL.

Let me suggest you visit the Vermont Rolling Pins website. They make many versions, and I would think you can fine a style that fits your needs.

Good Luck with your crafts project,

Ken.


Vermont rolling pins

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#10

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

Bill Howatt

Rolling pin- baker in the house says tapered. I made her one that is just the cylinder with no tapers and she uses it all the time. However, you may find people at the sale that think rolling pins should have handles but I would make them without the big knobs.

Box - rectangle but I agree it is too heavy as shown.

Bill

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#11

tapered, rectangle

Jesse Cloud

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#12

I agree with the ones who are right

Barry Irby

:)

Check out that Vermont rolling pin site. Lots of ideas. I like the tapered ones. As an aside, I wonder if you make one where the knob was larger than the pin and could be used to roll dough out to exactly 1/8" or what ever. I'll have to ask a baker.

Good suggestion on the boxes. Rectangular, lighter, smaller handles. I made a bunch with the spline corners and the only problem I ran into was the splines wanted to "squirt" back out. Wind them shrink wrap or inner tube or something for a few minutes. This would work well on your little corner posts.

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#13

my favorite rolling pin is a straight cylinder

Bruce, a MN Galoot

with rounded ends.

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#14

JL

OK - points taken

JL

I've got some 3/8" and some 1/4" thick stock from resawing.

I've actually got some ash as well as cherry.

I will thin down the corner posts on the next batch.

I will go for more tapered rolling pins and "adjust" some handles on other types. I've got a fair bit of cherry that will make some nice pins.

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#15

A.J. Hamler

Re: Tapered-there is better chance you'll survive

A.J. Hamler

Spoken like someone who has experience in such matters...

Re: Opinion questions (A or B)..

#16

Are these trick questions?  I like 'em all

David Lykins - Dallas GA