Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Grinding Woes

Posts

Grinding Woes

#1

Grinding Woes

Thomas Norton

Maybe this should be in Hand Tools but I will give it a shot here.

I have a heck of a time grinding a square edge on chisels and plane blades. I have the Lee Valley adjustable rest and grind freehand. But I do use my fingers as a guide. I do have the jig that clamps the blade/chisel but I find it very cumbersome to use.

Any thoughts? Maybe I need a better rest set-up?

Thanks

Re: Grinding Woes

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Grinding Woes

Moses Yoder

I usually take a square and check every so often till I have a square edge the first time I grind a blade. After that, I don't grind all the way out to the edge; I leave a little tip to hone. You have to keep the sparks in the center of the grinder too, that way you know it is being held square to the grinder. I hold the blade with my left hand and crank with my right hand; works pretty good ;)

Re: Grinding Woes

#4

Re: Grinding Woes

John Lucas

I have one of those rest also. I don't use it much anymore. The trick is set it square to the wheel, then true up the wheel so it's square. Then you can make a sliding tool rest to go in the slot on the Lee Valley rest. I just glued a piece of scrap to the sliding rest that is square to the stone. Then just hold the chisel or iron against this and slide it across.

I don't think perfectly square is absolutely essential. Color the end of the chisel with a magic marker. Scribe a line using a square. Then hand grind up to the line and go on a sharpen it. If your careful you can get is square enough to just barely see light below a straight edge. That's far straighter than we need for wood.

Re: Grinding Woes

#5

Re: Grinding Woes

Thomas Norton

One of the challenges I face is getting a really square blade for my shoulder planes.

I will try the felt tip marker trick.

Re: Grinding Woes

#6

Re: Grinding Woes

Dean J from MN

Are you trying to grind the bevel at the same time you are attempting to square the iron?

Try them in two steps:

1) Mark a square line on blade; grind at 90 degrees to the edge, working to the line.

2) Now grind the bevel, watching the "flat" you made in step one to guide your bevel grinding.

This is how one deals with curved/complex edges on molding planes, and works fantastic for square and skew blades as well.

Re: Grinding Woes

#7

The answer to your woes

Bill Tindall

How can anyone named Norton be having grinding problems!

Background: I have at best average hand skills so if I can achieve something about anyone can if they use an equivalent approach. All the following I find essential. I have been dong this procedure for several years.

1. I found the Lee Valley rest useless for the task at hand. It is frail and steel does not slide well on aluminum. I sold it.

2. Success will be at hand when get a large flat rest that is made of steel or anything steel slides easily upon. ( I use the Wolverine rest) And, you use a crowned wheel.

3. Use a side to side motion that I describe as "touch and go" like those practicing airplane landings. Never start off the edge or the wheel and then engage the wheel or rounding the edge will result unless your are better at this than I am. The touch must be in from the edge on the crown of the wheel, and then slide, and lighten up pressure while passing the trailing edge. Use an extraordinarily light touch. It might take me 2-3 min to touch up an edge because I am only removing tiny amounts per pass as a result of the light touch. Obviously the tool must slide easily to do this technique.

4. Use the original edge as a guide/target for the grinding progress and don't grind to this edge- EVER! as they say on MythBusters.

5. Once you have a nice hollow ground almost to the original edge, within 1/32" or so, stop and move to a diamond studded plate, fine or extra fine. Use this device to grind away the dull edge. Then proceed to a final honing with the abrasive of your choice. If you do grind to the edge and mess up straightness, then go to the plate, establish a straight edge and then go back to the grinder using the straight edge as a target.

6. resharpening can be done with the fine diamond plate untill most of the hollow is gone and then you take a trip back to the wheel.

Re: Grinding Woes

#8

Rest Idea??

Thomas Norton

So anyone have a pic of a homemade rest?

Re: Grinding Woes

#9

Re: Rest Idea??

Bill Tindall

I have seen them made from a piece of 2 or 2 1/2" angle iron. Just drill a hole in one side and bolt to grinder where the tool rest bolted on.

Re: Grinding Woes

#10

Re: Grinding Woes

FredD

I don't know if they are still made , but the best guide for grinding I have seen is one made by Delta and when I bought their grinder in the late sixties, I also got the guide that bolts on the grinder.

It is a piece of steel the size of your hand about 5/8ths thick and has a adjustable angle stop on it and the best feature is a Micrometer advance thumb wheel that lets you grind down to a burr edge and then I clean up on oil stones.

This jig eliminates a lot of unnecessary work and really all one needs to grind square or any other angle.

Free hand grinding is easily learned , one only need to practice and some shapes are only ground that way.

FredD

Re: Grinding Woes

#11

Re: Rest Idea??

Barry Irby

I made a home made rest that worked well. I don't have a picture but if you are interested I could take one. the rest is noting but a steel rod about 1/2 or 5/8" in diameter supported on a couple of posts across the front of the grinder. the rod sticks out past the grinder on both sides. The rod is as close to the wheels as you can get it. The grinder is a WoodCraft slow speed eight inch with white wheels.

You make clamps that are little more than two small rectangles ow Baltic birch or hardwood held together with bolts. You slip the plane iron or chisel between the side of the holders and tighten the bolts. You determine the angle of the grind by how far the tool stick through the holder and where it touches the wheel. You mount the tool square to the holder if you want a square edge. then you just slide the device back forth using a very light touch. If you have a grinder, the whole thing costs less than $20.

Take everything Bill said to heart even if you make one like this.

I also have a home made Wolverine rip off on the same machine for sharpening my lathe chisels. I actually use this much more than the one described above.

Re: Grinding Woes

#12

Re: Grinding Woes

Barry Irby

Fred, I have one of those Grinders I bought in 1971. The attachment on it is great for sharpening plane irons and charles. I have one of the Dewalt planers that has sharpenable blades. I clamp a steel rule in the grinder Jig (as a spacer and to extend the length of the rest.) and slide the blades back and forth and just barely snick a little metal off the edge. I have two sets and grind both sets at the same time to keep them matched. If I get a nick in a pair, I swap one of the blades out with the other set so that I don't have to grind the entire nick away. They may not be a pretty as the ones done by the pro's but they work very well and it costs me nothing, only takes a few minutes and I don't have to send them out and wait for them

Re: Grinding Woes

#13

Re: Grinding Woes

FredD

Sounds good to me Barry , BTW, is it hard to get Charles to stand still while your sharpening him ? Just wondered ....

FredD

Re: Grinding Woes

#14

Need spell check to check spell check

Barry Irby

>

Re: Grinding Woes

#15

Crowned Wheel

GolfSteve in Calgary

The crowned wheel is, in my opinion, very important. This gives you great control when initiating the grind (touching the steel to the wheel) and helps you avoid burning the corners of the iron.

As far as tool rests go, the Wolverine is the bees knees, and the Lee Valley version is a great idea that I think does not perform too well (too small, too flimsy, too sticky).

Get the Wolverine platform (around $99), true up and crown your wheel (mine is crowned about 1/64", not very much, just enough so that it cuts mostly in the centre of the wheel), and freehand grind; don't bother with any Wolverine accessories, the basic platform is all you need unless you're a turner.

When starting a cut, touch the centre of the iron to the centre of the wheel and move the iron left or right until you reach an edge, then pull the iron back. Repeat, starting at the centre or the iron again, and move in the other direction.

Occasionally check the iron with a square and adjust your grinding appropriately. I can grind until only a feather edge remains on the iron without any blue-ing.

When the iron starts to get hot, let it rest for a few seconds on the Wolverine jig and it will cool off. Take very light cuts and when your wheel isn't cutting very well, dress your wheel again.

On the hand holding the iron, rest your index finger against the bottom edge of the Wolverine platform to control movement of the iron into the wheel.

This is much harder to describe than to do. It really helps to have someone show this to you the first time.

Re: Grinding Woes

#16

Re: Rest Idea??

Tom MacGregor

I use this homemade jig on a Sears belt sander. A belt sander gives you a nice wide flat grinding surface, easy grit change & slower speed to prevent overheating the edge. Klingspor belts have smoother seams at half the price of Sears belts. I'll never go back to grinding wheels. I don't have to bother keeping it dressed flat, either. At today's avg. price of $110 this sander is cheaper than any dedicated motorized sharpener. Since this photo was taken I've attached a 1/8" thick ground flat steel plate to the sander under the belt. A simpler jig would probably be simple to make but even freehand this is easier and faster than a wheel. I've easily rebeveled dozens of used blades ready to hand hone a microbevel including some skewed ones.


img

Re: Grinding Woes

#17

Dale Lenz

Re: Rest Idea??

Dale Lenz

Tom: I've seen this type of jig before, Nice! I've often wonder how you square the iron up in the jig. Seems like you could skew the iron easily and keep from having a square end(?).

Re: Grinding Woes

#18

Re: Rest Idea??

Tom MacGregor

The jig is marked L & R so it's always placed on the sander exactly the same way. Before grinding any blades I ground the bottom of the holder - you can see the angle in the photo. That established a straight edge on the holder at an exact right angle to the belt movement to index blades. I can line the blade up and check it for square with a small engineer's square, and scribed several lines at 90 degrees on the jig to get it very close by eye. Once an old blade has been properly beveled it's easy to line it back up when a regrind is finally necessary. The critical construction detail was getting the rod as close to parallel to the belt as possible. Lateral adjustment has been coming out well within acceptable limits.

The thick rubber was already bonded to the aluminum when I got the scraps the jig was made from, but McMaster-Carr sells thin adhesive backed neoprene that works just as well. It keeps the blade from slipping. I've reground a very poorly beveled 3/16" thick plane blade in about 6 minutes with this thing starting with 50 grit, 80, 120, and at 220 ready to hone.

Re: Grinding Woes

#20

BTW.......

Bill Tindall

I used to buy 1" wheels thinking a wide flat wheel was the solution to my grinding woes. Now I dress away all but the center 3/8" by crowing. Duh! One can buy 1/2" wheels for surface grinders at any of the tool supply places-Enco, MSC, etc.) that are extraordinarily cheap and available in a huge variety of grits and bonds.

Re: Grinding Woes

#21

Disadvantages of belts

Bill Tindall

One can't argue with success and your clever arrangement works well and convenient. If one was starting with nothing it would be an excellent option. However, it doesn't make wheels obsolete for those that already have a grinder.

A properly selected wheel sheds its abrasive particles during use, thereby exposing new sharp particles. Or, if it is a SG wheel the particles additionally microfracture to expose fresh edges. Sharp grits mill shavings from the tool and the heat generated is largely ejected in the metal chip (that shower of sparks). Dulled abrasive particles plow as well as mill across the tool surface and plowing generates more heat that isn't ejected with a chip. Hence, a properly selected wheel will grind faster and cooler. Additionally, the wheel produces a hollow grind which enables faster edge refinement in the subsequent steps, especially if the subsequent steps are hand held (jigless).

I wish I had an attachment on my belt sander like yours for scraper blades.

Re: Grinding Woes

#22

David Barnett

You convinced me

David Barnett

I'll never go back to wide wheels. Ever since you recommended the narrow ones I've used them on my 7" Baldor and couldn't be happier. Besides the cost benefits and variety, it sure makes things easier for freehanding chisels. I also prefer them for grinding 1/4" tool bits for the Taig lathe. These days, I tend to use the original plain iron tool rests that came with my grinder, although I have aftermarket ones for some grinding tasks.