Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Tax questions -- workshop deduction

Posts

Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#1

A.J. Hamler

Tax questions -- workshop deduction

A.J. Hamler

For those of you using your shop professionally to some degree, I've got a couple of tax questions. Full disclosure: It's a miracle I can even do my own taxes at all. I'm fine with numbers and math, quite good in fact, but my brain crystallizes instantly by just putting a dollar sign in front of a number. Were it not for Turbo Tax Home & Business I simply couldn't do it.

Anyway... I've been deducting my home office for a number of years, so I'm familiar with the process of figuring square footage and coming up with a percentage and such. However, I've been venturing into tax-deduction land slowly and tentatively since becoming a full-time freelancer a few years ago, and have not until now considered deducting my shop. I'm thinking this year (meaning for figuring 2010 taxes) is the time to do it. To that end, I need your advise on these three questions:

1) What the heck do I call the shop? All the IRS and Turbo Tax stuff makes liberal use of "home office" as the overall term for this sort of thing. What's the terminology here?

2) My shop is in my garage, which is really no longer a garage. No car can enter the shop, nor has ever been able to enter it, since moving into our house seven years ago. Although nominally a garage, it's really a regular room of the house that just happens to have a wall on one side that you can lift up. It is a 100% dedicated shop space under the roof of my home. Of course, that space has never been included in the square footage of the house. To that end, when considering the space for tax purposes, will I need to add the shop square footage (about 440) to the house's square footage to come up with a new household square footage, and then subtract the shop (along with my home office) to do the tax deduction? I'm guessing the answer to this is a pretty obvious "yes," but I just wanted to be sure.

3) Do I then lump the two work spaces together as a single space for figuring deduction? That is, do I add the 120 sq ft of my office to the 440 sq ft of the shop for a single 560 sq ft of total household workspace?

That's it. I should note again that my shop is 100% geared toward my professional work. We store no household stuff in there that isn't also used for the shop. That wasn't true until two years ago -- we used to have lawnmower, bicycles, trashcans, hoses and all manner of regular household stuff in there, which is one reason I never explored a shop deduction before. I built a roomy shed summer-before-last and moved every last bit of general household stuff out there. The shop is now completely, totally a shop.

Thanks in advance.

A.J.

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#2

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

Frank Grambo

AJ I do volunteer taxes for the local dept of Aging. We don't do what you are asking about.I can only pass on the advice my former CPA gave me about 10 years ago when i was in yo.ur shoes. My shop was the 1500 sq ft basement .

His advice was forget it , you would just be asking for trouble with very little "reward". For what it is worth.

FG

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#3

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

Thomas S Stockton

My original tax person who was an auditor for the IRS said the same thing but for different reasons, she said it was a red flag and not worth it.

I would talk to a tax professional and get their advice.

Tom

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

Clint Searl

The use of the garage absolutely qualifies as a business expense. It doesn't matter that you call it "home office" on the 1040. Exclusive use in the business is what matters. Combine its space with that which you had been claiming, and figure the percentage of that total against the total of the garage plus the living space. Use that percentage to figure operating expenses and depreciation. The new basis for depreciation will be the original cost of the whole house plus improvements, broken out of the total cost of the property, or if less, the prorated market value of the house when first used in the business, minus depreciation already taken.

Clint

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

Moses Yoder

Do you live in an area zoned for commercial production? I thought about all the implications when I ran a business out of my garage shop and ended up not deducting anything other than fuel costs I had spent directly for heating my shop. My shop heater was a small kerosene heater completely seperate from the house so I had receipts to prove how much I had spent on fuel. The electricity to run a garage shop is not that much and if you don't have all your ducks in a row may end up costing you more to deduct than it will save you when the IRS comes along to check on your deductions.

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#6

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

Frank Orfanello

A.J.,

You have a lot to consider this year. Based on what you wrote, then you would add the garage square footage to the house square footage, then take the percentage of the house and garage that is used exclusively for business dived over the total.

Others have given you advice about "red flags" and risks. That is true, home office (or home based business) deductions are subject to more scrutiny however if you are really using the space for business and following the rules you are entitled to take a deduction for it.

As others have said, you really should seek a competent tax advisor. Lay out your facts and documentation and he/she will help you get all the deductions you are due.

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#7

Clint Searl

Forget the "TAX PROFESSIONAL"

Clint Searl

Between you and TurboTax, plus online access to all the IRS documents, doing an audit proof return for a sole proprietorship may take a couple hours, but but you don't need to be no stinkin' "professional." I did it for a home based business for fifteen years without ever being flagged for an audit.

Clint

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#8

Pigs get fat...

Mark Nowicki

...and hogs get slaughtered, according to my former accounting prof.

I am not a CPA, don't stay at a Holiday Inn, but I do have a business degree (I wanted to know how my enemy thinks), run my own business and do my own tax planning.

IMO, if you have not included the garage area in the past years, you have overstated your home office deduction and you owe the IRS some money. Voluntary disclosures are usually not subject to interest and penalties.

If you choose to declare the costs associated with the garage as a business expense, you should reset everything to zero and deal with that issue first.

One way to make the shop space a business expense is to pay rent. Depending on your business structure, AJ Inc. pays rent to AJ. AJ Inc. deducts rent, AJ claims rent as income. If your business structure is such that AJ pays AJ you are moving money from one pocket to another.

The other way is to increase your home office deduction and, perhaps in the future, convince an auditor that you never, never, never, really never do anything in the garage that is not business related.

In some tax jurisdictions, by claiming a portion of your home as a business expense, you forego the capital gain exemption that you might be entitled to.

You will have to keep track of the percentages, pay attention to changes in the inclusion rate and settle that bill when you sell, or when your beneficiaries inherit.

That bill will also include an amount for recapture of depreciation.

Incidentally that is why the so called "tax professionals" love home office deductions. It generates reams and reams of paper, and lots and lots of billable hours which very quicky eat up any tax savings.

Mark

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#9

Re: Forget the "TAX PROFESSIONAL"

Frank Grambo

Years ago...( the tax code has changed ) ....I had a friend that was the subject of a random home audit. They show up at "Honest Tom's " and went on in great detail. They finally got him because he claimed 2 courses that his wife had taken to keep her job as a school librarian. He was only allowed one..., pay the tax on 800$ please.

Today "Honest Tom", may have bought something on line and forgot about declaring the sales tax... The only folks that are truly in the clear have been dead a couple of years.

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#10

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

Steve Schoene

I think you open up a whole area of concern. Is the shop used in a business, or a "hobby business". Is it organized as a business. Is it operated with the motive of making profit. If it is a business, have you also deducted your other business expenses, materials, equipment, depreciation on machinery, etc. Have you kept business records, etc. Has it made profits. The irs has sometimes asserted businesses aren't really business if they don't actually earn a profit on occassion, but that is a rebuttable presumption. If it looks like a hobby, then hobby expenses can only be deducted to the extent of hobby income, so you need to be very business like in terms of records, etc. to be able to deduct losses.

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#11

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

Rick Christopherson

AJ, You're in a similar business situation that I am. Red flags come up for situations where people are not legitimately claiming a home office. That is not your situation, so you have far less to worry about. I've been doing the same thing for over 15 years, and what's worse is that my home office deduction has been 51% of the total of my home (basement extends under garage so its bigger than the house). On the first couple years of returns, I even included floor plan drawings to show the calculations.

The usage of my shop and office changes, so I have changed the allocation over the years. During a period where I was a W2 employee but still doing freelance work, I reduced the allocation accordingly, as I couldn't justify certain areas of the shop as business. Right now, even though I don't do as much woodworking, the shop is my primary photo studio. It's also the assembly area for the Multi-position Guide Stops I make for the Festool Domino Joiner.

I assume the fake chicken hanging on the cabinet behind you doesn't belong to Rockler, so that must be your garage shown in your sawblade article. Using your workshop for magazine photography qualifies it as a legitimate business deduction.

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#12

A.J. Hamler

Thanks!

A.J. Hamler

Thanks everybody. From what you've all said, I think I'm good to go with deducting it. Means more math with dollar signs -- ugh -- but that's what Turbo Tax for Mac is for.

Once I've gotten brave enough to actually sit down and do the taxes, I'll report back on how they turned out.

A.J.

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#13

A.J. Hamler

Fake!??

A.J. Hamler

That, my poultry-challenged friend, is no fake chicken. I'll have you know that chicken is finely crafted and molded of prime, 100% free-range rubber.

Re: Tax questions -- workshop deduction

#14

Re: Thanks!

Steve Schoene

A story about the home office deduction. An acquaintance recounted the story of how he deducted the expenses of maintaining his dog. Naturally challenged by the irs, the deduction was allowed after the irs agent's visit to the house for an audit meeting. The the dog would not let the agent into the office--growling, etc. This was told as a true story--and there wasn't even very much alcohol involved.