Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Got Walnut?

Posts

Got Walnut?

#1

Got Walnut?

David Yoho

I accepted a commission to build another fireplace surround and mantle recently. I needed to buy some walnut and cherry but when I got to the supplier here in VA yesterday he said they were almost out of 4/4 and 5/4. I went to look at what they had left and it was just enough. I bought the few remaining pieces they had. Since I haven't had a need for walnut in quite a while, I was unaware there was such a shortage.

I'm hearing they clear cut large tracts and sold the good stuff to China, leaving the smaller stuff that is mostly crap. When I asked when there might be some more available, the answer was maybe in three months - maybe longer. I was surprised to learn this and wonder how long before it turns around.

Looks like I won't be making much from walnut in the near future. Anyone else have information about what happened?

Re: Got Walnut?

#2

China is not the problem

Bill Tindall

I live in the heart of walnut country. At least two large walnut processing mills are located here. For reasons listed below the price has gone up and the quality down.

The problem with lumber quality is several fold.

1, Walnut is a rare tree. It is picky about where it will grow. If it is not growing in a place it prefers it will get out competed by oak, or poplar(in these parts). It prefers a deep soil where it can anchor its large tap root. Agriculture prefers this same kind of dirt. So walnut mostly is to be found on the margins of agriculture land and riparian soils. These more open environments often don't stimulate trees to shed limbs and yield tall straight trunks. "Deep woods" walnuts are rare as hens teeth because land that has been left to "deep woods" doesn't have deep dirt, or other favorable conditions.

2. Hardwood fashion swings from light to dark, and back. We have entered a dark phase. So demand has increased for walnut furniture, floors etc.

3. Veneer log buyers will pay more for a log than a mill that will saw it into lumber. Veneer mills are accepting smaller and more knotty logs now than in the past. This fact has likely had the largest impact on walnut lumber quality.

4. 1000 Canker disease has been found in Knox County TN. There is now a quarantine on the movement of walnut in this and surrounding counties, all counties where significant walnut is produced. This worrisome development bears close watching. It is the same sort of disease as Dutch Elm disease.

5. In your case your supplier is unwilling to pay what they would currently need to pay for walnut lumber. The problem is not shortage, but shortage at some price.

Re: Got Walnut?

#3

Re: Got Walnut?

Barry Irby

David I have about 4000 bf of walnut and a 1000 bf of cherry all nice and air dried in a barn in a top secret location. I foolishly had almost all of it sawed 4/4.

Wonder what a fair price is for local tree run walnut? I have made a number of pieces out of it and it is a very nice color.

The draw back is that some of it has some sort of insect (?) damage sort of like ambrosia. Some people really like it and some hate it. I ahve ben told that this is common in Virgina walnut and makes it commercially less atractive that that that comes for areas where this does not occur.

If you get in a bind, let me know.

Re: Got Walnut?

#4

Hey Bill, A question...

Barry Irby

In my post below I mention that my locally grown walnut (southside VA) has little insect (?) marks in it. There is a damaged/stained spot that sometime has two little snake bite punctures in it and then there is streaking along the grain. The mark is usually smaller than a dime and the streaks run about 2" or more each way. These are dark, approaching black. I see it as a defect, but my son likes it so, we share. Can you tell me what this is and is there any way to avoid it? I have some more trees growing and is there something I could treat them with to keep this out?

Re: Got Walnut?

#5

Re: Hey Bill, A question...

Bill Tindall

I don't know much about bugs. I have seen what are are talking about in TN walnut too. Suggest asking at county extension office or UVA dept of Forestry.

Re: Got Walnut?

#6

Thanks, Barry

David Yoho

Re: Got Walnut?

#7

Re: Got Walnut?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Locally, here in south-central Michigan, there is no shortage that I'm aware of. I bought 50 bf of kiln-dried this fall and had several 8' stacks to choose from. Bill's assessment is correct, around here walnut is a field tree. Most are from stands originally planted in the early-to-mid-20th century in the hope of a harvestable resource along roadways and fence lines. A lot were also planted as yard trees for their nuts or specimen trees in landscaping. My back acre (a soccer field being reclaimed by nature) has about 50 young trees, all planted by squirrels burying nuts from my neighbor's tree.