(Message Deleted by Poster)
Chuck Lenz
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Chuck Lenz
Re: Contractor's saws and the Delta 50-760 DC
Moses Yoder
In my experience 99% of people who use contractors saws don't care if they don't collect dust. I used a Delta contractors saw with a Jet 1100 dust collector for about 10 years. The only modification I made was putting a 1/4" ply bottom in the saw (attached to the frame right below the blade) and ran my dust hose right there. It collected 85% of the dust and I was happy.
Re: Contractor's saws and the Delta 50-760 DC
Henry (Raleigh, NC)
I too have a contractor's saw, but no dust collection capability. It's not that I don't care. I'm just not there in the evolution of my shop (YET!). That is likely the next upgrade, but it'll have to wait for employment and funds...
Until then, I am good terms with my half-face respirator, amazed at how well it works, and dying for the day when I collect dust at the source.
Henry
Re: Contractor's saws and the Delta 50-760 DC
Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ
I think what you have is a very nice product for an ill-defined market. Not all contractor saw owners are interested in dust collection. Haven't a clue how to separate out the ones who do. They would be the ones to target, of course.
The most important thing when selling a product is defining who wants to buy one (or more) as opposed to who SHOULD!
If you have a community college nearby that offers marketing classes, you may find them inexpensive to take and very helpful. BTDT-HTTS.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Chuck Lenz
Re: Contractor's saws and the Delta 50-760 DC
Barry Irby
I have an old Rockwell Delta Contractors saw and a 11/2HP Delta DC, but I don't know the model number. I suspect it is the one you are asking about. I have modified it to some extent. I also built a DC "port" for the TS. It is very effective, collecting about 95% of the dust.
I understand your frustration. I too have tried to market things and my services. My experience is that marketing is about 50% of the effort. You literally have to build in a significant factor for marketing/promotion. Even if you build a better mouse trap the world will not beat a path to your door.
I talked to a guy yesterday who just retired from a major tobacco company. He said each pack of cigarettes cost them about 20 cents and they make a profit of twenty cents. The rest of whatever people pay for them is profit down the chain and taxes. The government makes several times what they do off each pack. YOU can't build something for 20 cents and sell it for 4 to 8 dollars. That's a 20 to 40 times ratio. Most products don't carry that kind of markup.
What kind of things do people buy? Things they need and can't easily make for themselves. If I remember your modification (?) for the contractors saw, it looked a lot like a "Take Off" for duct work or perhaps an "End Boot". I can buy either of them for about 4 or 5 dollars. Your customers by virtue of the fact they are wood workers are handy and quite capable of cobbling together a take off and a piece of plywood. As much as I would like to help a fellow wood worker I am frugal (cheap) and would make my own. So I see your market as being pretty narrow. Wood workers who own contractors saws, who want dust collection, can afford your solution and are not willing to make their own.
Very well put
Clint Searl
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Chuck Lenz
Re: Contractor's saws and the Delta 50-760 DC
Barry Irby
I understand that your product is not an off the shelf piece of ductwork. The one I saw you were marketing trough a tool company, I think. If I am mixed up please forgive me. I only wish you well. If I had any advice that would help your make your million of even your thousand, I would give it to you. No skin off my nose, I ain't in that business. The product I saw happened to look a lot like a take off. I am not an Engineer or a physicist, but there was nothing about it that LOOKED superior to a take off. If this is not what you are selling, I apologize and I am talking out of a cocked hat.
If that is your product you need to find a way to make it LOOK superior. Roth's Cris is selling PRIME Beef and Making it SIZZLE. You got to sell the sizzle. I don't care what YOUR machines cost. That tobacco company has millions (billions?) of dollars worth of equipment to make those 20 cent a pack cigarettes. I don't smoke, but I am willing to bet that NO-ONE buys their product because they have fancy equipment. (Smokers speak up, do any of you buy any brand because they have the fanciest equipment?)
You have got to convince your customers that YOUR product sizzles, and does the job for them better than anybody else's and better than that on they could make themselves. Your problem is that that's called Branding and that is expensive to make happen. Especially in a narrow market.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Chuck Lenz
Fancy Equipment
David Yoho
I don't care what YOUR machines cost. That tobacco company has millions (billions?) of dollars worth of equipment to make those 20 cent a pack cigarettes. I don't smoke, but I am willing to bet that NO-ONE buys their product because they have fancy equipment.
Most people wouldn't know or, for that matter, care what the machinery was like as long as it's a product they want or need and can afford. In the case of your example, I know firsthand just how fancy those machines are and just what they can do. I can tell you they're light years ahead of what was used thirty years ago. The main and probably only reason machines of that caliber are in use there now is it is a major way to cut the cost per thousand to manufacture. Doing that does absolute wonders for anybody manufacturing and selling a product.
I operate a six axis robot that picks and loads much of the roll stock used out it the manufacturing floor. I can remember over five years ago when I was one of the ones doing that job. Now it takes just two robots to do the work more accurately and it costs less. Quite frankly, at this age I'm more than happy to be the driver instead of the mule.
Does all that fancy equipment influence which brand I choose? Nope!
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Chuck Lenz
Far from automated
David Yoho
Chuck, in your situation I think you're where you should be as far as manufacturing capability. No need spending the money for automation and the like without first having a big enough demand for the product.
In fact, building your product the way you do now is the smart thing to do. This allows your personal touch on each one and insures the quality is what it should be. It might end up that even though you have a great product, the demand for it may not be. It sounds and looks (from the photos) like your product and ideas have a lot of merit and work more efficient than what's been available.
If your product isn't selling off the shelf, there are two reasons to look at. One would be that folks that would use your product simply don't know it exists. The other would be like what I've experienced. I've seen many times when I saw a product but didn't buy it because I wasn't aware of its real benefits or how it might make my life easier. However, when I'd seen it demonstrated at a show and had a better understanding of it, many times I bought.
So, again, I think the success of your specific products could be dependent on coming up with a good marketing strategy. Can you see yourself at places like woodworking shows spending many hours in a booth showing off your products and how they're better? Only you can decide what price you're willing to pay to give your idea the best chance for success.
Re: Contractor's saws and the Delta 50-760 DC
Barry Irby
Chuck, here is a picture of a 4" take-off I used as a pickup on my jointer. It fit the opening so closely I did not have to modify it at all. (An omen?) They are available in 5" & 6". I understand they are no as heavy duty or custom made like your part, but when I see a pick up for a TS or any other tool, my brain starts to analyse it and wonder what makes it better than something I could invent or repurpose? How much does this cost? Can I make one? Would mine be as good/better? On and on.

This is essentially 100% effective. The dust in the pic is form me routing dovetails without ANY dust pick up nearby. And yes, that jointer base could stand a coat of paint.
When I got to my TS I considered a unit sort of like yours. I cobbled one up. I closed off the back of the saw as best I could. I bought brushes to help close off the back. I tried to buy those "hula" skirts you see on tractor trailers. what I ended up with is a flat duct or box that is mounted where the original dust chute on the machine was. Its angled at the top so the saw can swing a full 45 degrees. Its hinged at the bottom so the saw can swing. at eh bottom is and end boot that brings the duct out the front. Why? So the blast gate is right below the switch. To use the saw I reach down and open the gate, turning on the DC and flip the switch on the saw. This was important to me because I sue the Long Ranger blast gates and not a remote. (My DC is outside the shop and I was not sure the remote would work through a wall) Unlike the take off on the jointer that I just slapped on there, this was really tough to build. I made two cardboard mock up and still trashed the first metal version. This would have been a lot more fun if I had your sheet metal tools and skills.

If all the TS's were Identical you could make up a contraption like mine and sell it. It's not like anything else on the market. May be completely unique. (Its fine with me if you would like to use the idea.) Obviously, all the saws are not Identical, so you would have to build different units. Very tedious. but it looks like something the average wood worker would not even take a shot at, and it LOOKS like it would do a superior job. I don't know if it is actually superior or not. I don't have anything to compare it to. I can tell you this. I had to rip a bunch of stickers for lumber I wanted to stack and I ran the DC while doing it. I soon realized it was throwing a little spew off the top of the blade. I learned to stand to the side and let it fall on the floor. I filled two thirty gallon DC bags and got about a shoe box full of stuff from around the saw. And, an over the blade pickup would have gotten 90% of that, but I have such a small shop I don't want one in my way. (my perception is it would be in my way) Not willing to give up the space for the slight improvement in performance.
Re: I should of never come back here
Chuck Lenz
Barry writes : your modification (?) for the contractors saw, it looked a lot like a "Take Off" for duct work or perhaps an "End Boot". I can buy either of them for about 4 or 5 dollars. ( Then Clint chears him on. ) Thankyou to the rest of you that didn't feel a need to belittle what I worked so very hard on for so long. Goodbye.