Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

Posts

Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

#1

Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

Barry Irby

I need 1x2 strips to use as battens on my son's house. I have a lot of poplar. Is it durable enough for this? It will be painted. How about if I threat it with Bora Care?

Re: Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

#2

No, no and no!

Bill Tindall

Unless it is heartwood. The sapwood soaks up and retains moisture and rots while you are watching it, even painted. Don't ask how I know this to be absolutely true.

Re: Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

#3

Painted??? I don't know.

Basil

Painted??? I don't know.

But mounted vertically, not painted and not touching the ground some barns have 100+ year old poplar siding.

I would use something else if I could find it.

Re: Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

#4

Re: Painted??? Still no......

Bill Tindall

if it is sap wood. Indeed, the heart wood from old growth trees is rot resistant and I have experienced no problems with it painted in outdoor trim applications.

Re: Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

#5

Hemlock is bettergh?

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Hemlock was used for years as barn siding. Some barns are over 100 years old with the original siding.

Lee

Re: Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

#6

Re: Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

FredD

Western Red Cedar has been the best wood for that application, with a resawn or rough sawn surface.

FredD

Re: Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

#7

Re: Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

Barry Irby

Fred, which end of the country are you in? Here in the east the Western Red Cedar we get if so knotty it is very difficult to get a 9' long furring strip out of it. The huge majority of them would fall apart. I am given to understand they keep the good stuff on the west coast and ship us the crap. It would be perfect for them if I could get some that was clear at a reasonable price.

Re: Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

#8

Re: Is poplar weather resistant Enough?

FredD

Barry , I am in the middle , Abilene , Kansas and any lumber yard around here carries Cedar for outside trim.

Presumably you would pick the stuff, I certainly do. You can get it from really knotty to clear , depending on your tastes.

FredD