Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

OT - GPS revisited

Posts

OT - GPS revisited

#1

OT - GPS revisited

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

It is time for me to buy a new GPS. Conventional wisdom pits the TomTom and the Garmin. Price is within $20 - not an issue. The TomTom I looked at had a colored display - lots of yellowish-orange. The Garmin has a 'whiter' display.

Those who have them, please tell me about the clarity of the display both in daylight and night time driving situations. We older folks look for clarity on displays in any light. :)

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#2

Returned my TomTom

Henry Higginbotham

My Garmin Nuvi 660 suddenly went stupid and couldn't find any satellites, even after all manner of resets and "secret" reboots and such. So I bought a TomTom at Costco.

As you noticed, the TomTom display isn't nearly as good as it needs to be. Especially in bright sunlight, it took too long for me to find information on the screen. There were several other features I didn't like, too, but like most things it had its good points.

I wish someone made a really good road-navigation GPS with tracklogs and PC map software (sometimes I want GPS to tell me where I've been, rather than how to get there). There are several other items on my wish list that I'm apparently never going to find, but they DON'T include MP3 players, photo viewers, gas mileage calculators, something to tell me what time it is in Berzerkistan, etc.

Sorry I'm not more help.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#3

Re: OT - GPS revisited

Joe Pack

My old eyes prefer the Garmin. Along with a number of old, retired guys, I drive cars for area dealers to/from auctions, dealer trades, etc. Most of us use GPS. The breakdown is about 30% TomTom, 65% Garmin (255w seems to be preferred), with a couple of others tossed in.

One feature I like on the Garmin is that it switches from daylight to dark mode automatically while the TomToms my buddies have do not (may vary w/model).

If you do get a gps and plan to use it in multiple cars, by all means find a weighted dash mount base for it. Plus, you can easily take it off the dash and place it on the floor out of sight when you leave the car. Garmin makes one specific to their models, including a "neck" that fits the GPS; no suction cups required. Radio shack makes a universal "purse" style than serves as both a case and dash mount.

Enjoy! I love my gps.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#4

Re: OT - GPS revisited

Barry Irby

I have a Garmin Nuvi and I like it. The display is cartoonish but easy to see day and night. I have never even seen a Tomtom other than in the store. My only complaint with the Nuvi is I nearly run over those people standing on the side of the road because they don't show up on the Garmin. :)

Actually I do have a few small complaints. One, it lead me astray, sending me through a local town on the way to the interstate when I was already in site of an on ramp. (I posted a question here about it and learned how to preview the trip. Touch the route info at the top of the screen.) I also find it strange that it says things like Drive 5.3 miles on I95 and bear left to stay on I95 and and so on. and I wish it would learn to say Leave your neighborhood and turn right on Rt. 10. I know how to get out of the neighborhood.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#5

Re: Returned my TomTom

Barry Irby

Henry, my Garmin Nuvi has a feature that I think they call Tracking or some such thing and it puts a pale blue line on the screen as you drive. I played with it and sometimes its handy if you drive to a strange place, you can turn around and follow the blue line back. I suspect might be for tracking your teenagers or people you loan the car to. Not sure.

Added to the complaints I listed below I would add that eh documentation is really poor. I have a very hard time finding out what features are there and how to use them. At down times when I am waiting in the car I play with it and try to fumble through the menus. I do not find some of the things to obvious, easy, or user friendly, but then I am old enough to actually have a drivers license.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#6

Re: OT - GPS revisited

paul in AZ

My input is a year or two old but I started with a Tom Tom. I returned it quickly in part because it was too irritatingly 'twitchy' [telling me to turn if the road bent a bit] and partly from reports that it's mapping for US roads isn't as good as Garmin's. Of course in the PHX area there are enough new roads in the peripheral valley that either machine will have gaps. The screen was OK although I like Garmin's better at night.

I got the wider screen -?4 maybe 5 inch?- Garmin and have had no complaints at all with performance.

As mentioned it has a very readable display that automatically switches day/night modes. The wider screen is really nice.

I also recommend getting the dashboard beanbag mount. The windshield suction cup didn't hold very well and I can now easily put the entire thing away leaving no burglar-tempting evidence of a GPS in the car.

it may be different now but I found that Costco sold an older model and that the newest Garmin iteration was available on line for a bit less $.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#7

Re: OT - GPS revisited

Howard Norman

Carol, I have a Garmin Nuvi. It is not perfect but if I lost it I would buy another one ASAP. I like the fact that it turns from daylight to night time vision automatically.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#8

Re: OT - GPS revisited

john lucas

Carol My dad gave me a Magellan for Christmas. The display is bright and very easy to see. It changes to a black back ground after sunset so it's not as distracting. I find it hard to use but I'm not a computer person at all. It came with no literature whatsoever and I haven't found any online. Up until today it's worked fine. For some reason today I had me get off the interstate at an exit and then take the entrance ramp to get right back on. I would have ignored it except I had programmed in a store that I did not know where it was. I mistakenly took the machines advice. It also had me take a left at the last stoplight and put me one block east of the actual store. This makes me wonder how good these things actually are. I would not travel without a map after this incident.

I'll be traveling several times in the next month so I'll give it some more tries.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re:I actually prefer the Garmin display.......

Jesper, Denmark

For it's clarity and simplicity. I have had several and still use one for rental cars when travelling abroad.

However, that age thing has caught up with me too. it get's more difficult to change focus from the road to the GPS and back. The solution for me was a bult-in GPS with a 7 inch screen and integration into the car's information system. The car is a Skoda Yeti - not available in Morth america, but it is the same unit used in all VW models.

I leave the main display on a scale that gives an overview of the route for the next 30 minutes or so. Detailed instructions for the next "move" come by voice AND in the display window between the RPM and speed dials, just in front of your nose - not somewhere on the windscreen. the dispaly in the dash is very simple and clear, so you almost see it automatically, withot having to take your attention off the road.

it also integrates with a hands free mobile phne via bluetooth and the car's speakers, has a 30 Gbit hard disk and plays MP3 from an SD disk.

It is not the most inexpensive solution, and it is difficult to retrofit, but works very well.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#10

Lee Gordon

Re: OT - GPS revisited

Lee Gordon

A number of people have mentioned the Garmin changing automatically from daytime to nighttime display mode. I have a TomTom XL340-S (a slightly older model) and it also changes from day to night automatically or gives you the option to stay in nighttime mode all the time.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#11

Your Maps are out of date

Dustmaker Mike

it sounds like your maps are out of date. My old Garmin did the same thing before it was srtolen last fall. My wifes does it also she has a Nuvi 350. I know I have to update the maps on hers they are over 4 years old.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#12

Garmin

Dustmaker Mike

Carol I have a Nuvi 1690 with Traffic, local gas prices, movie times etc... I like it alot I had to replace a Nuvi 360 that was stolen from me last fall. I went and paid for the Lifetime maps update so I don't have to worry about having them out of date again. The local traffic or traffic along the route is a pretty good idea, but this morning on my way to work it showed the traffic as stopped and I was doing 65MPH. So I take it with a grain of salt. I got mine from Amazon as a refurbished unit. I have used the Tom Tom and did not like the interface the one I used would just say you have reached your destination but not say which side it was on. The Garmin says on the right or left. The big thing I would say is get the life time map up date and keep them up to date and you will be happy with either one.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#13

Re: OT - GPS revisited - Garmin it is

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

I have chosen the Garmin Nuvi 1450LMT. With a bean bag from Amazon. Costs about the same as a lesser model from Walmart locally. It has the life time map update option. It also has the 5" screen, which was a big factor for me. We'll see how it goes. Thanks, folks.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#14

Garmin recommendation

Bill Tindall

I have a very low tolerance for electronic complexity and lack of intuitiveness. I hate my Garmin eTREX hand held GPS for all these reasons.

However, we have a Garmin wide screen NUVI which I use occasionally on trips and I fine it easy to use and useful. I bought it on Amazon for less than $100.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#15

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Garmin

Jesper, Denmark

The traffic awarning difficulties are a worldwide problem. The agancies that post the information of traffic difficulties simply do not remove the warning quickly after the problem has gone away.

Re: OT - GPS revisited

#16

Garmin Nuvi

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

We have a Garmin Nuvi 760 which has a FM transmitter built in and blue tooth. I can pop in a 2 Gb SD memory card and play 12+ hours of my music and get travel directions via an unused FM channel on the car radio, so we can move it from vehicle to vehicle. It has worked well for over 5 years.

If you have local knowledge of roads and routes you can beat the "fastest" route in many instances, but if you aren't familiar with where you are going it will get you there. The blue tooth interface was flakey with my Motorola Q, but has worked very well with my blackberry. Get the lifetime map update. We don't have the traffic update anymore because it isn't applicable for the area where we live and normally travel.

As far as dislikes, a minor annoyance is that it doesn't always pick the fastest route as it doesn't account for stop signs and traffic lights. It also doesn't always take you back the same way it brought you, which can make drives a bit more interesting.

Lee