Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

I'm not chuck-ling

Posts

I'm not chuck-ling

#1

I'm not chuck-ling

Herb Yost

I have a Powermatic 2800 drill press, which is pretty nice in every way but one......the chuck. With any large bit, one of two things (sometimes both) is bound to happen. #1, the chuck will fall off while drilling, and/or #2, after drilling with a large Forstner bit, I will nearly always have to use two pipe wrenches to loosen the chuck before I can turn it by hand to release the jaws.

ANy suggestions for alternatives? Jacobs chucks? Links?

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

#2

Suggestions

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

"86" the keyless chuck in favor of a good 1/2" Jake with key.

You should be checking your Morse tapers (M & F) to find out why they're not seating properly. You may need to clean them as dirt or wood shavings will prevent a good set. Make sure that you remove any bumps, galls, or burrs in both to get a properly "stuck" fit.

m

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Also...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...if you're having problems removing the bits, make sure you're NOT seating them all the way in the chuck when you tighten the chuck. Think about it--when you turn the chuck to loosen the jaws, they're pulling inward on the bit. If there's enough friction and contact area between the jaws and bit, and the bit is fully seated, you won't get that bit out. If the bit isn't bottomed out, the jaws can pull the bit in a little before they disengage enough to release the bit.

Jason

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

#4

craigd

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

craigd

Sounds like a mismatch in the chuck back taper and the arbor. Or there is a side load (eg the big drill catches an edge and moves to the side as it starts to drill). If that is the case, try a bigger pilot hole. If not, arbors are cheap (I think I got one for $6 from Enco). The Enco branded Phase II keyless chucks are very nice (nicer than my Jacobs) and cheap - I think I got a 1/8-5/8 and 0-1/2 for under $50 & $40 (on sale). I've set the chuck in my drill press with a dead blow hammer when it has annoyed me and, surprisingly, it doesn't seem to have harmed it.

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

#5

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

john lucas

I love my keyless chucks for my lathe. I do not like them for a drill press. It takes 2 hands to release the drill bit which promptly falls through the table hole to the floor. I also don't think they hold as well as keyed chucks. I agree with Mark. Get a keyed chuck. Clean the morse taper well and then tap it with a dead blow hammer after inserting it.

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

#6

craigd

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

craigd

Hmmm, not my experience (I have keyless on my drill press, lathe and mill). While they suck for tapping, I haven't had the takes-two-hands-to-release problem.

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

#7

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

Dave Paine

I have a Powermatic 2800 VS drill press. Not sure if this is the same as yours. Mine has a 5/8in keyless chuck. I think this is Jacobs.

So far I have only tried up to about 3/4in forstner style. I have not experienced the taper coming looses or the chuck failing to release by hand.

I normally tighten by hand, not too tight, and have not experienced any spinning in the chuck.

As another reply stated, ensure the taper is clean. You may need to re-lap the two together.

I may try a test cut with my largest forstner style bit to see if I have any future problems in store.

Re: I'm not chuck-ling

#8

I switched and don't regret it.

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I switched from a non-name key chuck to a Jacobs key chuck on my old Homecraft DP and don't regret it. I've never had a bit come loose in my keyed chuck. I have had bits loosen in my Dewalt cordless with a hand chuck.

Clean the taper (M&F) and remove any oil or grease from them. When seating the chuck open the jaws all the way and them press the chuck down hard on a block of hardwood with the quill handle.

Lee