Re: reversibility myths of yellow glue
TomD
On more strike against Franklin technical. Have you ever asked them during your discussions what their practical experience was?
Just kidding some fair points there, and some interesting stuff. That said, it is true you can reverse hide glue in far more useful ways that you can yellow. To say you can't reverse yellow is not true. People do it all the time in guitar repair. But there are degrees. Like if you hammer veneered some veneer, and then noticed a bubble, you could just hit it with an iron and rub it out. It's instant, no need to clean or refresh. Can even be done decades later. If a dowel were to fail you can yank it out and reglue it without cleaning it. The Frankin guys' prognostication notwithstanding nobody trusts yellow glue in that way. You can wick alcohol into joints and it will break hide glue, which can be useful.
Even titebond 1 highly regarded in guitar circles will creep under bridge pressure and nobody would trust it to reglue unless bare surfaces were exposed. That said you would want a clean surface on the hide glue bridge also, but you could probably get away with less, it just wouldn't look good.
So hot hide glue retains the crown for stronger bonds, greater flexibility in regluing, and greater ease where cleaning is at issue. Only issue is whether the job needs it.
Dropping back into the guitar world after a considerable absence, I notice enthusiasim for fish glue. Gotta give that a try.
I have a bed that needs a similar repair, and I will probably scarf with WEST epoxy.