Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

Posts

yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#1

yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

DizD

I am replacing the top 4" of a spindle in a chair back (one of 4) thats about 5/8" diameter. I have turned a new part and cut a scarf joint with a backsaw and now it's ready to glue up. I believe I can do a rub joint, but don't know which glue would give the strongest joint. I feel like some gap filling capability would be beneficial, given that the joint is cut by hand. Anybody BTDT?

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#2

David Barnett

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

David Barnett

For a rub joint, you want the glue to set up fairly quickly and to draw the surfaces tighter as it gels. For this you'd need hot hide glue. Gap filling just isn't a part of well-executed rub joints, and if if epoxy set up quickly enough, don't expect it to draw surfaces together and to produce that thinnest of glue lines. There are things one can do with yellow glues that involve application, drying and applying heat that have rubbed joint properties, but mostly on veneered surfaces. I'd not recommend a rubbed joint on anything you feel might benefit from gap filling properties. Maybe epoxy with an additive and light holding or clamping to avoid squeezeout.

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#3

Stephen Shepherd

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

Stephen Shepherd

You are doing a repair/replacement job so use hide glue.

You are repairing furniture so use hide glue.

In the future someone else may have to do the repair again, so hide glue is the best choice.

Hide glue is the only choice.

Stephen

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#4

yellow glue rub joints and a clamp suggestion

Bill Tindall

I have been making "temporary" joints with yellow glue (adding a "foot" to a tall piece to aid keeping it perpendicular to the saw table whilst band sawing it).

To my astonishment a yellow glue rub joint where the contact is good will pull nearly 100% of the wood fibers from one side of the joint (near 100% wood failure) after only 30 min of set time at 60 degrees shop temp.

Where there is poor contact there is 0% wood failure under these conditions.

An excellent "clamp" for your task is anything stretchy- rubber band, section of inner tube, rubber tubing, Ace bandage, etc. Each turn added additional pressure and many turns applies boggling pressure to irregular shaped joints.

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#5

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

FredD

Exactly.

FredD

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#6

David Barnett

Although I don't disagree with your answer...

David Barnett

... and far be it from me to argue against hide glue for reversibility, but the original poster did ask about (a) rub joints, which glue would give (b) the strongest joint, and about (c) gap filling, all which you ignored, Stephen.

I certainly believe that a tight-fitting joint held with hide glue is the better course, and that reversability overrides all competing factors, but perhaps you could address his other issues and concerns. As he asks about gap filling, his joint may lack the fit necessary to form a strong and secure bond. And you didn't speak to the viability of the rubbed joint at all.

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#7

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Although I don't disagree with your answer...

Stephen Shepherd

'... and far be it from me to argue against hide glue for reversibility, but the original poster did ask about (a) rub joints, which glue would give (b) the strongest joint, and about (c) gap filling, all which you ignored, Stephen'

I will deal with the first part of your question with the following response:

(a) hide glue gives the best rub joint, either hot hide glue, liquid hide glue or fish glue.

(b) Hide glue will give one of the strongest glue joints around, ever so slightly less than modern poxies in terms of strength, shear, peel, etc.

(c) hide glue has moderate gap filling capabilities on its own, but can be thickened with wood or bone flour to improve its gap filling properties.

As for the second part of your question, see above.

Stephen

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#8

reversibility myths of yellow glue

Bill Tindall

I accepted the myth that "yellow" type glues are not reversible until I attended a class taught by a furniture repair/conservator who stated matter of factly that he found no significant difference in taking apart a joint assembled with yellow or hide glue. Having only heard about the irreversibility of yellow glue this statement intrigued me. So I disassembled a mortise and tenon joint prepared with yellow glue, according to the procedure advocated for hide glue. In short order the joint disassembled. Indeed, one will find that warm water dissolves cured yellow glue readily, so it is little wonder that steam in a joint will have the same effect.

Yellow glue is formulated to mimic the desirable reversible/irreversible properties of hide glue. At high temperature and/or moisture the glue is soft. At low temperature and moisture a reversible bond forms between the yellow glue molecules and the glue becomes rigid (as reported by the Franklin chemist). Indeed, the properties I observe are consistent with this claim.

Then I had the opportunity to ask a chemist from Franklin whether yellow glue would stick to itself, and important element in reassembly. He claimed it would, but that it could take a while for such a joint to cure due to the slow diffusion of water through the cured side of the joint. Testing this claim is not trivial and I have not come up with a reliable means of doing so.

There is no inherent reason yellow glue can't stick to itself. All that is required is for the glue molecules at the interface to soften and entangle. The solvent system in yellow glue could accomplish the softening.

Liquid hide glue has one outstanding attribute no one disputes. It has the longest open working time of the commonly used wood adhesives. I have not seen data, nor confirmed by my experience, the other claims made for hide glue.

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#9

Re: reversibility myths of yellow glue

TomD

On more strike against Franklin technical. Have you ever asked them during your discussions what their practical experience was?

Just kidding some fair points there, and some interesting stuff. That said, it is true you can reverse hide glue in far more useful ways that you can yellow. To say you can't reverse yellow is not true. People do it all the time in guitar repair. But there are degrees. Like if you hammer veneered some veneer, and then noticed a bubble, you could just hit it with an iron and rub it out. It's instant, no need to clean or refresh. Can even be done decades later. If a dowel were to fail you can yank it out and reglue it without cleaning it. The Frankin guys' prognostication notwithstanding nobody trusts yellow glue in that way. You can wick alcohol into joints and it will break hide glue, which can be useful.

Even titebond 1 highly regarded in guitar circles will creep under bridge pressure and nobody would trust it to reglue unless bare surfaces were exposed. That said you would want a clean surface on the hide glue bridge also, but you could probably get away with less, it just wouldn't look good.

So hot hide glue retains the crown for stronger bonds, greater flexibility in regluing, and greater ease where cleaning is at issue. Only issue is whether the job needs it.

Dropping back into the guitar world after a considerable absence, I notice enthusiasim for fish glue. Gotta give that a try.

I have a bed that needs a similar repair, and I will probably scarf with WEST epoxy.

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#10

Re: yellow glue rub joints and a clamp suggestion

TomD

"I have been making "temporary" joints with yellow glue (adding a "foot" to a tall piece to aid keeping it perpendicular to the saw table whilst band sawing it).

To my astonishment a yellow glue rub joint where the contact is good will pull nearly 100% of the wood fibers from one side of the joint (near 100% wood failure) after only 30 min of set time at 60 degrees shop temp."

most of the guts of guitars I have built were done that way. I do the bookmatch on the front and back with Titebond regular, just rub the two sides together, and leave. Same thing with the braces. The joint gets tighter as it dries and is so completely invisible I have sometimes lost the centerline.

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#11

OK - some useful info

DizD

Several good points to consider - I'm leaning toward hot hide glue and I appreciate the comments about hot vs liquid hide glue. I'm betting on the fact that this spindle, once in place, will have little concentrated stress, being one of five ( I lied about the number earlier.)

This is one of those cases where I will be repairing the wood itself, and not a manufactured "joint." In this case reversibility has zero consideration - if it breaks again someone will have to make a new wood part like I'm doing. I find this to be true in a number of instances in furniture repair.

Interesting comments about yellow glue adhesion also. I've become a beliver that It will form a rather strong bond to a itself as well as other surfaces. When I built my shop I put epoxy coating on concrete and after a year or so wound up with yellow glue drops in a place or two. I figured, no problem I'll just pop them off with a putty knife. After a few agressive scrapes I was getting the glue up, but it turned out the glue didn't give and the epoxy paint didn't give - the concrete bond failed- I now have a number of small concrete divots in the floor.

Thanks all for sharing your thoughts.

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#12

Re: OK - some useful info

John Lucas

Nobody has discussed epoxy. OK it won't do a rub joint it has to be held in position someway but it is an excellent gap filler. It bonds to itself and with heat it is reversible. I do repairs like you are talking about but I drill slightly oversized dowel holes as close to center as I can. I use short pieces of all-thread as my dowels. I put epoxy in the holes insert the dowels and the put the joint together and clamp it with blue painters tape. It's not an invisible joint but if you cut it carefully it's really tiny and doesn't show very well. You can color the epoxy if needed, you can thicken it to keep it from running. It has a lot of good uses.

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#13

May be a stupid question,

John E in SC

But what's a rub joint? Never heard that terminology before.

Thanks.

John

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#14

look here  *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

The link is to a wiki about animal glues. Rub joints are discussed there. Basically, it is putting on glue then just rubbing the two pieces together with no clamps.


Animal glue/rub joints

Re: yellow glue, hide glue, or epoxy?

#15

Re: OK - some useful info

DizD

Epoxy is high on my list for wood repairs (not joints). Glad to see someone else feels this way.