Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

BreadBoard End Protocol

Posts

BreadBoard End Protocol

#1

Alan Young

BreadBoard End Protocol

Alan Young

I am building a farmhouse styled table. The top will be 72" long and 36" with breadboard ends. My material is 5/4 clear cut pine-each board is 9"" wide.


My layout plan is for a bread board cap with hidden tenons. The tenon and matching mortise is 1/2" thick. The cap is 4" wide with the tenon 1.75" long. The outside boards will have the tenon haunched in 1.5"- the matching mortise on the cap is in 1' allowing a 1/2' on each end for movement.


My understanding is that normal pinning/gluing would have one dowel fully pinned and glued in the center and two outer dowels-pinned but not glued-in elongated holes. I'd like to have two dowels close to the center-glued and pinned-spaced 2" apart...


Is this sequence going to work?

-Alan

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#2

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Looks pretty good to me and very ample room for movement. I'd probably add another set of through pins between the outer ones and the center ones.

T.

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

Moses Yoder

It looks pretty good but your tenon does not have to be the full 1-3/4" long all the way across. You can notch the areas between the tenons to about 1/2" long, making it a lot less work because less wood has to be removed to put the mortice in the end cap.

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#4

Fine But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

With a bread board 1-1/2", I'd go at least 3/4" , if not a full inch on the M&T. 1/2" is, in my view, too short for strength in this application. I'd want more table meat inside the bread board to increase its down-shear strength. Would also give you room to put in a second set of pegs.

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#5

I agree with this

Bruce, a MN Galoot

if for no other reason than that when you're putting a dowel into an embedded tenon, 1/2" isn't much meat to drill into. That plus it would be pretty darn easy to lever the breadboard end right off the tenon.

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#6

Or

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Split it in the attempt. ;)

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#7

Alan Young

I think my numbers are too small to read..

Alan Young

Mark-Do you mean 3/4" for the length of the tenon or the thickness?

At this point the tenon is 1 3/4" long and 1/2 thick.


Moses is suggesting shortening it between the pinned sections....


or


Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#8

Re: I think my eyes are too fast

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

as I read your original post to have your tenon 1/2" in length into the 1-1/2" wide breadboard.

1/2" thick is fine for stock up to 7/8". If yout top is over an inch thick, I'd go to 3/4".

Yes you can do as Moses suggests (I've done so and it saves some work), but I'd use at least three of the long tenons and have their combined width be not less than 1/2 the width of the table. I've done several breadboard tables, and while it is a pain to cut those deep mortises, each table is still as solid as when I made them after years of use.

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#9

Disagree...

John in NM

In my experience, the weak spot will be the long grain on the bb end, not the end grain on the tenon. With a 1 3/4" tenon, it will be plenty strong even at less than 1/2" and I would be more concerned with the strength of the bb end if someone were to lean hard on it. Especially using pine, I tend to try to keep 2/3 or a little less of the material around the mortise - 1/3 or so either side, tending to round the mortise width up to the easiest available size. So if your bb end were a full 1 1/2" down to say 1 1/4", I would use the 1/2" tenon. If it's thinner than that I would make the tenon thinner.

All that said, this sort of thing is more of a concern elsewhere in construction, bb ends just don't see a lot of torque :D Someone parking themselves on it at a party is about the only case I can think of where what you have pictured would likely break. If you don't throw parties or have kids, nothing to worry about :D

As to the dowel layout, what is pictured will work fine.

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#10

Ooops....

John in NM

Hey Mark, better dis-regard all my dis-agreeing down there.... now it makes sense :D

Working nights and just got up... :\

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#11

Clint Searl

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

Clint Searl

The tenons are way overkill and prone to misalignment over the 72". Just edge glue with 4 or 5 loose biscuits spaced over the length for registration. Eliminate the breadboard ends, as likely seasonal movement will always make them either too long or too short, except for the three days a year when they are just right.

Clint

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#12

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

Jesse Cloud

The design has more than ample room for movement. I built a breadboard table a couple of years ago that was 40 inches wide. Here in the desert we go from bone dry (2 per cent humidity) in the winter to darn near saturated in the summer when we run the swamp cooler. Total movement on each side is 1/4 inch. The table is made from maple.

If the difference in width between the table and the end that Clint mentions bugs you, look at Greene and Greene tables. They used a decorative spline on the end of the breadboard that disguises the offset somewhat.

One piece of advice, and don't ask me how I know that, is that if you are using a film finish such as varnish, finish the board separately from the table. If you don't the film will break and crinkle first time the wood moves. :\

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#13

Shoulder plane.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

It's a long tenon so fitting the mortises first time out is doubtful. Have a shoulder plane on hand and it will make quick work for adjusting the tenon for fit.

T.

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#14

Re: Joint

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Jessie,

What I did, and works is the finish as one piece but after an hour or so (depending on the finish) while the coating is sort of "leather hard", take a fresh single edge razor blade at a low angle and carefully slice the film. Even easier to do if the edges of the joint have been chamfered. As the finish film dries/cures, the cut will widen just a hair. If you rub out your finishes as I do, the edges of the cut will soften just enough. No crinkling or chipping when it moves. :)

m

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#15

Look again,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Mark he has a 1.75" tenon going into a 4" BB end.

One thing the Green brothers taught us, is to plan for the inevitable fact that the top planks are likely not going to stay the same width as the length of the BB ends, so don't leave sharp edges, and know your starting MC, and expected EMC, and think about how you want it to look when it isn't like how you started.,

For instance, if you are using Air Dried, you might expect the top planks to end up 1/2" less than now.

Another way is to not edge glue the planks, so the gap between boards is part of the plan, dividing it into 4 ~ 1/8" gaps.

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#16

Ellis Walentine

Agree with Moses

Ellis Walentine

Your second-last drawing is the way I would approach it, Alan, with a 1/2" long tongue between tenons. I customarily make five tenons on a top this width. And, in your drawing, the slot width is longer than necessary.

Here's how I design for expansion and contraction. The average MC swing from summer to winter in North America (except the coasts and the deserts), is between about 6% and 12%. If you know the MC of your table top, you can predict how much it will expand and contract from its current width, so you can plan your slots accordingly. For example, if the wood is bone dry now, you know it will not get narrower at any time in the future, so you wouldn't need any slot space toward the center of the table; all the movement will be expansion. If you know the shrinkage coefficients, you can calculate how much expansion room you would need -- probably about 3/8" each side of the centerline of the table for pine.

Ellis

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#17

Re: Look again,

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Keith,

Shrink 1/2"? I don't use any wood that hasn't reached EMC, so I'm never dealing with such shrinkage. I do, however, plan on movement based upon seasonal changes and tie that to the season that the piece is made.

You lost me with the "Don't edge glue" "have 1/8 gaps" between boards. What do you mean, lay the table planks up dry and hold'em together with the breadboard? :\

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#18

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

Phil in CT

Built a cherry trestle table very similar to the one you are proposing (see cover of FineWoodworking Issue 141). Rather than make separate tenons and mortises, I simply routed one continuous mortise in the BB end and made one continuous tenon on the table end. Pinned with 1/4" dowels, all in elongated holes except for the center dowel. It has held up well over 8 years of continuous use (well, except for one dowel that has popped up slightly:


img

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#19

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

Paul Vander Woude

I agree with Moses and Ellis. Make the tenon 3/4 inch long all the way across, with five sections of longer tenon. I would make the longer sections of tenon at least 2 and 1/2 inches long, and probably 3 inches. The wood you remove between the five longer sections of tenon won't be there to expand and contract, and the breadboard will be more solid without a deep tenon all the way across it. The longer sections of tenon (3 inch rather than the 1 and 3/4" of your first drawing) will better support the breadboard from pressure on the outside edge of it. (Remember that when someone lifts the table to move it, they will grab the outside edge of the breadboard.) The elongated holes should be carefully located so that when you drive in the tenon, it draws the breadboard tightly against the table top edge. I built a cherry table of the same size as you are contemplating, and did the tenons that way. I glued and pinned the center tenon, and made elongated holdes on the other four. By the way, after the first few months, there has been no measurable seasonal movement in the top.

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#20

Small Point

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

That Paul references.

I have always glued the center of the tenon into the center of the mortise. I would not rely on a few 1/4" dowels to hold the breadboard on over the years.

Re: BreadBoard End Protocol

#21

Alan Young

Thanks for all the replys

Alan Young

A great set of informative comments-Thanks all...

-Alan