Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Struggling with design questions

Posts

Struggling with design questions

#1

Struggling with design questions

Barry Irby

I'm trying to come up with a design for a couple of night stands. I went to Google images and looked a hundreds of pictures for a little inspiration. Nothing grabbed me. Been cogitating on this for a year or two. I can build most anything except a design.

Right now, I am thinking of a "folded" stand. A top/back/bottom and little more. Three pieces of walnut dovetailed together. A box with the front and sides missing. Perhaps a drawer hanging underneath the top.

I am desperate for a better Idea. Any comments or suggestions welcome.

Re: Struggling with design questions

#2

Re: Struggling with design questions

Chuck in Mtl.

Barry,

I would suggest the Arts and Crafts style with the square pegs and slats.

Re: Struggling with design questions

#3

JL

Re: Struggling with design questions

JL

+ 1 on that thought. The simplicity would carry the project.

Re: Struggling with design questions

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Struggling with design questions

Moses Yoder

I don't really have time to do a drawing but if you have no support at the front top you will have problems hanging something from it or putting weight on top. If you had legs fastened at the front on each side that curved toward the back you could have more support on the top and a more interesting look from the side. I would use a 2-1/2" or so wide leg, perhaps a bent lamination, ending up at the back of the stand then having supports at the bottom tenoned into the legs. Do a sketch and see what you think. You can use planks in the stile of I think it was Economaki, to do the design you are thinking of, but they need to be about 2-1/2" to 3" thick planks to support a top like you are envisioning. If you do that style I don't think hanging a drawer underneath would look very good. Perhaps building a seperate box like a jewelry style box to set on top would be more apropriate.

Re: Struggling with design questions

#5

Barry, I dad a customer last year wanting that

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

What I ended up doing, was using 8/4 material, but the back slanted in at the bottom, by about 30�. Then the foot, was made from a 3 x 4, passing through it, tapered down both ways.

I failed to photograph them, but still have the model here in the office, and will send you a pic if you will send me an email first.

Re: Struggling with design questions

#6

Ellis Walentine

Process

Ellis Walentine

I would suggest going about this in a problem-solving mode:

1. Who is the customer? If it is you, what do you want from your nightstand? Make it big/strong/attractive/functional enough to meet these expectations. Functionally, it should be so tall and so wide, with or without particular storage requirements. Aesthetically, it should be attractive to the customer.

2. What is the style of the room and other furnishings in it? Should the nightstand(s) harmonize with the surroundings?

3. What are the cost or other constraints, if any, such as your time, availability or cost of materials, skills or technologies required, etc.?

I know this seems to be really open-ended, especially on the aesthetics of the design, which is probably your biggest question. Often, if you are having trouble coming up with a form based on your own preferences or skills, you can get inspiration from art and furniture books, interior design magazines, maybe even makers' websites or etsy.com or custommade.com or elsewhere on the internet.

Ellis

Re: Struggling with design questions

#7

Clint Searl

Coupla ideas

Clint Searl


Re: Struggling with design questions

#8

Re: Struggling with design questions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

As a concept, it's a neat idea. I'm not sure whether it's practical - anything put on the bottom shelf created by the construction would, in my house, fall off to the side and wind up under the bed or underfoot. But you always have to balance practical and aesthetic.

You're going to be asking a lot of dovetail joints if you do that in its pure form, although Rietveld pulled off something like that (though not with dovetails) with his Zig Zag chair, pictured below, which is, apparently, still in production (so it must be possible to build it without liability lawsuits driving the company that makes it out of business; perhaps it's marketed only to supermodels who weigh 80 pounds).

You might Google "Rietveld zig zag chair" and look at various images to try to dope out the joinery. It appears that, at each meeting of plane surfaces, the miters are screwed together with a lot of screws, with a long triangular glue block between the two.

If you put a drawer under the top, that could give you space behind the drawer in which to hide some reinforcement of the top; and extending the back down past the bottom, suspending the bottom above the floor a bit with feet held back from the front, would give you room to put in some reinforcement hidden in the corner below the bottom and in front of the back.

No one has yet used the magic word, "mockup," but I think that would be a good idea. For starters, you can get big pieces of cardboard, probably free, from any appliance store, just to mock up the shape and see how it looks. Then some cheap pine or fir from a big boxy store will let you explore construction, before you start cutting on the spendy wood. Your final is going to need some chunky wood for enough stiffness.


img

Re: Struggling with design questions

#9

Start with what you already know.

Ray - Middletown, IN

You probably know the approximate size, and where it will be located. Will it match existing furniture or contrast? Start sketching with what you know and add or subtract from there. Sounds like you know what you want for a top so start there, add some legs or panels to the floor. Need a drawer? where will it go, sketch it in. Don't like it, erase and put it someplace else. Visualize on paper, it will help to gel your thoughts. Don't throw your sketches away, you may want to use them down the road on another project. If you go through half a sketchbook, so what, you have captured several ideas for future work or things to incorporate into this project.

Ray

Re: Struggling with design questions

#10

David Barnett

Design from constraint (what Ellis said, plus)...  *LINK*

David Barnett

... is just another, rather more negative-sounding restatement of Ellis' design process. Sometimes it's easier to start from what you don't want something to be.

As Ellis suggests, by all means look for inspiration. Designers often have libraries for just this purpose, but there's plenty of help online. Of course, there's Google, but websites like 1stdibs.com, an amassing of current gallery offerings can quickly expose you to copious design, period, and style choices.

Save the good ones (or just provocative examples) in a folder. Just go through each page and play "hate it, hate it, really hate it, not so bad, maybe, okay, hate it", and so on, making quick critical decisions. You can further refine your decisions and spawn new ideas later without the distraction of too many influences. Another advantage to shotgunning brick and mortar galleries, you'll often find measurements and other comments as to materials, provenance and design history, even price.

Another website, in addition to etsy and custommade, is http://design-milk.com/ covering trends and innovation in design that can help break through stasis. Go to their links for closer looks at the more interesting stuff. Become a design junkie.


Night Stands at 1stDibs

Re: Struggling with design questions

#11

Re: Struggling with design questions

Jesse Cloud

Sketch, sketch, sketch.

Get a sketchbook and a couple of pencils. No eraser.

Find a quiet spot and fifteen undisturbed minutes.

Think of a shape, curve, whatever and draw it. Draw it again and again with small changes. Don't think too much. Chances are pretty good that you will start moving in a particular direction toward something you like.

Don't worry about how it could be built at this stage. Just capture shapes. We can figure out how to build it later.

After a few of these sessions, you may have something you like. Spend some time on that, thinking of joinery, type of wood, finish, etc. Mockups are a good idea. A three dimensional view of the piece may give you new ideas. Cardboard, scrap, whatever put together with drywall screws, hotmelt, staples, tape, whatever is quick and easy to change.

When I start a new model of chair, I make a half scale mockup and usually try out four or five different leg styles, a few different styles for rails or splats, etc. Since its just screwed together, I can swap out legs in a few minutes.

Another good trick, when you see something you like in a book or magazine, make a copy, note what you like about it, and file it away for future use.

Hope some of this helps!