Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

Posts

OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#1

OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hi all.

Sorry for the off topic, but I know I can get good advice from you guys.

I need to insulate my attic. This is something I've put off for 14+ years. I know, don't say anything. My wife has already said it all... :)

I have water coming into two rooms right now. Uhg. After all the snow and ice we've had, it is now melting. All my gutters are frozen and all backed up.

I know insulating the attic will not solve all the problems, but it will help.

I don't know what to do as far as the insulation goes, so here is some info about the attic and so on to help help me know how to insulate and/or offer suggestions:

- My roof, about 10 years old, is vented at the top - a ridge vent.

- The soffit(?), or overhang shown in the picture (#8) below, is not vented.

- I don't have a safe way to get up that high all around the house.

- I don't think I can get up to the soffit to drill holes and insert vents if that's required.

- The house is aluminum sided

- The attic floor is tongue and groove flooring

- As far as I can tell there isn't any insulation under the attic floor

- Each side of the roof is about 26' wide (width of the hosue) and 18' long.

- The roof rafters very in distance appart but average 18-19" appart.

- The rafters are 2x6 (5-1/2").

- House was built in 1924.

- I don't plan on spending the rest of my life in this house.

- I'm getting wet!

Please offer suggestions on how I should go about doing this. I really know very little about installation, ventalation, house construction and so on.

Thanks in advance.

Some pictures to show what I have.

#1 One of two windows. There is a window on each end of the attic.


#2 This is looking down an end wall towards the attic floor.


#3 This shows where the roof meets the attic floor. It looks like the below room ceiling lathing almost where the roof meets the floor/wall.


#4 Same as three above.


#5 A look along the attic floor towards the chimney.


#6 This looks straight down onto the below room ceiling (I think) where the attic floor ends.


#7 A look up at the ceiling.


#8 A look at the overhang/soffit - I think soffit is the corect term...


Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#2

It is all open and easy access

Dustmaker Mike

I would call a company and have them foam it. If you are up to it www.tigerfoam.com has all the stuff to do it yourself. I love this stuff

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#3

Re: It is all open and easy access

ehgauss

In theory, your best bet is to insulate the devil out of the floor, and open the attic so that the temperature under the roof is no warmer than outside. That way you will minimize the melting that results in freezing when it reaches the eaves under which it is also unheated. I didn't have that option, so I removed several rows of shingles from the eaves upward, and installed aluminum ice slides. That seems to have done it.

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#4

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

Barry Irby

As a Home Inspector, I have several questions.

Your roof is ten years old? Locally it would have been required to install Ice and Water Shield membrane under the bottom three feet of roofing. Did you not get it when the roofing was installed. If you have it, it should have blocked any intrusion from ice damming.

One of the pictures shows "splat" marks on the floor. This is usually from humidity condensing on the tips of the roofing nails protruding through below the roof and dripping off. Generally these are not roof leaks, but a cold weather phenomenon. Is this what you have as opposed to leaks or do you have both?

The traditional method of insulating an attic is to insulate under the floor/on top with the ceiling, based on the idea of retaining the heat in the living space. This also keeps the escaping warmth from melting the snow and letting it refreeze on the over hangs, the genesis of ice dams. If you had soffit vents, the theory is that the heat will rise out the top, drawing cold air in through the soffit vents, keeping the temperature more evenly distributed. Insulating the ceiling MAY retain enough heat in house to limit ice damming, even without soffit vents.

The latest approach to this is to insulate the under side of the roof deck with foam as suggested above. The foam must be suitable for this application. Closed cell and "non-hygroscopic" meaning does not absorb water or water vapor. This will keep the heat from the interior from reaching the underside of the roof sheeting and prevent the uneven melting that causes Ice Damming. BUT it may do little to keep the heat in the living space and therefore may do little to reduce energy bills. Foam is usually several times as expensive as other types of insulation.

If it were mine and money were limited, I would have someone blow dense pack cellulose under the attic floor. If I had some more money I would also insulate the underside of the roof sheathing with foam. (This may be that I am turning into an old Fuddy Duddy and am not sure I trust that new fangled foam.) I am also a little skeptical of not being able to see the underside of the roof sheeting. That may be the inspector in me, wanting to see everything.

How about opening the attic windows and seeing if that will let out the heat and even out the temps?

If you want to do some in-depth research check out Joe Lstiburek's site BuildingScience.com.

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#5

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

Frank Orfanello

You've gotten good advice here so far.

I favor the icynene (sp) foam idea. I was sold on it a couple of years ago when a good friend of mine built a new home and used this as insulation. The house practically sips fuel in the winter and stays warm and comfortable.

I know that's what I'll do next time I can.

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#6

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

jim in w. central mo.

Check out this months Fine Homebuilding for an article on foam and insulation combo's. By far the easyest, cheepest, diy is blown in- dense pack between the ceiling and attic floor. This still might not provide enough R-value for your zone, but you can add on top of your floor with more loose fill, or batts, or extruded foam with ply to preserve your open area. You missed the boat with Tax credits of 30% last year, but new credits of 10% are avaliable this year. This diy would Save you a ton of money and add so much comfort to your house! Keep in mind if you don't need to heat or cool your attic you'll reduce energy use, which can be spent in your shop!

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#7

Not an expert, but thoughts *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Either ventilate the attic or don't. A vent at the top, if you don't have a vent at the bottom, won't do much but attempt to draw air from the heated part of the house (and, if it's doing this, cause the moisture from the heated air to condense in your attic, which could be contributing to your water problems). You need vents at the bottom for incoming air.

You can rent scaffolding. Maybe that would allow you to reach the soffits. It looks like you've got aluminum soffit material. Snap vents (round vents that snap into a hole drilled with a hole saw - thus the name) might be fastest, although most of them have limited free area for the size of the vent - see if you can get some that don't have louvers but are just open screens.

About the scaffolding: call around. Locally, the regular rental yards charge about twice what the one specialty scaffolding rental place charges. You can get cool extenders that let you work cantilevered out from the scaffolding, if there's something in the way, and other specialized stuff.

All I can add about the insulation is that I've heard, if you're going to insulate under the rafters, you should NOT ventilate the attic (no point in insulating and then ventilating the space under the insulation).

Big subject. You might consider consulting with a contractor who knows his/her business and being up front about it: you plan to do the work yourself and need consultation and are willing to pay for it. Don't pretend you're seeking bids and then use the information learned; bad karma.

People talk about insulation, but, really, there's two parts to it: eliminating or at least minimizing airflow from the heated area to the unheated area and insulating. One of the advantages of foam insulation is it does both at once, when properly applied. Fiberglass and cellulose tend to just insulate. If you're going to use these, in the attic floor joists, you should start with lots of spray foam in a can - ceiling boxes, pipe chases, etc. Basically, try to seal up anywhere that air can get outside the heated area (see some warnings, following sentences). If you've got any can lights, make sure they're rated for insulation contact before sealing around them; and, if they're not, consider replacing them. The old can lights, which ventilated heat out the back/top, are regular airflow chimneys. And be careful around any chimney; get some advice before you block up any air spaces there.


http://www.askthebuilder.com/B335_Calculating_Ventilation_Area_of_Attic.shtml

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#8

consult a local insulation contractor?

Bill Tindall

I have insulated several houses and the normal procedure is to get quotes and advice from 2-3 local contractors specializing in insulation. A truck shows up, preparation work gets done and then a hose gets snaked into the attic and minutes later the recommended feet of insulation is blown in. I used to install "grade stakes" to ensure the fill but the last time the company even did that. It is the cheapest, more pain free thing that gets done on a house, at least in these parts.

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#9

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

FredD

Bill's suggestion in getting a local Insulation Contractor is highly recommended for people such as yourself who are in the dark so to speak about what to do.

If you have several local Contractors , some may even be Building Contractors who do a lot of remodeling , get a couple of bids.

Even though you may be untutored in Insulation approaches , this should not keep you from asking a couple of questions about the job itself.

Until you have the Soffit vented , the Ridge vent is worthless. Gable vents are a plus , ask about them to replace the window's which are never used in your Attice Gables

Do nothing further along the line of insulation , until you have a competent roofing Contractor correct the ice damming above the eaves.

When the Attic is sealed from the Weather , then it is good to go , have the Insulation people give you more then one option regarding material used.

In my own experience as a General Contractor , I would be leery of blowing in any shredded Cellulose ( read paper ) in spaces I am not sure are free of potential Electrical hazards , like Pull cans and Junction boxes without covers, Nob and Tube

Iron wiring, Can Lights that run so hot that the typical ones used to require the first three feet of wire from the fixture can to be Asbestos clad and so on.

Blown in Fibre Glas insulation has non of those problems , it is fire proof up to 3,000 degrees F and has a Higher R rating.

You did say this home was erected in 1924 , so you may have that Era's wiring and not know it , if you can't see it.

Approach the job ,like you do your day job, get the relevant information and you will do fine.

One other thougth comes to mind , your Roof if it has Mineral coated three tab Shingles , depending on your location , Weather wise could very well be ready to be replaced, you would want to know this before you do any remodeling to the present one.

FredD

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#10

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Joe, lots of good advice so far. I would do one more thing based on the experience with my house. We used to have vented soffets and gable vents and never had icicles or ice dams. When we had the roof redone a few years ago the contractor put in a ridge vent and wanted to eliminate the gable vents. He was going to put in decorative vents on three of the end peaks that can be seen. I insisted that he make these functional as well. The first winter with the new roof we started getting icicles as soon as the ridge vent was covered with snow. I started checking and found that the new peak vent on one end of the house was completely blocked on the inside so no air could get through. Once I opened this vent up so air could flow, the icicles stopped forming.

In my experience ridge venting is fine until you get a significant snow covering and then it quits working and allows heat to build up and melt snow from the bottom. This in turn forms ice dams and icicles.

Lee

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#11

Fred has a good point or several.....

Barry Irby

If you have a 1924 house that has never been insulated, it's possible you have vintage wiring also. It is not safe to bury Knob and Tube wiring in insulation. It's designed to run in free air so it can dissipate its heat. It could easily over heat if it gets covered with insulation. In that case cellulose might be more dangerous if it does not have excellent fire retardants added.

As you see, this is a vast topic and you should be careful.

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#12

Re: OT - LongAttic insulation - Need Advice Please

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Greetings good people. I haven't posted for a long while, but do read the mail everyday.

I had to jump in in support of Icynene insulation. When we built in 2002, I had Icynene foamed into those walls that were not SIP, and the attic. Icynene is not a high value insulation, it is equivalent to fiber glass at R3.5 per inch. The thing that it does and others may or may not is that it absolutely seals the area into which it is sprayed resulting in no airflow or moisture flow between the heated and unheated spaces. It drys solid in a minute or two and does NOT shrink. In my attic I had Icynene sprayed between all joists, and then an additional 12 plus inches of blown in fiber glass. We also use ridge vents, and vented soffits.

I agree with Lee that an attic MUST be ventilated summer and WINTER. In addition, all vents from the bath and kitchen must be properly vented out through the roof. Interestingly in the south, they are just vented into the attic space.

One thing you can remember is that you cannot have too much insulation. .

I grew up in Akron and know what nob wiring is. In this day and age, run do not walk to a licensed electrician and get new wiring and distribution panel.

Good luck on the home upgrades,

Ken who had 4 days of 10 degree lows last week.

It was warmer in Green Bay than the Dallas area.

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

#13

Re: OT - Attic insulation - Need Advice Please

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks everybody for taking the time to offer information and suggestions.

Turns out, this is a pretty complex subject.

Thanks again.

Joe