Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Request: Advice on a tail vice

Posts

Request: Advice on a tail vice

#1

Request: Advice on a tail vice

Ed Beck

I'm installing a Rockler 12'' Quick Release End Vise on my workbench and have a couple of questions.

  • How thick should I make the tail and face? I'm using European Beech.

  • My bench is 41" wide and the vice is 17" wide. Can I make the tail and face the entire width of the bench or is that too much?

  • Does the answer to #2 depend on how thick I make the pieces?

  • Thanks Everyone,

    Ed

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    #2

    Ellis Walentine

    Not everyone, but...

    Ellis Walentine

    Your #3 question anticipates the answer to #1 and #2. Those faces are beams, and they

    are subject to beam deflection calculations. The jaws need to be thicker to resist deflection the further you get from the cast-iron jaw.

    Ellis

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    #3

    Re: Not everyone, but...

    Ed Beck

    I thought so, let me put it this way, If I plane 5/4 European Beech down to 1", then glue them together to make a 2" pieces, would that be OK to take out the full 41"?

    I'd have about 12" beyond the end of the vice.

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    #4

    Re: Not everyone, but...

    Thomas S Stockton

    Ed

    Ellis is correct about the wider you go the thicker it needs to be. I usually do things like this by a couple of different ways.

    1. see what the instructions say, sometimes works other times they are so poor it doesn't matter.

    2. go off of their picture and make an educated guess.

    3. if it looks right it is right. One of my favorite British sayings.

    and if all else fails

    4. wing it.

    I think your idea of gluing two boards together will work fine, I would face joint them and the glue them and then size up the chunk of wood. That way you would get the maximum thickness.

    Tom

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    #5

    JL

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    JL

    I have the Lee Valley version. My bench is ~31.5" wide. The Lee Valley version allows up to 24" center to center for the larger Twin Screw Vise. For your bench (41"), I would prefer as wide as possible. The Rockler, with 17" center to center isn't enough (IMO). That means ~12" outside of the screw. Of course with the Lee Valley, you would still have ~8.5" outside of the screw.

    My faces are 8/4 maple.

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    #6

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    GolfSteve in Calgary

    Hi Ed,

    From your link I see pictures of other benches that are probably 36" wide. I wouldn't be too worried about 41" - and you can always cut the face shorter later so long as you plan your dog holes appropriately.

    At 41" wide, you would have a 12" overhang on each side of the vice (and a bit more overhang if you measure to the guide bars). When holding small pieces you would presumably place them close to the centre of the vice. When holding wide pieces, one edge would be placed close to a guide bar. My engineering schooling is now just a drunken fuzzy memory, but there's a vague recollection about friction coefficients that states that as the piece of work being held gets wider you will not have to apply as much pressure on the vice to get the same holding force as a narrower piece...thus leading into the next paragraph:

    Others seem to worry about the beam strength of the wood face on the vice. I think the bigger problem is racking if you were to use the extremeties of the vice with narrow work. I'd guess a 1" thick piece of maple is plenty strong for the vice face, but I'd go for 1.5" - you can always go thinner and shorter later.

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    #7

    Thanks, Here's what I did

    Ed Beck

    Thanks to everyone for the advice. A limiting factor was that I already owned the vice, so getting the wider twin screw wasn't an option.

    I ended up face planing the 5/4, gluing two pieces of 42" together, then trimming. The faces are about 2 1/8" each.

    I had a thought about this, what if I had routed out a groove to place metal rods in before I glued the pieces together? I'd have to be careful on the placement to avoid where I'm likely to drill the holes for the guides and screw, I'd have to have the rods shorter than the total width so I don't try to trim metal off, and I'd have to place them out of the way of holes for the dogs. I think with all that taken into consideration I could have gotten a couple of rods in there.

    Thoughts?

    Ed

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    #8

    JL

    Re: Thanks, Here's what I did

    JL

    Are you talking about extra strength?? I don't think you'll need it with 2 1/8" of wood. You are only trying to hold a work piece - not crush it :D .

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    #9

    Re: Thanks, Here's what I did

    Ed Beck

    LOL - no, to prevent the wood from bending at the extremities.

    Re: Request: Advice on a tail vice

    #10

    Re: Thanks, Here's what I did

    GolfSteve in Calgary

    The wood shouldn't bend at the extremeties because you shouldn't be holding narrow material at the extremeties. I wouldn't bother with the metal rods. At the most you might consider putting a very slight camber on the vice face.