Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

Posts

Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#1

Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

Henry Higginbotham

I'm about to build a cutting and assembly table, and planning to use a torsion box for the 48" x 96" top. A finished height of 24" seems about right for cutting sheet goods with a Festool saw and guide rail, and also about right for assembly of projects of kitchen cabinet size or similar.

But I'm unsure about how to ensure that the torsion box turns out flat. It would seem that building it on a known flat surface would do the trick, and (surprisingly) I actually thought about this when planning the shop. However, the quadrant of the shop that I asked the concrete clowns to give some extra attention to regarding flatness is the very part they flubbed the worst. There are some areas where the floor is acceptably flat for most purposes, but not quite as flat as I'd like the torsion box to be.

So . . . anyone got any suggestions for maintaining a flat top? I don't have a number in mind for tolerance, but obviously the flatter, the better, and there's no changing it once the glue sets.

Also, I'm planning to use inexpensive Chinese 12mm poplar-veneer plywood for both the skins and the core, with a finished thickness of 4 inches. Does that sound adequate?

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#2

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion bo

Barry Irby

I would set up two straight pieces of lumber (2 x 8's ?) and make them level and level with each other. About 32" apart. Have them secure and study and then lay the bottom layer of plywood on them and then the frame and the top layer. I would dry fit it and be sure the top ply comes out flat and level. I would set it up with a transit, because I have one, but a really good level would work well also. After the dry fit is successful, glue it up.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#3

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion bo

Stuart Johnson

Build it on top of a sheet of 3/4 MDF. You would have a very flat surface and nice straight edges to align the plywood and webbing.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#4

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion bo

AZ in Colorado Springs

I don't know the term for the pieces that criss-cross to make the core of the torsion box, but as long as they are all ripped or cross cut to the same dimension, wouldn't the torsion box turn out flat with both sides parallel? Likewise, if they are not all cut to the same dimension, how would the torsion box ever come out straight?

I'm not disagreeing with your desire to have a flat, open space to work on, but in this case, it seems to me that the quality of material prep leads directly to the final result.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#5

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion bo

Jim Dillon

Henry,

I've built a 4x8 foot torsion box to be used as a "portable" assembly table and it worked very well. I used dimensioned 1x2s purchased at the local borg for the innards and 1/4 inch masonite for one side and either 1/4 or 3/8 plywood (can't remember which)for the other side. I purchased the 1x2s as this was before I had my TS. No problems with achieving flatness as the 1x2s will keep everything parallel. I just built it on my garage floor - nothing special. I say "portable" as it turned out to be quite heavy and awkard to move, especially for one person, but it sure served the purpose; I placed it on a set of sawhorses during use. I used screws to pull the skins tight to the ribs. I countersunk the screws below the surface to avoid sharp surfaces on the top.

Jim

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#7

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion bo

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I have made numerous torsion boxes before, where I cut a dado to cut half way through the bundles of x & y axis parts. I think you are going to thick, to use the dado for this, and 3" would be more than enough.

I like to use thickened epoxy rolled heavily onto the top and bottom substrates and edges of bundles before starting assembly.

You can use a shop vac with a bag made by folding over plastic sheeting, pressed together into a bead of butyl caulk. I put my bathroom scale between two sheets of ply, just to see how much, and got 180 # psf, which is plenty for this type of work.

One thing that worries me about the china ply top and bottom, is that even if you get a wonderful bond between your parts and the face veneer, the glue-up of that stuff is pretty pitiful. I have gotten plenty of it that delaminated, from lacking enough glue.

It would be a shame to make this up, only to have the face that you glued to fail.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#8

Re: Here's a YouTube video

Henry Higginbotham

Thanks--good video. I'd already done a search but must have overlooked this one.

It may change an hour from now, but I'm leaning toward building it off the floor. Barry suggested a transit, but I probably have access to a more accurate instrument--a Leica DNA03 digital level. It's not doing much else at the office these days (man, we need some work). We typically get repeatable level readings to 0.001 foot (0.012 inch) on very smooth concrete floors.

My (possibly harebrained) idea is to mark and shoot a 4' x 8' area on the floor (at a one-foot grid), use my civil software (also not doing much lately) to get a best-fit plane, raise the plane until no point on the grid protrudes through it, and then figure how many layers of shim stock (or tape, or ?) need to go on the floor at each spot to produce a planar matrix. Think of the extra points I'll get for overkill and for involving more tools and toys!

Then again, this may in practice be no better than the method in the video. Further suggestions are still welcome.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#9

Accuracy is good.  I vote for extra points!   

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#10

I'd worried about delamination, too

Henry Higginbotham

The bottom shouldn't be as much of an issue, as I plan to rout grooves into it to hold the core components in place horizontally during assembly. The underside of the top might be another story. You're right--I'd certainly be bummed.

I guess I could use 1/2" MDF, but the plywood is already here, whereas I'd have to make a trip to (probably) Atlanta for 1/2" MDF. I can get 3/4" MDF locally, but that adds to the weight issue. Or it's possible a local (real) lumberyard could order some 1/2" for me.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#11

Do it this way . . .

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I have built a number of torsion boxes including one for a two part article in the Dec'09/Jan'10 Issue of American Woodworker.

First I would not use dimensional lumber for the structure- too much chance of warping with internal stresses in the wood, warping from humidity, etc. Likewise for the skins. Use MDF and tempered hardboard (Masonite) - consistent composition throughout, no internal stresses, absolutely flat to start with, etc. and cheap.

Unless you change your intended use and decide to pound on the torsion box, you can make it relatively light and keep it to under 4" . Look at my posts here.

Here is an 8' long X 18" wide torsion box made entirely of hardboard and yellow glue. In the second photo it is supporting over 300 lbs at mid-span and only deflecting 1/2" . For your application I would use 1/2" MDF for the top, 1/2" MDF for the webs (more surface for edge gluing) and 1/4 hardboard for the bottom.



Build a ladder shaped construction platform like David Marks and use his winding stick method to make it FLAT. Joint, rip, and plane 2 x 4's so they have straight, parallel edges and are all the same width. Attach the cross pieces with hotmelt glue to the long pieces then all you need to do is adjust the two long pieces to make it FLAT- IT DOES NOT NEED TO BE LEVEL. AZ in CO has it right. I also screwed my saw horses to the floor.


Use the "halved joint" (more correct term than "half lap") method to make the web- it is quicker, less work, more precise, etc. etc. than the method used by David Marks and the Wood Whisperer. Just don't cut the notches tight- the MDF must slip together easily or it will splay.

Yellow glue is fine. Slow-set epoxy will give you more time, but I don't like the cleanup.

Don't waste your time putting dadoes in the skins!!!! They add little and create problems using the halved joint method. A simple indexing jig and a dado blade results in perfect web pieces.



If you send me a PM or email request I'll send a PDF proof copy of the article- it has a lot more details. Or you can order the back issue from the AWW website.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#12

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion bo

ed hoxter

henry, if you use plywood for framing don't do what i did. i glued and screwed the frame together and glued and screwed 3/8 ply to the first side. then i went in the house for the night. next morning my table top was shapped like a banana. good luck ED

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#13

Clint Searl

Sounds like overkill to me

Clint Searl

A couple 24" flush doors, joined together, will provide a flat surface. And a coiple low saw horses will provide sufficient support. Flat, sturdy, infinitely adjustable, portable, and done in one session.

Clint

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#14

Ouch!  Well, you could always

Henry Higginbotham

. . . change your specialty to boat hull building. ;)

What caused it? Damp floor?

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#15

Thanks, Alan.  Email sent

Henry Higginbotham

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#16

Re: Ouch!  Well, you could always

ed hoxter

henry, it was because of all that wet glue on one side. plus i had it laying on tressel benchs overnight. its 4x8 fairly flat in the middle. about 2 1/2 foot on each end is warped about 3/8 of an in. if i had finished both sides the same time, it would have been nice and flat. good luck ED

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#17

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion bo

Dick Coers

I built a 4'x12' conference table as a torsion box. I actually made the guts of a torsion from 3/4" particle board, 11" tall, to make a flat plane on the floor. I just slid it together, no glue. Then I laid up the skins and gird on top of that grid, and bowed 1x4's from the ceiling to the table top to apply clamping pressure. I had 1/4" melamine under the 1x4s to protect the top skin. It was one expensive skin that I had layed up by Indiana Architectural Plywood. The table worked out great! You could have parked a pickup on it when it was done.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#18

Re: Do it this way . . .

Doug Ring - San Diego

Alan - I would also like to get a copy of your article. What is your email address?

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#19

Agreed

John E in SC

I have a 36" hollow core door that I bought used at a Habitat store for $5 that I use on top of a couple folding plastic sawhorses (about $15) that makes a great assembly / work table. When it's in the way, only takes a minute to lean up against the wall, and it's held up remarkable well. If you want 48", certainly edge-gluing 2 24's would be incredibly simple.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#20

Re: Agreed

Barry Irby

I am not sure I would do it, but if you wanted, you could hinge two 24" units together and then unfold them onto the saw horses, and fold them up to put them away.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#21

Maybe I should have explained better

Henry Higginbotham

When I said this was to be a cutting and assembly table, I should have emphasized that it's for cutting sheet goods with a Festool saw and guide. That will often involve my putting all my weight onto the middle of the top at times (thus the low 24" height), while expecting it to remain as perfectly flat as possible come assembly time. Also, the long sides will have drawers for storage, and there could be a vise mounted at some time. While the door idea scores well as "cheap, quick, and functional," I want this to be something I don't ever have to build again.

Re: Any tips for building a large, FLAT torsion box?

#22

A couple of things

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

When I do this, I like smaller squares ? closer spacing, and thinner stock. Like in fiberglass boats, with balsa or other light core, it is not the inside so much as being bonded to both faces, then thickness between the faces.

When I cut the dados, I tape the bundles together, and cut them all at once, which is easier on a nice big sled.

Before ripping up the core parts, crank the blade all the way up to see how much height above the sled you get, then don't go more than twice that.