Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

Posts

Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#1

Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

Barry Irby

I am in the process of putting the front of my car back together. (2003 Honda CRV) The Antifreeze that leaked out was distinctly bright Green. Anybody know what brand that is? Does it matter? Can I mix brands? Does Honda require a specific brand?

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#2

Read the Owners Manual..... *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Don't have a Honda, but the link to the owners manual below recommends Honda 50-50 mix antifreeze.


http://techinfo.honda.com/rjanisis/pubs/OM/CR0303/CR0303O00251A.pdf

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#3

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

Derek

I'm not a mechanic, so take this as opinion, but I've never even heard of anyone having a problem with mixed antifreeze brands. One thing to watch out for is that coolant needs to be flushed and replaced every couple of years to make sure the cooling system does not degrade from )I think) acids that build up in the coolant. That should be in the manual for sure. I'd just replace it all. 50-50 mix is the usual ratio of coolant to water in most cars.

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#4

JL

It is just the dye mixture that colors antifreeze

JL

The components of antifreeze are water, ethylene glycol and dye. The dye can be a fluorescein dye which has a nice intense color. It can be a "substituted" fluorescein (such as dichlorofluorescein).

So you can mix and match. They typically put the dyes in so you can trace coolant leaks. Also, ethylene glycol is hazardous to drink. The dyes warn you. Animals like it because of the sweet taste. There was a case in Georgia of the "black widow woman" who killed off two men in her life using ethylene glycol.

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#5

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

ehgauss

NAPA sells anti-freeze that's supposed to be compatible with either the red or the green. But if it were me, I would replace the green with green, and red with red.

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#6

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

Howard Norman

I am sure that Honda has a Honda brand antifreeze. If it was me I would just go to AutoZone or some such store and get the national brand that was the color of the original antifreeze.

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#7

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

Bill Howatt

Antifreeze isn't as simple as it used to be. There is no standard life, long-life and the color coding may not be standardized.

If you mix short-life with long-life you won't have long-life antifreeze. Suggest you check the owners manual and pay attention to the recommendations.

Lots of serious, expensive engine repairs are caused by antifreeze eating through gaskets and leaking into the engine oil so monitoring the life of your antifreeze can save $$$$.

Bill

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Mostly, yes.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

For the most part, anything you buy at a typical auto parts store will be compatible with everything else. However, for a while, GM (I think it was) had an antifreeze that came from the factory that was NOT compatible with others, and, when mixed, would cause gelling.

You likely won't have a problem.

I've also gotten to the point where I just buy the pre-mixed stuff instead of the full-strength. That way, I'm always adding antifreeze that is the correct mixture, and don't have to worry about keeping distilled water around, either, or another jug to mix in, etc.

Jason

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#9

If you do it yourself be aware *LINK*

Gary Smyth

This may be OT but be sure that dogs and cats do not ingest the antifreeze liquid. They love that stuff and will sniff it out. Even a few drops will cause crystals to form in the animal kidney and damage is permanent. I do not know the amount but not very much is almost always lethal as the kidneys shut down..


http://www.2ndchance.info/antifreeze.htm

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#10

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

Dave Paine

The colour is not the issue. The compatibility with the materials in the cooling system is the potential issue.

Over the years the materials have changed, and some brands of anti-freeze could cause problems with certain models.

I own a Subaru, which had such a warning in the owners manual.

There are now brands of anti-freeze which state compatible with all materials.

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#11

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

Jerry Nicholson

Most antifreeze uses ethylene glycol with additives but some antifreeze is based on propylene glycol which may be labeled "non-toxic". It isn't really non-toxic but it is much less toxic than ethylene glycol. Its properties are different from ethylene glycol and I suspect mixing ethylene and propylene glycol might not be a good idea. I did read that breakdown of propylene glycol creates a corrosive acid.

Jerry

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#12

Why not just get one brand ???? forget mixing

del schisler

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#13

Call up a Honda dealer and find out what it takes

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have an old goldwing, and it used to take the orange stuff. But that was for a reason. I don't know if it holds true any more.

The reason was that there was a service bulletin released by Honda about the early goldwings that said that the green stuff included silicates that were intended to scour the interior of water passages and keep them clean. Those silicates were suspected of causing damage to the seals on the water pumps. Many of those old goldwings had water pump failures, including mine.

Anyway, I doubt if that reasoning applies to your CRV. But I would still call Honda and ask them. It's cheaper to mix your own. Just get some distilled water and dilute to 50% by volume.

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#14

Not that simple

Alexander Grigoriev

Besides of ethylene glycol or propylene glycol, which prevents it from freezing, all coolants contain corrosion inhibitors. There are different formulations of those inhibitors, that depend on the radiator and engine material.

It's VERY BAD IDEA to mix different types of coolant. The additives could react in a bad way, leaving you with clogged or corroded radiator.

For Honda vehicles, only Honda coolant should be used. It's kind of blue or green-blue. It's already mixed 50-50 and goes straigth to the system without further dilution. All Honda dealers sell it.

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#15

Indeed it is not this simple

Bill Tindall

As stated, engine coolant is a mix of some solvent that lowers freezing point of water(ethylene glycol(cheap raw material)or propylene glycol(expensive raw material), for example) corrosion inhibitors and a dye, typically a fluorescent dye. Any solvent or dye to be found in any product is going to be miscible with any other, or water.

But, as stated, it is the corrosion inhibitor additives that could be incompatible across product lines. But here too is where folklore develops. If you go into your local auto parts store and on the shelf is Prestone, Peak and Generic brand coolant can you really imagine that these materials would be made to form harmful products if mixed? Imagine you are in Green River Utah and in need of coolant and the one store that has a bottle doesn't have your brand.(maybe there are two stores here now days) Are you going to wait for a UPS delivery, or are you going to imagine that the marketing manager of Peak has made the decision to not get sued as a result of putting a product on the shelf that is incompatible with all others? If Honda really requires special coolant you need to keep a gallon in the trunk or avoid Green River Utah.

Personally I buy what ever is cheapest. Unless in 150 point font on the front of the package it says to not ever mix with any other brand of coolant I mix with reckless abandon. If I ever experienced a problem I will sue.

If you want to be cautious you could withdraw a bit of what ever is in there and mix with some new stuff and see if it forms Jello or remains just fine. (the color might be putrid)

For the record, there are two kinds of propylene glycol. One kind is toxic. But, the propylene glycol used in the "environmentally/pet friendly" version is benign. I pour a pint down the throat of ewes in difficult labor to prevent ketosis. It serves the same function as an IV of glucose.

Re: Car Guy Question Can I mix antifreeze?

#16

Re: Indeed it is not this simple

Steve Schoene

I agree with Bill. I recently had to add some coolant to my car. I don't remember the brand, but it was a name that I recognized. On the container it expressly said works for all makes and models and all colors of coolant. The potential for lawsuits if that weren't true would be staggering.