Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Lost my heat & Waterstones

Posts

Lost my heat & Waterstones

#1

Lost my heat & Waterstones

Thomas Norton

Well because of running out of propane my shop went cold and waterstones are in bocks of ice in their tubs.

So are they a lost cause? Or can I let them thaw out and still be OK?

The glues will be tossed but that is the low $ items.

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

Moses Yoder

There is a good chance they are not frozen hard enough to break. The only thing to do is thaw them and see. If they are still in one piece when they thaw they are probably okay.

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#3

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

wilbur

I'd let them thaw slowly. The main risk to your waterstones is cracking from the freeze-thaw cycle. If they crack, it's not the end of the world. I've seen people epoxy them back together, glue them to a piece of glass or wood, and convert them into slips for sharpening gouges or other non-flat profile tools.

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#4

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Tom Hintz, the guy who runs New Woodworker dot com, has been doing a test saturating his Jet wet stone wheel with water then allowing it to freeze. So far the wheel shows, no cracks, no damage, just icicles.

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#5

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

FredD

Franklins says or it least it did a few years ago , that frreeezing the PVC glues did not harm them.

FredD

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#6

Clint Searl

With your name,....

Clint Searl

.....you should be using oil stones. :b

Clint

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#7

Re: With your name,....

Thomas Norton

HA, HA unfortunately no relations. Rats!!

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#8

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

They probably will be fine. The best way to find out, it to thaw them out. But then again, it may take a while to really find out. They may look fine on the surface, but be hollow or mushy in the middle.

You know how when you look at an ice cube, it is nice and clear on the outside, but inside it seems to be filled with tiny bubbles. Ever wonder where those bubbles came from and how they got through the clear outside? The ice cube forms from the outside in. As it freezes, it also expands, and the bubbles are just little vacuum spheres, rather than air. This may have caused your water stones to just crumble into mush on the inside. Of course I could be wrong. %\],,,,,,,,,,,k

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#9

The bubbles are air....

John in NM

Or another dissolved gas, but most likely air. One way to get clear ice cubes, like the kind you might buy in a bag for fancy mixed drinks, is to boil the water first, or better yet pull enough of a vacuum on it that it boils at room temp. If you freeze it soon after it won't have time to re-equilibrate with the atmosphere, so the amount of dissolved gas will be the same or close to what it was at the higher temp or lower pressure.

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#10

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

David Weaver

if they're not fine, crumble them up in a bag and use the loose stone grit on a plate, or a board, or anything. Save them for when you don't want to sharpen something on the good stones you'd replace them with.

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#12

Looks like I missed it...

John in NM

My sense of humor is not dry enough to joke about water :D

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#13

Don't move to Seattle or coastal Oregon, then

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Joking about water (well, rain) is how they get through the winter.

Re: Lost my heat & Waterstones

#14

Not a chance!

John in NM

I have relatives up in that area :D