Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Deep counterbore

Posts

Deep counterbore

#1

Deep counterbore

Jeff Smith

I need to drill some 3/8" diameter, approx. 7/8" deep counterbores into the end grain of some 3/4" oak. (I'm attaching four corbels to the post and base of a coat tree, and due to the curve of the corbels I need to go through a fair amount of wood in one of the screw positions for attaching to the base.) Pilot holes will be 1/8" for #8 x 1 1/2" screws. I'm not finding a counterbore bit long enough for the 7/8" deep hole. The common, inexpensive ones with a set screw for holding the pilot bit aren't long enough, and I'm also finding they generate lots of smoke and carbon in the oak on some scrap pieces I've been trying. I don't have a drill press, and I'm limited to a 3/8" shank. What's out there for creating such a deep counterbore cleanly? An ordinary 3/8" bit is too difficult to control, and seems to oversize the hole just enough so that the oak plugs for a 3/8" hole don't fit.

Re: Deep counterbore

#2

Re: Deep counterbore

Paul Leuba

Try a 3/8" forstner bit. You should be able to find one with a 1/4" shank. It will leave you with a flat bottom hole.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Deep counterbore

#3

Don't raise the bridge

Neal in San Jose

Lower the river. Is there any reason you couldn't go to a longer screw? If you use a 2 inch screw in those holes, the counterbore would only need to be 3/8 deep if I did my math right.

Re: Deep counterbore

#4

Re: Don't raise the bridge

Jeff Smith

Nice analogy. That's occurred to me also. If I go that route I'll definitely need to search out high-quality screws. I snapped two ordinary (i.e. made in China) hardware store 3 1/2" screws trying to attach the post to the base from the underside; didn't matter whether I turned them in by hand or used a driver bit on the drill, they broke off at the bottom of the smooth neck as soon as the latter began to enter the hole. No getting those out again, had to squeeze two new holes in the little 2" x 2" space I had to work with. That'll never show, but it's ugly. As it is I've got some #8 1-1/2" Spax screws on order for the other 3 (shallower) holes in each corbel.

I'll pick up some Forstner bits per Paul's suggestion also.

Can you REALLY get away without a pilot hole in white oak when using a Spax screw? I'm thinking I want to drill 1/8" pilot holes just to be sure.

Re: Deep counterbore

#5

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Use a different screw

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

If you're going into oak, you need fine-threaded screws. You might try screws for hanging cabinets, or even a machine screw or lag screw. Drill the pilot hole about 1/64" smaller than the minor diameter of the screw where the threads need to hold and the size of the major diameter of the screw where they don't (or slightly smaller).

Jason

Re: Deep counterbore

#6

Re: Use a different screw

Barry Irby

I would use a different screw. I would probably use Kreg Screws. Or deck screws. I have used the deck screws from the borgs for a lot of things and can't remember ever breaking one. I would pre drill the holes either way. I would be concerned about splitting the oak post if I did not pre drilled them. By the way, I would not try to pre drill the holes with the Kreg bit without a drill press or a good positive stop in it. Those bits are very aggressive and I have had it snatch itself much deeper into the wood than I intended. With a positive stop on the bit, it would do an excellent job. Can't remember ever breaking a Kreg screw either.

Re: Deep counterbore

#7

Re: Use a different screw

Jeff Smith

I may try fine-threaded screws. Machine screws would require tapping, I think, and I'm not sure I could keep the tap straight by hand (some recommend using a drill press turned off, turning the drive pulley by hand, but I don't have a drill press anyway). BTW, I'm screwing AND gluing the corbels to the base and post.

Re: Deep counterbore

#8

Re: Use a different screw

Jeff Smith

Yeah, I think pre-drilling is a given here. I've used Kreg screws including the pocket hole fixture in softwood, never tried them in oak before.

Re: Deep counterbore

#9

Re: Use a different screw & lube the threads

Bob Entwisle in NJ

beeswax or soap on the threads will work wonders.

Bob in NJ

Re: Deep counterbore

#10

Ellis Walentine

My 2�

Ellis Walentine

Make a drill guide as we discussed here last week and use a regular twist drill. You'll get a dead straight, properly aligned hole. Drill a clearance hole the rest of the way that is big enough to clear the entire screw shank, and drill a pilot hole that is halfway between the root diameter of the shank and the outside thread diameter. Use a little wax on the tip of the screw when you drive it home.

Spax screws won't break under most circumstances, but I'd drill pilot holes for them. Deck screws will also work if you want to go the long-screw route, but you need properly sized pilot holes and a dab of lubricant.

Ellis

Re: Deep counterbore

#11

Re: Deep counterbore

Barry

Use regular brad point bits. Drill the counterbore to the proper depth using a 1/2" bit, then drill the pilot hole just slightly larger than the diamter of the screw. Use a 1/2" plug cutter to cut a plug of the same wood. Although slower, this is a superior technique. Burning should not be a problem either.

Re: Deep counterbore

#12

BTDT

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Provided you want your screw centered in the board, use a self-centering doweling jig with your 3/8" twist drill (or brad point) bit. If you're desired location is off center, you'll have to shim one side of the board to move the drill point in that direction. I'd mark the entry point using the point of the 3/8 and the jig, then carefully drill the 1/8th relief as a guide hole, then position the jig so your 3/8" follows the pilot.

PS you want to be careful how hard you tighten those screws; pretty easy to split the board this way.

PPS If you're going to plug the counterbore as suggested by Barry, most plug cutters will cut a 3/8 plug. If you use a 23/64 drill instead of 3/8, your plug will be almost invisible.

Re: Deep counterbore

#13

Re: BTDT

Jeff Smith

A jig is pretty much out of the question, I'm afraid. It's like this: the corbels (4 of them) are shaped kinda like Idaho. The short side gets 2 screws into the 3" thick base coat tree base (two half-lapped pieces to form a cross), and the long side 2 screws into the 2"x2" white oak post. So all the screws are going into end grain along the 3/4" edge. The screw closest to the post fastening the corbel to the base is where there is already some curvature (think Sun Valley, with Idaho Falls being the other screw), so that's where either the longest screw or the deepest counterbore needs to be to make it through that much more corbel. Can't see how I'd get a jig to fit over the edge of the workpiece (which also has to be tightly clamped for drilling). And as I think I noted, I even have to drill that one inside hole at an angle (15 deg. or so I'm guessing) rather than vertically through the piece, since otherwise a round plug won't fit (at least not the ones I bought!). That adds even a little more to what the depth of the counterbore needs to be vs. going straight down. Also means the screw exits the bottom of the corbel at an angle, so I have to be really careful about drilling the pilot hole(s) through the corbel and into the base, spread my TiteBond, reposition to exactly line up the pilot holes, and get the thing tightened down. I didn't WANT to drill at an angle, but I can't think of another way to solve the plug problem. I never thought sticking the corbels on would be the most challenging part of the deal!

Re: Deep counterbore

#14

Re: Use a different screw & lube the threads

Jeff Smith

Actually I had used beeswax on the screws that snapped. Think I'll go back to good old Ivory, that seems to work best.

Re: Deep counterbore

#15

Re: BTDT

Barry Irby

Mark said: "PS you want to be careful how hard you tighten those screws; pretty easy to split the board this way. "

He is correct. If you are driving two screws on each side of an oak 2"X2" and fairly near the end of it at that, it would be relatively easy to split it, particularly with wood working screws that have countersunk heads. The cone formed by the counter sink could act like a wedge and split the piece. This makes it important to pre drill those holes for the shaft of the screws (Ellis said it better than I did) and I think this is where screws like the Kreg screws pay off. The Kreg screws are self tapping and have a flat should under the head, so they pull the pieces together rather than wedging into them.

Re: Deep counterbore

#16

Re: Use a different screw & lube the threads

FredD

Actually Beeswax is superior to soap for the simple reason soap contains moisture and that rusts screws, doesn't take much.

Especially in Oak with a ferrous screw and moisture which is guaranteed to form a black stain with the Oak's reaction to wet iron.

FredD

Re: Deep counterbore

#17

Ellis Walentine

If I read you right

Ellis Walentine

... I would think that a drilling jig, based on the principles we mentioned the other day, would be perfect. See if this drawing makes sense...You'd still need to make the guide holes straight through the drill guide piece, so, absent a drill press, you might have to innovate a bit. Maybe horizontal drilling using a flat board and an aircraft bit to make the holes parallel to the sides of the jig?

Or, you could eyeball it, which is probably what I'd do.

Ellis


Re: Deep counterbore

#18

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Don't raise the bridge

Jesper, Denmark

When driving screws in materials like oak and Black Locust, dip the tip of the screw in linseed oil before driving. It both makes it easier to drive and also makes it possible to remove afterwards.

Pilot holes are essential. My preferred drills are Fuller tapered drills for the screw size. Their countersinks are also good quality.