We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I usually use BLO/Polyurethane/Mineral Spirits as it is relatively inexpensive and I can pretty much make it up as I go.
I have used Waterlox (Original). I do use tung oil for some pieces. I have used Behlen's Rock Hard. I have used Nordic Oil (General Finishes). I have used Danish Oil.
The reason I'm asking is I am going down to the big city and I have a Woodcraft gift card. I figured I might as well use it as I'll be on that side of town.
I have a settee, a coffee table, an end table and a small standing cabinet to finish in the near future.
I've only ever made one chair and it was painted so I can't speak to chair finishes, but for furniture, I prefer Deft Clear wood finish in a semi gloss. It is an easy apply finish that looks good, holds up well under normal use and can be touched up years later with little difficulty. It is a lacquer based finish so it needs to be applied outside or in a well ventilated area. I have applied it in temperatures as low as 10 F with no problems other than it takes 24 hours to dry to handle. Each coat softens the previous coat so they become one layer as you build the finish. I usually apply three coats with a brush.
Solvent lacquer is pretty much a spray only product--brushable lacquer is available but has a fairly steep learning curve to really get right.
I like your Danish oil/varnish mix. You can use any oil based varnish, there is no particular benefit to poly since this doesn't build on the surface.
For items that need a film finish I think Waterlox is great. It comes in three flavors, a Original/Sealer which is thinned for wipe on application, Gloss, and Satin, which have a bit higher solids content.
Pure tung oil doesn't make a very good finish--not much protection, very long drying time--3 days or so between coats. Absolutely ignore what it says on the label in the Woodcraft 100% Tung. By the way if the label reads Tung Oil Finish, it isn't pure tung oil, it is either varnish (Formby's) or an oil/varnish mix (Minwax.)
Your modified "witch's brew" is fine for many things as you already know.
Personally, for flat work, I've (mostly) moved from oil finishes in favor of shellac and waterborne topcoats where a more resistant film finish is called for; brands I use are Target and General finishes. These also greatly reduce my need for solvents and thinners which have to be disposed of properly. I used to use Watco as the venerable "grain popper", but find that a washcoat of dewaxed shellac does the same thing just as well and faster.
I still use Waterlox (red and green) for turnings as well as a sealer on treenware and things like working tops because the finish is so easy to restore and doesn't chip or flake off.
Only thing I use oil poly for is interior trim and doors.
Woodcraft sells some of the General line of waterbornes so consider some. Applies easily with a fine nylon brush (no foam brushes with waterbornes) of HVLP spray.
Lee, I used Deft many years ago and found that the finish turned milky after a few years. Do you think that was an abnormal occurrence or have you found the same experience ?
I can think of a bunch of different objectives that may or may not coincide, f'rinstance,
1. Appearance. Probably #1 on most people's list, this could be broken down into sub-concerns, such as sheen, transparency, "depth," surface quality, tone (e.g., Waterlox has a very amber cast, lacquer tends to be colorless),
2. Wear resistance. Urethane resin is tougher and more wear resistant than others, and water-borne finishes are generally harder. Certain catalyzed and pre-catalyzed finishes are also very wear resistant. Wear resistance requirements may vary depending on the use of the piece and may also vary among different surfaces of the same piece, e.g., vertical surfaces vs. horizontal/work surfaces.
3. Tactual quality. This has to do with what you're feeling -- the wood or the finish, i.e., film vs penetrating finishes, number of coats, friction coefficients thereof, etc. -- and whether it is amplified or modified by waxes or polishing steps.
4. Water +/- chemical resistance.
5. Ease of application. This would include reliance on particular skills, techniques or specialized equipment.
6. Drying time. An issue if there is ambient airborne dust that would settle into a slow-drying finish, or if logistical constraints exist.
7. Safety/health concerns. Possibly an issue with some solvents and catalysts.
I used to be one of the loudest advocates of Waterlox Transparent, which has been reformulated and redubbed Waterlox Original Sealer and Finish (?). But it's gotten so expensive that I now make my own wiping varnish using inexpensive varnish and some thinner, at least for furniture and woodwork that requires a degree of protection from water and wear. I use clear gloss product and build as many wiped coats as I want or need, then impart the final surface with some combination of fine sanding blocks, steel wool, buffing, wax and possibly a thin final wipe on/off of thinned varnish mix or a varnish/oil mix. To me, it's more of a dance than a recipe or a specific product.
"Solvent lacquer is pretty much a spray only product--brushable lacquer is available but has a fairly steep learning curve to really get right."
Not totally true. I often brush on thinned solvent NC and acrylic lacquer as the first coat or two to get a quick build without overspray. With a little reduction and brushing technique as for shellac, brush marks are rarely a problem. Subsequent spray coats will melt back any slight brush marks. It can be considered a self sealer.