Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Light bulb Question Again

Posts

Light bulb Question Again

#1

Light bulb Question Again

Barry Irby

I asked about this before, but I want to follow up. My son bought two fixtures for the front of his house that have dusk to dawn sensors in them. Of course I did not read the instructions or warning labels, I just put them up and screwed in two CFL bulbs. I put my finger over the sensor and the bulbs came on. Now it is cold, about twenty degrees and they don't come on any more. (Only been a couple of days) But the ones on the back of the house in ordinary manually operated fixtures work fine. Is it safe to assume the sensors killed the bulbs? What now? Incandescent bulbs? How about LED bulbs if we can find some that are reasonably priced.

Re: Light bulb Question Again

#2

Re: Light bulb Question Again

John McGaw

Options: The sensors killed the bulbs (or) the cold killed the bulbs (or) or the cold killed the sensors (or) the sensors killed the bulbs (or) the bulbs are fine but won't work in the cold (or) the bulbs are fine but won't work in the cold with the sensors (or)... well, you get my meaning -- you have a number of variables to deal with. I'd test the bulbs in other outdoor fixtures to see if it is just the cold + sensors causing problems and I'd test the bulbs indoor to see if the bulbs are truly dead and I'd test the fixtures/sensors with incandescent bulbs to see if they are still viable. My guess is that you'll find that the bulbs will work fine inside but will work poorly in cold conditions but won't work at all in the cold with the sensors controlling them. Call it a hunch.

If I were forced to go to a different sort of bulb for outdoor usage today, I'd likely go to halogen bulbs but of the sort which are in a glass envelope which make them look more like ordinary bulbs. I've been using one of about 75W capacity in an automatic motion-detecting fixture outside between my garage doors and it has been going strong for probably 10 years now. LEDs might be wonderful and the next big thing but right now they are awfully pricey for what they do.

Re: Light bulb Question Again

#3

Clint Searl

Wait till Spring

Clint Searl

Re: Light bulb Question Again

#4

Re: Light bulb Question Again

Rick in Colgate, Wi

I have been using Sylvania Micro-mini CFL's in 3 outdoor lights that are all controlled by one dusk to dawn sensor and they have worked perfectly in cold weather, -10 degrees the last two nights. I put the CFL's in last summer and no trouble since. However, I have 4' flourescent shop light in my garage with electronic ballast and T8 bulbs that will not turn on if the temps are below 20 degrees. I also installed an outdoor light on my brothers garage last week and used one of those screw in dusk to dawn adapters with a 100w CFL and that has worked fine in our cold weather as well.

Re: Light bulb Question Again

#5

Re: Light bulb Question Again

Howard Norman

I would use incandescent bulbs if it was me. I have had mixed results with CFL bulbs outside and LED's are way too expensive as far as I am concerned.

Re: Light bulb Question Again

#6

It depends

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Some sensor type switches (motion, timer and dusk/dawn) use the down stream filament as part of the circuit to operate the sensor itself. They run a little current through the device to make the sensor work. This type of sensor will kill CFL's not made for that type of circuit in short order. LED lights with their lower current draw will tend to glow dimly on these types of sensor switches.

Some new switches are rated for use with CFL's and don't use the down stream circuit for their power. I also understand that some CFL's say they will work with sensor type switches, but haven't seen them myself.

Lee

Re: Light bulb Question Again

#7

Halogens put out a lot of heat

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you do put in halogens, Barry, do some research to make sure the fixture can handle the heat produced by the bulb you choose.

Incandescents, although they're no longer environmentally correct, are at least simple and predictable.

Re: Light bulb Question Again

#8

Re: It depends

Paul Leuba

I have used inexpensive CFL's in outdoor fixtures in Maryland for several years without any problems. In the winter (0 - 30 degrees) the light output takes a few minutes to come up to its usual brightness.

This year I purchased screw in photo cell sensors which quickly ruined the CFL bulbs. I failed to purchase the type designed for use with CFL's. I then traded in my newly purchased photo cell sensors for a set that are designed for use with CFL's and they have been working fine ever since.

It seems that the non-CFL designed photo sensors cause rapid cycling of the bulbs during dusk and dawn light situations, perhaps a hundred, or more, brief on/off cycles per transition from light to dark and vice versa. This quickly ruined the CFL bulbs.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Light bulb Question Again

#9

Re: Halogens put out a lot of heat

John McGaw

Not to be pedantic but a halogen lamp is an incandescent -- they differ in the gas used to fill them and the type of glass used and the proximity of the glass to the filament but they both operate with a white-hot tungsten filament heated by an electrical current. A 75W halogen and a 75W 'regular incandescent' put out the same amount of heat. I conditioned my recommendation on using a bulb which is in a normal-looking glass envelope rather than one of the tiny cylindrical types -- this will keep anything from getting overly close to the inner envelope next to the filament and being exposed to the higher temperature there. Halogen lamps have a number of advantages that I won't get into -- I simply prefer the quality of light they emit.

Re: Light bulb Question Again

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Yes, but...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

if you do a little research, you'll find that halogens, watt for watt, are slightly more efficient than a standard incandescent, so they actually put out LESS heat. The difference is that most people, when they think of halogens, think of the 300 or 500 watt work lights, but think of a 60-100 watt incandescent. Compare apples to apples, and an incandescent puts out more heat per watt (and their filaments are actually slightly hotter).

Jason