Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Is my walnut dry enough?

Posts

Is my walnut dry enough?

#1

Is my walnut dry enough?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

I just bought some rough sawn 12/4 walnut from a luthier that has been in an unheated shed for many years. I do own a moisture meter and have not tested the wood yet. Someone told me that, if the wood has been in an unheated shed for years, it is not dry enough to work and should be put through a kiln once I have rough dimensioned it.

Why would wood stored in an unheated shed for many years not be dry enough to work? What should I look for in a moisture meter reading? What options do I have short of a commercial kiln?

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

#2

Clint Searl

What happens in Seattle.....

Clint Searl

.....stays in Seattle, unless it's gonna end up in Death Valley.

Clint

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

#3

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Likely, but

Put you meter on known dry wood in your shop. Compare that reading with the walnut. If they're close, let it sit in your shop for a week or so, then go to work. Walnut being about the most stable domestic hardwood we have, you should be fine.

You do not need to put it in a kiln.

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

#4

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

del schisler

depends on what you are going to build. Check it and see . I don't belive i would spend money on kiln dry . Bring it in the shop and get it out of the weather . Let it get used to the shop moisture . Than check it again . If the product's are for you and going in your house where heat. Than check the moisture . If the wood is real high moisture like 15 percent that is kind of high . I would try and get it down under 10 percent if it were me. If you can take it inside the house for a while check moisture now and again and see what changes you are getting . If you get it kiln dried it will pick moisture but not back where it started . So maybe money spent and not needed to be. ?? This is my opion . I have cut lot's walnut and stored and bought lumber from under tin roof's and shead's . And never a bad item i built. Their be more opioni's i am sure but this worked for me. Now if this was oak i would kiln dry that wood good luck

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

#5

assorted advice.........

Bill Tindall

Facts: given enough time, and your lumber has done the time, the wood will equilibrate to the humidity of the shed. Just to give an couple of examples: if the humidity of this "shed" is 90% at 50 degrees the lumber will have equilibrated to 21% moisture content. But if the shed is 50 % relative humidity at 80 degrees the lumber would equilibrate to 9% moisture content. And if you then bring it inside in Minnesota where the room is 70 degrees and relative humidity 10% the moisture content at equilibrium will be but 2%. And if you move the Minnesota lumber back to the WA shed it will go back up to nearly 21%. (Data from Encyclopedia of Wood.)

Opinions: I would not send lumber to kiln. The chances of finding a kiln that will reliably dry 12/4 lumber is nil. (This may be the first time on WC that I have advised to not KD lumber. There is just too much risk when it is over 8/4)

What do you intend to use the lumber for? If you are carving legs a high moisture content won't matter much. If the lumber will be used in a situation where shrinkage would cause some sort of failure you will need to move the lumber to some pace that is warm with moderate relative humidity and leave it there some weeks.

A good rule of thumb: before using lumber it is best to have it at the moisture content it will be where ever it is going to live as furniture. It is irrelevant equilibrating to shop conditions unless shop conditions are close to living room conditions.

Under the bed and behind the couch are great places to equilibrate rough cuttings to living space conditions.

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

#6

Walnut Answers

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

The walnut will be used to make "Maloof-inspired" rocking chairs. The single biggest piece is the seat at about two foot square and 2 inches around the perimeter but, hollowed out in the "seat". All the other parts end up being fairly small with lots of wood removed in the sculpting process.

I just don't know enough about wood to understand why wood stored in Seattle in an environment just like my unheated garage for all those years (ten to twenty years) would need to be kiln dried.

I have just checked each rough sawn board with a Lignomat mini-LIGNO DX/C on the end, edge and face and got consistent readings from 11 - 14 % MC. It has been in my garage since Monday.

Your opinions are important to me because I was told if I did not kiln dry my chair would "blow up".

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

#7

Dale Lenz

IMO

Dale Lenz

There's no need to KD the walnut unless you see insect activity or to speed up the drying process. As a general rule of thumb, is that it take 2.5 times as long to dry wood every time you double the thickness. I dry outdoor one inch stickered wood 12% to < 10% in my shop in about 1 month, can speed this process up to 2 weeks if I blow air through the lumber, fans while I'm in the shop, will let you do the math.

As many have stated you need to bring the walnut into a "house enviroment" and sticker stack for several month and then enjoy building you a great Maloof R. chair.

Would love to see a picture process of building the chair.

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

#8

Re: Walnut Answers

Barry Irby

Doug, Bill knows far more about this than I do and I agree with him. Over time wood equilibrates to the surroundings it is in. It reaches a point where it MC is about 1/5 the RH of the surrounding air. If you store it in an area where the Humidity is very high, near 100%, it will eventually reach something near 20% MC. If you store it where the RH is nearer 20% it will approach 4%. I doesn't mater if the air is in Tucson or Seattle. What matters is the RH of the air, Wherever it is, but I think Seattle generally is more humid than Tucson. Its also important to note it the RH. We think winter air is dry, but outdoors, it often has a fairly high RH, but bring it in and warm it up and the RH goes WAY down.

If I were you I would start working on the chair and bring the pieces into the space where the chair will be as you process them. (There is often a piece of furniture in its immature form hiding behind my sofa.) If your shop is heated and cooled very similar to your house, that will be fine, but if it is like mine and poorly heated, not so good. I move slowly on my projects because of other demands on my time, but I use that to the advantage of the wood. I would rough out that chair and let it rest behind the sofa for a few days. Im Aight partially carve some of the pieces, leaving them oversized and let them rest before starting to finish them. This has two advantages. Sometimes wood has internal stresses and carving away major parts of it may allow the remainder to warp either form the stresses or from additional drying. Leaving them a little "fat" give you the chance to correct.

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

#9

Keep that walnut out of the kiln!

Jesse Cloud

There's no point in kiln drying that wood. Kiln drying will lessen the intensity of the colors. Air dried walnut is my favorite wood.

Be mindful that with thick wood, like 12/4, the inside may well have a different MC than the outside. That's mainly a problem when you resaw - expect to see some cupping after resaw. Suggest you cut it a little fat, let it sit for a couple of days then do your final milling.

A Maloof chair is perfect for this kind of wood, as the pieces are left large while doing the joinery and then sculpted to form, so a little bend or cup can just be sculpted out.

Please share some pics of the work in progress!!

Re: Is my walnut dry enough?

#10

Re: assorted advice.........

FredD

"It is irrelevant equilibrating to shop conditions unless shop conditions are close to living room conditions."

I disagree with that for a host of reasons , not the least of which RH in a clients house miles and even states away do not lend themselves to accurate predictions of moisture in the air.

What does , at least for me and it has not failed me, is to keep the lumber in the shop dry and warm which keeps it at 6% MC or slightly less.

Knowing this to be a unchanging condition allows me to design the project for future MC and any change will be due to expansion, not shrinkage , so the allowances for expansion always are taken into consideration and shrinkage and the following failure of joints does not happen.

Even if I know the habitat's ambient moisture content for where the piece will live , I still work with dry lumber, it is a waste of money to pay for dry wood , store it in a hostile environment, allow it to acquire ambient MC which can easily be 15% for lumber in a unheated shed and then have it go all to hell as it shrinks and destroys the finished piece.

Even Hardwood flooring is brought into the house one to two weeks before it is installed to allow for acclimation.

My shop environment is bone dry , my house climate is not for obvious reasons.

FredD