Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???
Tim Greif - West of Chicago
I've seen repeated references here and on other forums warning of the dangers of not having a professional do this or that type of work or not having it inspected because the insurance company won't pay if it results in damage to your home. I've always considered this to be well meaning but rather unfounded advice exaggerating the consequences. The issue resurfaced again below in the tankless water heater thread.
I have not been able to find any evidence of a homeowner being denied damage claim coverage because of something they did themselves. Let's not get into the discussion of commercial properties or personal properties being used in a commercial manner because they play by an entirely different set of rules.
It is my understanding that insurance companies do indeed cover damages due to homeowner actions, due either to their inept DIY skill or their complete lack of knowledge of what they are doing. Inspections and adherence to code has little bearing on anthing. They don't deny claims due to stupidity, ignorance or lack of proper skill. They MAY deny coverage if they can prove intentional arson or damage, but that is very difficult to prove.
Let's please stop using this reference to denial of insurance coverage as a reason for not doing this or that to code or not getting it inspected. Yes, it's prudent advice to do things properly and safely. And yes, it's good common sense. But not following that advice will not result in you and the family ending up penny-less with a burned down house and no insurance coverage.
Consider the poor hapless novice woodworker that unknowingly tosses his BLO or Watco soaked rags in a pile on the wood table in the kitchen (it happened to my neighbor) and causes a house fire. The insurance company will not deny coverage, even though it was clearly the homeowner's fault, right?
If I'm wrong about this, please please give us some real facts to support otherwise. Below are some related links.
Electrical Link 1
Electrical Link 2
Electrical Link 3





