Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

Posts

Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#1

Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I've seen repeated references here and on other forums warning of the dangers of not having a professional do this or that type of work or not having it inspected because the insurance company won't pay if it results in damage to your home. I've always considered this to be well meaning but rather unfounded advice exaggerating the consequences. The issue resurfaced again below in the tankless water heater thread.

I have not been able to find any evidence of a homeowner being denied damage claim coverage because of something they did themselves. Let's not get into the discussion of commercial properties or personal properties being used in a commercial manner because they play by an entirely different set of rules.

It is my understanding that insurance companies do indeed cover damages due to homeowner actions, due either to their inept DIY skill or their complete lack of knowledge of what they are doing. Inspections and adherence to code has little bearing on anthing. They don't deny claims due to stupidity, ignorance or lack of proper skill. They MAY deny coverage if they can prove intentional arson or damage, but that is very difficult to prove.

Let's please stop using this reference to denial of insurance coverage as a reason for not doing this or that to code or not getting it inspected. Yes, it's prudent advice to do things properly and safely. And yes, it's good common sense. But not following that advice will not result in you and the family ending up penny-less with a burned down house and no insurance coverage.

Consider the poor hapless novice woodworker that unknowingly tosses his BLO or Watco soaked rags in a pile on the wood table in the kitchen (it happened to my neighbor) and causes a house fire. The insurance company will not deny coverage, even though it was clearly the homeowner's fault, right?

If I'm wrong about this, please please give us some real facts to support otherwise. Below are some related links.

Electrical Link 1

Electrical Link 2

Electrical Link 3

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth??? *LINK*

Moses Yoder

My experience with insurance companies is if they can find any excuse not to pay then they won't pay. They will not pay to put shingles on my parents house that were damaged by hail. Below is a link to a legitimate claim that was filed by a homeowner and the company refuses to pay therefore does not have to pay. They would have to be sued in order to make them pay, and the homeowner would have to hope that they win. Then the company would probably just file bankruptcy. By law, if I add electiral wiring to my house I am supposed to get a permit and then have it inspected when it's done. If I just run a wire under the carpet over to another wall and add an outlet to plug a light into it and the house catches fire, do you really think the insurance company would pay the claim?

P.S. Don't even get me started on lead paint laws.


The character of insurance companies

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#3

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

Howard Norman

Moses, several years ago my home in Scottsdale, AZ had hail damage to the roof which caused water damage to an inside wall. My insurance company paid for the roof repair, shingles in that area, painting the damaged wall and the replacement cost of a new thermostat that was on the damaged wall.

Last year my son & DIL had hail damage to their residence and to a rented house nearby. The insurance company paid the depreciated value of the roof immediately upon inspection. After new roofs were installed they paid the difference between the deprecated roof value and the cost of the new roof.

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#4

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

Howard Norman

I agree. By the way I can't get your links to work.

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#5

Hmmmm.... Hey Ellis, where'd my links go?

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I edited my original message for some typos, and evidently the embedded links disappeared. Any way to bring them back?

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#6

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

FredD

Moses , what you say in general was my experience as a General Contractor in California.

I observed many cases of people denied claims for many unfounded reasons and many were denied for legitimate reasons such as using a unvented Kerosene space Heater in their homes and starting a fire.

This particular cause for denial of claims is well founded , because the State specifically bans the use of such space heaters in a residence.

Even though every Hardware in the state sold them for that purpose.

Most if not all insurance companies will use a Fire Department Arson report as a basis for denial of claims in a suspicious fire and this is hard to overturn , even in a lawsuit.

Weather related damage coverage is standard , though you may have to specify Hail damage to have it covered.

Here in Kansas wind and hail coverage is automatic in policies.

In California intentionally ignoring Health and Safety code requirements which can be shown to be the reason the damage or death occurred will in many cases let the Insurance company legally invoke clauses prohibiting this type of activity and deny claims.

In addition that information is added to a pool of information maintained by Insurance companies to access risk on future coverage.

Things like roof shingle damage replacement varies from company to company around here , some only replace the damaged part of the roof covering and some will replace the whole roof covering, which is the better way to go , from a aesthetic and life of the shingles standpoint.

In California , hair splitting is a art form of business in Insurance claims, for instance if your home foundation is damaged in a flood , flood insurance pays to replace it, if the same damage occurs over a period of time, they will say damage is caused by settling of the foundation and not covered.

This one issue has been the underlying contention in thousands of lawsuits out there and in many cases finding for one or the other party is a crap shoot

FredD.

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#7

Ellis Walentine

Re: Hmmmm...I'll look into it

Ellis Walentine

Test link to home page.

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#8

Re: Hmmmm.... Hey Ellis, where'd my links go?

Dan Donaldson

>I looked at the message, and it looks like the edit wiped out the links. I don't think there is a way to retrieve them.

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#9

Ellis Walentine

Sure enough

Ellis Walentine

I just replicated your issue. I'm awaiting some help from our guru in Germany.

Ellis

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#10

Clint Searl

Caveat emptor - Read the policy

Clint Searl

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#11

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

Rick Christopherson

In my opinion, these myths get blown way out of proportion. If an insurance company is denying claims as often as some claim, it is probably a fly-by-night operation, as also suggested by the statement they will file bankruptcy if they honor a claim.

The most egregious example of stupidity resulting in a paid claim by yours truly is fire damage from a half-installed fireplace. I installed a fireplace in my living room, but began to use it before it was fully installed--thereby a major code violation, and a pretty obvious one at that. The fireplace wasn't even framed in yet, but was sitting (freestanding) on a plywood pedestal with exposed ductwork above it. There was no hearth in front of the fireplace.

A large ember rolled out of the fireplace and melted a hole in the carpet while we were out of the room. I didn't think it was a valid claim, but contacted my agent anyway. He said, "of course that's covered" and sent out an appraiser the next day. He specifically told me that if they refused to pay for stupidity, they wouldn't have any claims. The appraiser didn't even comment on the fact that the fireplace wasn't properly "installed", wasn't permitted, and wasn't to code. They replaced carpet for the entire room.

The other stupid claim was that I had a leaking refrigerator water line for months, but didn't notice it until I went into a lesser used area of the basement and noticed the standing water. This should have been noticed and corrected long before any damage could have occurred, but that was never even questioned.

They didn't hesitate on the claim itself, but they did originally argue the extent of the claim. Nevertheless, with very little arguing with the appraiser, they paid for new hardwood flooring for the entire floor. More surprisingly, they also paid for the prototype DeWalt DW746 and DW7461 sliding tablesaw sitting in storage in my basement due to the rust on the cast iron.

It is one thing for an insurance company to argue the extent of the claim, and that will happen. However, it is entirely a different matter for them to deny the claim altogether. If that is happening, then it is time to re-examine who you pay your premiums to.

With the exception of a lightning strike, virtually all fires are the result of human error, yet they are still considered valid claims. In my opinion, these doomsayers are just that; doomsayers. The alleged reports of rejected claims are probably omitting critical pieces of information in their stories.

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#12

I thought I posted a response to this????

Barry Irby

Didn't Mark Mandel and I both post a response to this? Where did mine go? It was brilliant and the end all answer on the topic. And no, I won't repeat it. :D

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#13

Re: I thought I posted a response to this???? *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Look Down ;)


Link

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#14

Myth

DouginDenver

The short answer is, it's a myth. But this thread shows how such myths get started. If a hail damage claims is denied, it would usually be because the inspoector says he saw no actual hail damage (happened to me). Likewise, arson is not covered, but that's a totally different issue from whether a fire from a stupidly placed space heater is covered - it is. Negligence is covered, intentionally burning down your house is not. If you are driving 85 miles an hour and cause a bad accident, your insurance will still pay. Everything, of course, is subject the terms of the policy, but the terms of most policy clauses are identical - insurance companies do not draft them typically - they come from a central source. You may have certain exclusions - like floods if you live in New Orleans - but the basic coverage declarations are pretty much all the same.

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#15

Reminds me of a roofer I met...

John in NM

He was re-roofing most of the houses in my neighborhood when I lived in Tucson. Houses were all about 15 years old, coincidentally the average life span of asphalt shingles in that climate. Basically he was telling all the homeowners that they had hail damage and could get their insurance to pay for the job. It seemed to be working because he did a lot of those roofs.

I don't know if people's insurance paid or not, because I did not participate in this - mostly because I considered it to be on the wrong side of a grey area between right and wrong, but also because my roof was only 3 years old. But that didn't stop the roofer from telling me I needed a new one and that my insurance company would pay for it :D

Re: Denial of Insurance Claim - Fact or Myth???

#16

Re: Reminds me of a roofer I met...

FredD

The discrepancies from case to case could be largely due to the Agent and whether he is a broker or a company man.

A couple of examples come to mind ; A retired Plumber I grew up with and was in several business's in this area until he retired , had the same hail storm we had in 1997 and he had a few dents in his shingles and two in the metal siding of a new pole barn that was his storage and was a hundred and fifty feet long,with 12 foot high sidewalls and the minor dents were in that long side.

His and mine also, State Farm Agent paid to reroof the entire house and replace all of the metal on the long side of the pole barn and allowed him to keep the metal they took off.

He believes and so do I , that due to all of his rentals and business interest's which were all insured by State Farm for a annual outlay of 40.000 dollars had more to do with the outrageous repair of non damaged property then anything else.

My case was in 1959 when I wrecked my first new car a Fairlane 500 Ford.

Tore it all to hell and the adjuster from the insurance company said they could fix it , bent frame and all , mainly because he said it lacked 200.00 dollars of enough damage to total it and replace it.

He came in the pool room that afternoon and we got to playing a few games and I bought him two or three beers and I just happened to mention how bad that car was wrecked and if I handed him the 200.00 in cash would he total it.

He said "no problem" he totaled it , Cruise Ford rolled out a another one and that is the first time I came into contact with how business is really conducted , at the tender age of 21.

FredD