Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT. Tankless Water Heater

Posts

OT. Tankless Water Heater

#1

OT. Tankless Water Heater

Jerry Draper

Other than cost of installation, what are some other negatives of this system I should consider?

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#2

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Venting for code compliance. In the context of a homeowner's insurance policy, this is NOT a DIY job. Have a license do the install or risk losing coverage in the event of a fire.

Water quality: Hard a/o acid (iron) water will have to be treated (acid should be anyway) to avoid damage to the unit.

Capacity: Make sure that the unit chosen will supply all down-stream needs. Two sinks and a shower, or a 150 gal jacuzzi will demand a whole lot more than a kitchen sink.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#3

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

Barry Irby

Mark is right. He did not mention initial cost. that's a consideration.

If you do an exterior installation, you must provide freeze protection.

Be sure the unit has the capacity to provide the flow you want. Some of them are designed to provide a certain temperature at a given flow rate and will restrict the flow to maintain the temp. so if someone turns on another faucet, your shower might slow down.

Also, large units require a huge amount of gas to fire fast enough to heat a continuous flow of water. Saw a house the other day with two units, each requiring enough gas to fire at 195, 000 BTUH. That's a combined total of nearly 400,000 BTUH. They were having to replace the gas meter to get enough gas. (Your gas furnace may be a third the size of the water heater.)

None of this addresses whether they actually save enough energy to pay off.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#4

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

R Payne

You didn't mention if you are interested in gas or electric.

When we were looking, there were a couple of things to look at. One is the flow rate needed to start the unit and keep it running. If the flow rate isn't met, the heater won't start. For us that has been an issue with the low-flow shower heads.

The other is how much hot water can be delivered at what temperature. Large units can supply enough hot water to run 2 showers and a faucet. The smaller ones may only supply one shower. If you like a really hot shower, the small units may not supply enough water hot enough for what you like. I talked to a guy who tried one and it couldn't supply enough water hot enough for his wife's liking.

We've got a gas one (propane), my brother has an electric on. We went from a standing pilot tank to an electric ignition tankless. We saw a large drop in propane usage (about 2 more months between fills of the propane tank in late winter, the house was heated by a propane furnace). My brother saw a drop of $25 to $30 a month in his electricity bill. Around the same time he put in a programable thermostat and a ceiling fan.

I have yet to see a report that showed they don't save energy. From what I've seen the payback varies from between 4 and about 10 years. Ours has a 7 year warranty on all components and 12 (I think) on select components.

ron

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#5

Ellis Walentine

Jerry, please e-mail me your correct e-mail addres

Ellis Walentine

Your notifications are bouncing and I suspect a typo. Kindly send me an e-mail so I can correct your existing messages. Next time you post, please type your correct address or don't request an e-mail notification when others reply to your post.

Thanks!

Ellis Walentine

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#6

Concur on flow rate as an issue

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Disclaimer: this is all speculative on my part so far; still doing the research as we prepare to replace the heater.

When I shower, I turn the water flow down pretty low after getting wet, and soap up that way before turning it back up to shampoo (not quite a Navy shower - I don't have that much courage - but a similar idea). I measured the flow at the low rate, and it would not be enough to fire off a tankless heater. So: consider how you use water, and do some flow tests.

When we replace our heater, we'll be going with a high efficiency tank-type heater. The high efficiency tank-type heaters seem to come out at close to the same efficiency as a tankless, from what I've read so far.

Another issue for us in our small-town area is that we get periodic power outages lasting 4-5 hours (long enough to be frustrating; not long enough to justify a generator and switchover unit). Most of the tankless heaters need electricity. Granted, so do the high efficiency tank-type heaters; but at least we'd have one tank's worth of hot water.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#7

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

Jesse Cloud

I live in an area with very hard water. The enabling principle for tankless heaters is that the water is heated in very narrow pipes with heating elements surrounding them. Solids quickly clog the pipes.

+1 on the large extra energy needs - gas or electric.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#8

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

John Veerkamp

If you are considering elec, you'll need to have much more power available. 400 AMPs at least. When I investigated it would have cost me several thousands to upgrade from my 200 Amp service. Electric only makes economic sense in a commercial setting. On the other hand the small electric,s are ideal for a remote home bar or half bath where a shower is involved. Small businesses use them regularly.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#9

we have 1 and love it...

Terry Alexander

My wife and I take separate long hot showers. So, when we built our house, we installed a tankless hot water heater for a family of 5 (just the 2 of us now). A little more expensive.....but well worth it. When I had my shower head installed I asked the plumbers to take out the water restriction "part". I like to be practically "sand blasted" by water. Even at that, we can both be in ths shower at the same time for as long as we want. Heck, we can even run the dishwasher and 2 showers.

Propane use? Negiligle....really. We have a 350 gallon propane tank and filled it up over a year ago. We still have 40% left in the tank and the only reason that dropped was we ran our propane logs several days in a row.

HTH

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#10

Re: Jerry, please e-mail me your correct e-mail ad

Jerry Draper

Ellis, my email address has changed. New address is jdraper@dtccom.net.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#11

Very good advise. Thanks to all.

Jerry Draper

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#12

One consideration

Al Goldstein

We put in a gas high efficiency water tank several years ago. The high efficiency comes from two sources. The first is extra insulation and the second is a tank thermostat with wide set points. That is, the high set point (stop heating the water) and the low set point (start heating the water) are far apart. This reduces the need to heat the water during the night or any long period when hot water is not needed. But it is a pain in a long shower or when two showers are taken close the same time. DAMHIKT

Find out what the tank thermostat set points are on your selected water tank. Manufacturers have several thermostats available with different set points. You can select a compromise between higher efficiency and a more consistent water temperature. Or, if after the tank is installed you are not satisfied with the water temperature, a different tank thermostat unit can be easily switched for the original one.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#13

Re: Why are you considering tankless?

David Hay Denver

Just curious why you're looking at a tankless water heater? Are you looking to replace an aging, existing water heater? Looking to save energy? Some other reason?

If you're looking for energy efficiency, you might look into a solar water heating system. With all of the various incentives/rebates in place right now, the cost of a solar water system is really quite reasonable (only a few thousand dollars).

David

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#14

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

Howard Norman

>Venting for code compliance. In the context of a homeowner's insurance policy, this is NOT a DIY job. Have a license do the install or risk losing coverage in the event of a fire. <

I have seen the reference of losing insurance coverage several times when various things were not done by a licensed contractor. Can anyone cite am actual case where this happened? I wonder if it is real concern or just an old wives tale. Unless an actual case can be cited I will consider it an old wives tale.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#15

Re:  Insurance Denial

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Howard,

As an attorney, I've been involved in several such cases over the years.

In one, a commercial case, my client's tenant made a modification to a loading dock heating unit which diverted heat to a different area. During a severe chill (0-5�) the sprinkler piping in the originally heated space froze and burst, flooding the building basement over a weekend, shorting out the electrical panels, and killing the main boiler. With all heat gone, the second floor of the building froze and split water pipes that poured down through the ceilings on the first floor, destroying the tenant's store and inventory. The insurance company sent their engineer in with plans of the building from the time the policy was written. Upon discovering the modification, the insurer denied coverage for the $400,000 in property damage citing the improper modification of the ductwork that a licensed contractor would either not have done or would have done differently.

Fortunately, my engineer was better than theirs. The client got his building fixed (the tenant went bankrupt), but the litigation still cost him over $50,000.

Case 2:

My son was renting a ground floor apartment in Brooklyn, but was burned out on New Years Eve last year when a light fixture, installed by the landlord's son, shorted out. The landlord's insurance company refused coverage because the fixture was improperly installed next to combustible materials rather than being done by a licensed electrician to meet code. Fortunately, my son had renters insurance that covered part of his loss, but only part.

Insurance companies are in business to make money. They don't make money by having to pay claims, and so they will look for any excuse to avoid paying.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#16

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

R Payne

You do not necessarily need bigger service for an electric tankless. My brother had an electric on installed, replacing an electric tanked unit, without having to upgrade from his 200 amp service. He has had no problems with his electric service and his house is all electric.

ron

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#17

Re:  Insurance Denial

Barry Irby

Don't want to refute what the lawyer said, but as a Home Inspector, we just had the local Fire Marshal come in a give us some training. I had two questions. What really causes fires, and do insurance companies ever deny coverage for stupid stuff done by home owners. He turned the first one around and asked us. We were guessing things like heating equipment and electrical systems. He said there were three main causes, Men, Women, and Children, probably in that order but not necessarily. On the second question, he had never heard of them denying a claim for home owner workmanship, but said they would report you to some service the insurance companies have for recording such things and cancel your insurance. You may not be able to get new insurance or have to pay through the nose for it. I think the distinction here is that in both the cases Mark mentioned there was a commercial element, either a commercial property out right or a landlord tenant situation. And you will notice the tenants insurance did pay off. It might also be that Mark in New Jersey and I am in Virginia. I know nothing about the Code in NJ, but in VA home owners can do their own work, but it is still required to meet the code and it must be for their personal use.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#18

Re:  Insurance Denial

Howard Norman

Barry, I also have never heard of an insurance company refuse to pay a claim that was caused by the homeowners work here in AZ. I have heard of the reporting of some claims to some insurance industry clearing house but have never substantiated sure referrals. I would guess that such denials would get appealed first to the State insurance commission, at least that is what I would do if it happened to me. I guess I should ask the question of a friend of mine here that worked early in his career as an Insurance claim adjuster and later on was the Attorney General for the State of Arizona.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#19

Uninspected work vs. contractor

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In this part of California, anyway, it's legal for a homeowner to work on his own house. We've gotten permits for our work, and the city inspector has been supportive and helpful. I know not all inspectors are as good as ours (in fact, some of his predecessors sure weren't), but I would be prepared to argue any attempted denials of coverage now: the city approved the work.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#20

Same Here

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I replumbed my entire house, from the well to the last faucet. I also built my own decks, and did all the wiring in my shop and office. Each time, however, I had my work inspected and a CofO issued, which is a requirement under my local laws.

If you have the experience and skills to do your own work, do it, but don't leave it at that. Have your job inspected and approved and have the documents to show for it.

My own homeowners policy has an exclusion for damage caused by illegal repairs and alterations. I read that kind of stuff and take it seriously.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#21

Re: Uninspected work vs. contractor

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

I agree with Bill...the home owners here in CA can do their own work...provided they are capable of doing it properly and according to the local Codes.

Back in the 80s I decided to put on a side building to be my "garage/workshop. Drew up sketch and took it to the Building Dept for approval. they made a couple changes and I got the permit. And I decided to replace the 100 amp elec service to upgrade to 200 amp. Had elec turned off at 730am; ripped out the existing boxes, and discovered the wiring wires undersized for the days requirements for a 200 amp service box...so I added a junction box up above the main new box and drew down proper wiring to the new panel. Was sitting at the panel wiring in the circuit breakers...when I noticed someone standing behind me...turned and saw it was the local building inspector. He had been watching me for about 20 minutes and said he saw I had the knowledge and was properly doing the work...went over and signed off on the inspection list. I still had another 2hrs of work to do. Elec service was turned back on at 330pm when wife came home from work.

Also elec co came and reinstalled new lines from the pole to the roof service pole.

Re: OT. Tankless Water Heater

#22

Re: Uninspected work vs. contractor

FredD

With all due respect Joseph, since I don't know where you live in Ca , that used to be the case in most counties except San Mateo and San Francisco counties which suffered the greatest in the 1906 quake and are paranoid in the extreme about who does what to a residence.

You mentioned the eighties and in the Bay area where I lived for thirty years and did very well as a B1 General Contractor, that is when the counties started to follow the example of San Francisco and San Mateo counties and some like Contra Costa county , where I lived for the last ten years refused to allow a home owner to pull any permit , regardless of whether it was a building permit for a New Structure or any of the Mechanical , Electrical or Plumbing single permits.

The underlying reason is .., not what you think , you could be perfectly capable and in, years gone by , allowed the permit and allowed to do the work, like Bill H. says.

The various Building departments decided based on plenty of evidence, that once the Homeowner walked out with a permit , in many cases he hired the work done by unlicensed people , like his Brother-in Law .

Also a major factor in that decision was the problem caused by unlicensed workers who couldn't get a permit because it was required that they be licensed, they then would ask the homeowner to pull it themselves , thereby according to the unlicensed shoddy worker, doing so would save the Home Owner money .

That was the farthest from what generally happened that you can imagine.

Rather you want to acknowledge it or not , Home building and Remodeling work and associated Engineering and Architectural work , has to be licensed by the

State.

That requirement is obvious to most and the ones who want to ignore it sooner , rather then later, run afoul of the Contractors License Board in Sacramento and the current penalties are severe.

You may say many Contractors do shoddy work ,some do and will be eventually run out of business, it's a crapshoot if you don't check out the worker before you hire him , instead of running to the Board and a Lawyer after the fact.

When I started in Business , the bond required by the State was 1,500 dollars every two years. Now I understand it's 20,000 dollars, that has a tendency to winnow out the Wanna-Be's , but it is imperfect like all Human endeavors.

FredD