Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

G&G marries Stickley

Posts

G&G marries Stickley

#1

Clint Searl

G&G marries Stickley

Clint Searl

A new offering from the Stickley Company that integrates G&G with Stickley.

Clint


Re: G&G marries Stickley

#2

Ellis Walentine

I like it, but...

Ellis Walentine

...somehow it doesn't seem right for the manufacturer of an iconic style to be borrowing so directly from another iconic style. Sure is a nice blend, though -- the form of Stickley and the decoration of G&G.

Ellis

Re: G&G marries Stickley

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

This is "close" to somthing I was going through design wise a few years ago,,

I need to shred my unused notes next time....

:-)

Jim

Re: G&G marries Stickley

#4

Clint Searl

Re: I like it, but...

Clint Searl

The Stickley camp might consider it a wee precious and overwrought while the G&G'ers think it's an attempt to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear. I've played in both fields and am not too keen on the blend.

Clint

Re: G&G marries Stickley

#5

Alice Chalmers marries John Deere

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Clint,

A marriage made in Heaven! I was never one to get hung up on design exclusivity. I like the items very much, and I am unanimous in that. ;)

George

Re: G&G marries Stickley

#6

Re: G&G marries Stickley

Mark Salomon

I like both G&G and Stickley (at least the early stuff) but this isn't my cup of tea. The side looks pretty good but the flared leg looks all wrong for G&G. The swept back looks too modern to be either, IMO.

Re: G&G marries Stickley

#7

Re: G&G marries Stickley

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Seems a bit "busy" for my taste. The overall design gets a little lost in the details. They have a finish option for "rubbed through" black paint that IMHO just makes matters worse.

That said, some of the pieces in the "collection" are well done. The Morris chair is not a highlight in my view.

Re: G&G marries Stickley

#8

Ellis Walentine

Ask for a royalty

Ellis Walentine

I recall your G&G Morris chair, Jim. Wanna post a picture of the finished chair again?

Ellis

Re: G&G marries Stickley

#9

Jim in Burlington Ont.

My G&G Morris Chair *LINK*

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Ellis,

This is the chair I made for Eileen. While it's not the same as Stickley's design I was kind of taken back by some of the design applications I had considered in mine ( I actually had a very similar side application and apron shapes drawn out before I chose my double cloud life returns and clean aprons with carves lifts).

I have also had the height of the back cushion adjusted since I made the initial pictures.

Eileen says what she likes the most about the chair is that the proportions fit her perfectly, that makes me very happy.

Take care,

Jim


My G&G Morris Chair

Re: G&G marries Stickley

#10

Steam Punk?

John M in Mid Mich

Borders on steam punk if you ask me. But then, I LIKE steam punk.


img

Re: G&G marries Stickley

#11

Ellis Walentine

Love it!

Ellis Walentine

Re: G&G marries Stickley

#12

Not for me, thanks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Just seems way too busy: that routed detail on the bottom of the legs, the similarly raised line on the bottom cross member of the chair side and apron of the hassock, and the wee porthole in the side splat of the chair. Stickley and Greene & Greene were both good at strong but simple details - the simplicity was as important to the impact as the strength.

I can enjoy over the top design details in the right piece - I love some of the Art Nouveau pieces that look like they'd been in the jungle too long and are being strangled by the vines - but this one's details are disharmonious.

To me, the chair looks like the designer had too many of those new 31-oz (almost a quart!) Starbucks coffees.