Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

hvlp opinion's

Posts

hvlp opinion's

#1

hvlp opinion's

jacomb

After brushing woodwork all these years I'm thinking about buying a hvlp, I would use this on mostly house trim work and I use waterbore poly. Any help?

Re: hvlp opinion's

#2

Clint Searl

Consider airless

Clint Searl

Re: hvlp opinion's

#3

Re: hvlp opinion's

frank ashmore

I have been using HVLPs for over 20yrs.Everything gets finished with it.I wouldnt even want to think about finishing a job by brush.This is my 3rd system.The 1st 0ne was to small and on the cheapish side ,the next was a Graco pro system, it just wore out after 17 yrs.

Bought a new Graco Pro Finish setup last year.For me HVLP is the only way, it saves so much TIME.

Re: hvlp opinion's

#4

Re: Consider airless

FredD

yes. airless

FredD

Re: hvlp opinion's

#5

Re: hvlp vs airless cost?

Gary Smyth

After reading I went to visit airless. The price varies from, say, $200 to $3,500 for airless and about $650 for hvlp. Is there a level one would expect to pay to get similar results. Can a $200 airless push through all of the finishing products at the same quality as a $600 airless or hvlp? If it is for occasional use vs. full time refinishing is that the value of the higher cost over the lower end , or is it something else?

Re: hvlp opinion's

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

HVLP is fine finish, but...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...after 15 years in the painting biz, it really doesn't save me any time--it just produces a better finish, especially if I consider time spent doing area prep: cleaning, masking, etc. If I want a better finish and to get it faster, airless or air-assisted airless is the way to go. With the correct tip and pressure, airless can also be more efficient in material usage and put much less into the air, and thinning is almost never required.

Jason

Re: hvlp opinion's

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: hvlp vs airless cost?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Don't waste your time with a $200 airless. They're all junk, meant to be used maybe a half-dozen times at most. However, $600 will get you a very versatile machine that will spray all finishes short of block fills and other heavy, industrial coatings. Use a fine-finish tip and you can even spray very thin materials like semi-transparent stains. Clean it well after every use, don't leave it pressurized for extended periods of time, don't let any fluid in it freeze or store it for long periods with water in it, and it will last you a good long time. Even if it does go south, usually a packing kit and/or a new prime valve will solve most problems for less than $100 if you're not a foreigner to turning wrenches.

HVLPs have their place, but they're pretty much worthless for anything more than the smallest projects or thinnest materials.

Jason

Re: hvlp opinion's

#8

Re: hvlp vs airless cost?

frank ashmore

I have never used an airless system.Is the transfer that much better with airless ?I do almost nothing but lacquer finishes . If customer wants something painted I will primer it for them and they get their own painter .I have finished all kinds of jobs from kitchens to fireplace mantels (alot of them)to armoires to jewelery boxes.My system has a 2 gal pressue pot that allows me to finish larger jobs without reloading .What would make an airless system better for larger jobs?

Re: hvlp opinion's

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: hvlp vs airless cost?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Transfer efficiency CAN be better, with proper settings and technique. The only way to get a really high transfer efficiency with HVLP is to turn it down so low that it's practically worthless for anything larger than a shoebox.

The biggest advantage of airless is speed. Even with tiny fine-finish tips, the material output is several times that of an HVLP. Say you're finishing a large bookcase or entertainment center. It might take 30 minutes or more to apply one coat, with the initial areas already drying and collecting overspray. With an airless, coating a bookcase might take 2-3 minutes.

Keep in mind here that I'm talking about true HVLP--which means an air pressure of less than 10 PSI. Even when I have used our HVLP, I turn it up past that by quite a bit so that I can bump the fluid pressure also, getting more overall output (and speed).

Jason

Re: hvlp opinion's

#10

Re: hvlp vs airless cost?

frank ashmore

I have a friend who is a pro.painter .Im gonna have to see if he will let me try one out .

Re: hvlp opinion's

#11

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: hvlp vs airless cost?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Depending on what you're spraying, you'll want one of the following fine finish tips (I use Graco's RAC 5 and RAC X, which will have green "handles" on the tip for fine finish): 210, 310, 212, 312

The last two numbers on each of those designations is the orifice size in thousandths of an inch (e.g., a 212 tip has an orifice of 0.012").

The first number is half the pattern size in inches at 12" from the surface (e.g., the same 212 tip will have a 4" spray width at 12").

I almost never use an airless at that distance--that causes LOTS of overspray. Typical is 4", maybe 6-8" if I'm looking for a light coat or finer finish. Overlap is typically about 1/3-1/2 of each pass, sometimes as much as 2/3 or as little as 1/4 (less overlap when laying very heavy coats).

Jason

Re: hvlp opinion's

#12

Re: hvlp vs airless cost?

jacomb

Thanks for the info, I have experience with airless, perhaps you have driven over or under one of my bridges or alongside a pile auger retaining wall. But, I'm finishing fluted casing and although it takes awhile to brush out the clean up is rather easy. Cleaning a airless is much more involved and consumes alot more material. I was thinking along the lines of a cheap hvlp that would only see limited use. Of course you get what you pay for!

Re: hvlp opinion's

#13

Re: hvlp vs airless cost?

FredD

Jason has pretty much made the case for why Airless is far better and faster then HVLP .

My second Graco airless about $995.00 not counting the Silver model gun and stacked orifice reversible tips I use exclusively for Lacquer.

This model is considered a small airless by Graco standards.

The first one lasted twenty years and still works though it is primitive in design compared to the one I use now.

Nearly all of the Lacquer containers I use , are five gallon cans and that makes the Airless a nonstop gun for any size project.

Cleanup for me is fast and except when I break the gun down and grease it , I just run thinner though until it is clean.

I also never use that hose for anything but Lacquer which helps in the cleaning process.

When you consider that the material is being delivered at about 3,000 to 3,500

PSI , you will see the difference is insurmountable for HVLP.

By having only one hose running to the gun and the gun not having a cup attached to it makes for easy spraying inside cabinets and tight places where a HVLP cannot easily go.

On the other hand if you only doing relatively small projects and time is not a factor , then HVLP may be the right equipment for you.

One caveat about Airless equipment , it is easy if your not paying attention to inject yourself with sprayed material , which requires a immediate visit to the ER.

That being said , I have managed over the years to avoid that predicament.

FredD