Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

removing chip collection from shop

Posts

removing chip collection from shop

#1

removing chip collection from shop

retiredguy

Hi,

I began lurking at Badger Pond and then switched to this site. I must admit it has been several years since I have spent much time here. But I'm back, now and have joined.

I built my shop off the back of the garage before I retired, knowing that I would be spending a fair amount of my time in retirement woodworking.

Ten years have gone by and now I'm thinking about making some major changes to the layout. When I built the 22 by 26 foot shop in 2000, I figured I would have plenty of room. Many tools and many accessories later, I find I'm really cramped for space.

What I'm thinking about doing this spring is building another small building adjacent to the shop to house my dust collection equipment and, perhaps, my air compressor.

I would be interested to know if anyone else has done or attempted to do this and what problems were encountered.

My shop is both heated and air-conditioned.

Thanks in advance.

Re: removing chip collection from shop

#2

Re: removing chip collection from shop

McKay

The best thing that I ever did was to move the compressor out of the shop. I live in a cold area and find that the compressor will throw the breaker when it turns on. I built a box of 1" pink ridged foam framed with 2x2s. I then put a light globe in the box to keep the compressor warm. Works like a charm. I would like to move the DC out, but I have yet to figure an easy way to separate the chips, and return the heated air to the shop. In my situation, the DC is on the north end of my shop and accessing it to dump it would be a major pain if I were to move it out doors.

Re: removing chip collection from shop

#3

It depends

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Depending upon where you live an local codes regarding out buildings you should have no problem relocating your compressor.

The DC is another problem all together. In order to work it has to move lots of air. This air will be either heated or cooled depending upon the season. Replacing this air with conditioned air (hot or cold) will run your HVAC system harder. Look at the cfm rating on your DC and determine if you want to heat or cool this amount of air every minute it runs from the outside temp to the desired shop temp. It might be worth it if you only run a few minutes of every hour.

The other problem is distance. The longer your DC piping runs become the less efficient your system will be. Running your DC to a remote building and returning filtered air to the shop saves the heating/cooling costs but will decrease efficiency and not do anything to reduce the noise level in your shop.

Lee

Re: removing chip collection from shop

#4

Re: removing chip collection from shop

Yonak

If you have to empty or replace dust collection bags, having them out of sight may cause you to forget to change them until it's too late. If it were me, I certainly would forget.

Re: removing chip collection from shop

#5

JL

Re: removing chip collection from shop

JL

You don't say where you live - but I'll assume as you have heated space that you live in a cold climate.

If you "heat" this new outbuilding so that is above freezing - your air compressor should do fine. We had an air compressor ice up once. Not a pretty sight - of course the shed had gotten down to ~10 degrees F.

As far as your dust collection system - if you have a means of returning your conditioned air to the shop - it should work. As an example, I could have put my cyclone outside - if I had the filter portion inside.

If you have a double bagger or a cartridge system - you would have to incorporate a return into the common wall and insulate the space enough so that you wouldn't lose too much heat/cool.

Re: removing chip collection from shop

#6

Re: removing chip collection from shop

retiredguy

Thanks to all who responded.

I live in Wisconsin, so both cold and heat are factors.

I was aware of the need to return air from the DC system back to the shop.

A little more background. The place where I want to build the building is right next to the shop, on the northwest corner. Until this fall, that spot housed an outdoor, wood burning stove, that I used to heat the shop.

The stove worked very well, maybe a bit too well at times (too much heat), but it did emit a fair amount of smoke, especially when started. I live in a village. There was no ordinance prohibiting its installation in 2006, but there was one soon after. To make a long story short, one of my neighbors finally came to me in person last fall to complain about the stove, and, being a good neighbor, I removed it.

As a result, I now have two openings in the wall of the shop. One served as the cold air return for the stove and the other the hot air. My thinking was these openings would allow enough heat to bleed into the closely connected new building to keep the temp in it above freezing in the winter. And the holes would allow air circulation the DC system needs.

Both the DC system and the compressor are located in the northwest corner of the shop, so piping and connecting wouldn't be very difficult.

Since the wood stove is gone, I'm back to heating with baseboard electric. The building is very well insulated, and I keep the temp in the shop at 55, so the cost of heat is very tolerable.

After hearing about the compressor freeze-up, I may have to enlarge the holes.

Thanks again for all the advice.

Re: removing chip collection from shop

#7

Re: removing chip collection from shop

Barry Irby

I live in VA so my winter conditions are probably not as severe as yours. I moved my bagger DC and compressor to a exterior closet. I have no problems with it except I need a better way to monitor the DC bag. My shop is small, a one car garage and heated with a small electric heater. Heated being something of an exaggeration, perhaps chill knocked off would be more accurate. I have blast gates that turn the DC on when the machine comes on and off when it goes off. I notice very little heat loss unless I run the DC for a long time. I am very pleased to have moved them outside the shop. The reduction in noise alone is worth it, let alone the increase in space.

I wish I could just blow the dust out into the woods and not have a bag, but the neighbors wouldn't put up with it.

Re: removing chip collection from shop

#8

Re: removing chip collection from shop

retiredguy

Did you notice a reduction in dust in the shop once the DC unit was removed?

I, too, would be happy to have the noise outside the shop. My least favorite shop task is emptying the bag. I do have a can with a cyclone top that collects most of the chips, but a couple times a year I have to dump the bag.

Sounds as if I'll be putting up a new building this spring.

Re: removing chip collection from shop

#9

Re: removing chip collection from shop

Big Dave

A couple things...

I don't know what brand of DC you have, but Oneida now sells a device that alerts you to the need for emptying the bag/can. I don't remember the price, but it might be worth looking into...

One other thing you might also consider is to install a furnace-type filter on the return air from the closet to the shop. It wouldn't need replacement very often, and it will keep just a wee bit more dust from entering the shop.

Just wondering if you could wire the new addition to include another baseboard heater? If not, adding an additional 120v receptical will allow you to plug in a heat lamp in the winter/cold months to keep the room warm enough to prevent "cold starts". Remember, 100w of light equals 100w of heat. :)

Two pennies worth...

Dave

Re: removing chip collection from shop

#10

Re: removing chip collection from shop

Barry Irby

I have worked hard on my system, but kept the budget low. I have a Delta 1 1/2 hp DC that has an upper filter bag and a lower collection bag. I installed it in the shed/closet and did not put it on the roll around base. I found that the bags would get "fat" and bulge into the frame members, making it difficult to remove them and empty. I had one that managed to get its corner down onto the floor where the rain had driven in and soak up water. Seemed like it weighed 300 pounds. To make it easier I bought a cheap metal 30 gal. trash can and put the bag in that. Now I drag the can out onto a hand truck and roll it up the hill and dump it in the woods. There is about four inches between the unit and the top of the can. I try to watch for the shavings to get to the top of the can and then I dump it. The bag in the can idea is a huge improvement over just the bag.

Moving the DC out of the shop is a huge improvement in that any dust it collects is GONE. Before, I would spill some dust or some would sift out of the filter bag and fines would float out into the air. Now, all of that is outside and not in the shop. Also, I don't care what the micron rating of the filter is. Any fine dust that blows through the filter is outdoors and also GONE.

My shop got much cleaner after installing the DC and better still moving the unit out side. I have a home made air cleaner that pulls ambient air through four furnace filters and that does a lot of good. (It not all that obvious, but those filters sure get dirty and I assume that is dust I would be breathing if it were not stuck in those filters.) My biggest problem right now is my son. He is doing a considerable amount of shop work right now in finishing the house we are working on. He finds the dust collection to be annoying so he turns it off. Turned off the Ambient air cleaner. (I was stunned) Refuses to hook the suction hose to the ROS and won't even use its filter. Ah! to be young and foolish. The end result is everything in the shop is covered with dust as it used to be before the DC came along.

Re: removing chip collection from shop

#11

Re: removing chip collection from shop

retiredguy

Big Dave's furnace filter suggestion was a good one.

My DC is the 220 v Grizzly.

Barry,

I was glad to hear that your shop was cleaner after removing the DC system. The area around mine is always full of dust and I always have to content with fine dust that escapes my low-micro bags. I have a Grizzly particle filter, but still get fine dust.

Thanks again for the good info/suggestions.