Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

Posts

Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

#1

Alan Young

Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

Alan Young

I am looking to build a farmhouse styled table-Needs to be in the "Pine family"


So what are the differences if any between Sugar pine,White pine and Douglas Fir? I suppose the type that Turns on the lathe with as little "fuzz" is desirable...

-Alan

Re: Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

#2

Re: Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

FredD

Ponderosa Pine if your on the West coast , or Eastern White Pine on the other.

Old growth Doug Fir made some nice Cabinets and tables like your thinking, but not the second and third we are getting now.

FredD

Re: Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

#3

Re: Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Much Doug fir has got very strong working contrasts between early and late wood, which makes it a bear to work smoothly. Vertical grain, with fine growth rings, is still available around here (California North Coast), at hardwood prices.

I'd lean toward pine - easier to work, although a bit soft for long run durability.

Re: Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

#4

I'd say pine too...

John in NM

In addition to both points Fred and Bill made, I've gotten the worst splinters ever from Douglas fir! :D However, I may be less than impartial :D

Fred - is sugar pine another name for ponderosa? I've never worked with sugar pine, but the pieces I've handled in the yard seemed like ponderosa (with no knots :D)

Ponderosa tends to be lighter and less pitchy, I believe it has a lower structural rating all around (but that won't matter for a table). I would choose the one where you can get the clearer boards - especially for the legs.

Re: Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

#5

Re: Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

David Yoho

Alan, I don't like Douglas fir for general use for several reasons. It has the tendancy to produce splinters and the grain can be troublesome on the face of the boards where it seems to want to separate and protrude from the surface.

Around here clear furniture grade white pine is available and real nice to work with. That's what I would use unless I could get my hands on some old heart pine (and I can). That would make a super table top that would withstand most anything and look fantastic too.

Re: Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

#6

Alan Young

Thanks all-

Alan Young

Have a supplier close by with some very nice White Pine- Will be wood of choice if the project goes through.

-Alan

Re: Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

#7

Re: Thanks all-

Dick Coers

Make sure it is kiln dried. A lot of guys like to use construction grade since it is said to be kiln dried. Except construction grade is flown through the kiln and the moisture levels vary wildly. Get something around 8%. Personally, I like to use soft maple for projects like this.

Re: Sugar pine,White pine-Douglas Fir???

#8

Re: I'd say pine too...

FredD

Ponderosa Pine , known as Pinus Ponderosa and as Western Yellow Pine though I have never hear it called that, is a different tree from Sugar Pine known as Pinus Lambertiana.

Both are great woods in the Pine family and the Sugar Pine will give you large plans in old growth , resistant to the usual warping and twisting seen in other woods.

I could always tell Sugar Pine at a glance from the very white wood and the dusting of what looks a little like sugar , on and in the wood. either are great wood choice's for soft wood furniture, but finished natural , they would look different in the same piece, one yellow and one white .

The smell of either in the shop is lovely .

FredD