Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

Posts

More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

#1

More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

Virgil Johnson

It was suggested that the rollers in my planer were in stalled in reverse order or with an in feed roller in the exit position.

Below is a pic from Henry H's planer(competitors machine...thanks Henry) but is identical to mine.The rollers on my planer and Henry's machine are similar in size (within .005") and in both machines the exit rollers are serrated and .035 large in dia. than the in feed. It seems the exit roller is over driven by 2% on both machines. One theory was this overdrive is to keep the lumber from being skewed to the left by the helical in feed roller.


I've searched other wwking web sites and found at least 4 posts of the same exit roller mark problem from similar machines but no posts that identifies the root cause or that has a solution other than backing off the roller to minimize the marks so they will sand out.

As of now I'm waiting on tech support and will post their solution.

Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

#2

Now I'm more confused ..

Marv Horn

if that's possible. Viewing the pic left to right I see the anti-kickback prawls, a helical serrated FEED roller, chipbreaker, cutting head, and smooth EXIT roller. If this configureration is visually identical to yours but reversed your planer is running backwards.

Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

#3

Better picture

Henry Higginbotham

The picture had been reduced to fit WoodCentral's limits and may have lost some resolution in the process. Here's a detail from the same image:


Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

#4

Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

Gary Smyth

Are the cutters aftermarket? Is it possible that the rollers have to be cranked down to move the lumber thus making the marks because the cutters are slightly undersized?

Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

#5

Here's what I think:

Grant in Iowa

I have seen this before. In the instance I am thinking of, an guy had replaced the planer knives on his 15" planer for the first time and was getting the infeed roller marks on his planed lumber. I had a look and it turned out that he had used the manufacturers knife setting jig incorrectly and the knives were set too low. This machine was also a Grizzly, but this user error could have happened on any of the clone machines in just the same way.

I reset the knives corectly and end of problem.

It should also be said that machines with serrated infeed rollers are generally the larger non-lunchbox style machines. Of the machines of this type I have experience with, they will all leave infeed roller marks on softer woods when a very light pass is made. If you want to be able to remove .005" of material in a pass, you should consider keeping a lunchbox planer around for that purpose.

When I made the upgrade from a DeWalt 733 to my Delta 15" planer, the inability to remove a small amount of material was a problem for me. It meant I oculd no longer fit a piece to a dado precisely, and so on. Of course that can be overcome by changing methods of work, but I hit upon another solution. I installed a Wixey gauge to my planer and now I can hit the desired thickness precisely every time.

So in closing, I thought that with your new planer the knife height might need to be double checked before futher troubleshooting is warranted. I think it unlikely that the factory would have the knives set too low, but it is possible.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

#6

Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

Virgil,

While the outfeed roller on my 9 y.o. Jet planer is not completely smooth, it's very nearly so. It feels smooth if I run my fingernail around the roller, but ever so slightly serrated going lengthwise. The angled looking part of the roller is just in that one section.


Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

#7

But the problem is with the outfeed roller

Henry Higginbotham

Definitely not the infeed. See picture above of my planer, and picture from the earlier thread of the marks on the wood.

Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

#8

Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

Virgil Johnson

Thanks for the pic. Another smooth exit roller... The marks you are feeling when you run your finger nail lengthwise along the roller are from the radii of a lathe turning tool. The angled section you refer to is chatter from machining the outside dia of the roller.

Re: More on planer exit rollers. (Marks)

#9

Re: Here's what I think:

Virgil Johnson

If you want to be able to remove .005" of material in a pass, you should consider keeping a lunchbox planer around for that purpose.

Thanks for taking the time to post but as Henry mentioned the problem is not with the infeed roller and not with .005 cuts. It happens with any cut and the marks are from the exit roller.



So in closing, I thought that with your new planer the knife height might need to be double checked before futher troubleshooting is warranted.

I have the exit and infeed roller set to the factory spec now. I have tried multiple spring forces and heights below bottom dead center of the cutter head. Thanks again.