Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Dust collection and fluid mechanics

Posts

Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#1

Dust collection and fluid mechanics

Bill Tindall

Now there is an off-putting title. But in spite of it I attended the woodworking club meeting only half curious as to what I might learn about dust collection I didn't already know. I was not optimistic. Wrong!


This is how I used to pick up dust, in this case while sanding a small piece. (Large pieces get done out doors.) The arrangement was based on numerous flawed notions about how to move air from the sanding block to the hose.

What I learned: In this case a significant amount of air going down the pipe is coming from behind the face of the pipe. Well, that is useless. Additionally, and non-obviously, the kinetic energy of the air pulled from behind is reversed when this air is turned around to go down the pipe. The process wastes energy, in this case in the form of pressure drop, the bane of dust collection.

This picture shows how to properly pick up dust.

When terminating a pipe it would best terminate in something shaped like a trumpet end. Now all the air must come from in front of the pipe and none has to have its kinetic energy reversed. This arrangement has little to no pressure drop and vastly more useful air (from the thing being sanded) goes into the pipe. I was astonished how much better it worked even with this crude arrangement.

Now, if companies that sell dust collection stuff understood these principals we could buy inexpensive trumpet shaped terminations for our pipes. (Is someone at Lee Valley listening?) (Oneida does, but their trumpets are "gold plated" when plastic would do.)

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#2

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

Stephen Kirk

I'm always interested to learn more about dust collecting. It's a very confusing subject and it seems that allows everything to cost a lot of money. I'm always explaining to people who see my (simplistic) system that dust collection works the opposite of how you would think. When I reduce my 4" hose to 2 1/2" I don't increase flow, I reduce it.

We certainly need more simple applications like this. I'd love to do something like this behind my drill press. Do you think that the flow is still strong enough to pick up the large pieces that come off of a drill press?

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

Jesper, Denmark

Hi Bill,

Let's try to clarify the principles (Not principals, which are something entirely different!)

The big pressure drop in the small pipe entry is due to a very large velocity change. Essentially, the air in front is at ambient pressure and zero velocity. Inside the pipe there is a velocity and a negative pressure relative to the room. Let's call the velocity 15 m/sek and the pressure -100 mm water column.

The air flow towards the inlet of the pipe is basically a circle around the pipe center, and as you say, there is air coming from behind the opening as well.

The funnel essentially has about 10 times the opening area relative to the pipe, so the entry velocity is smaller 1/10th, and therefore the pressure drop much smaller. More air is coming from the front and the air flow is a bit larger due to the lower pressure drop. The circle of air moving towards the inlet is bigger, so there is a larger area of dust laden air moving towards the pipe.

The collection efficiency also depends on the velocity of the air moving towards the funnel. At the 1.5 m/sek stipulated above, this would be OK, but if much lower, dust will settle out before reaching the funnel.

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#4

Great Source Of The FACTS On Dust Collectio *LINK*

charlie belden

Bill Pentz is a woodworker, with a LOT of other interests. He also has some lung problems that can't tolerate the dust generated when he works wood. So - he has a real interest in dust collection and has spent a great deal of time learning all he can about it - and has put a chunk of change into equiptment to get emperical data (as opposed to anecdotal opinions) on the performance of various dust collection systems and the concepts behind them.

Go to the site attached and start with Dust Collection Basics. Knowledge is power - and this site contains a lot of knowledge.


The Best Source of DC Info I Know Of

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#5

I ain't buying' it.....

Barry Irby

I agree that Bill Pentz site has an enormous amount of useful info and we could all learn a thing or too there.

As to your set up and premise....I will take you at your word if you have experimented and seen the improvement, but I wonder....

The moving stream of air has to have enough velocity/energy to capture the sawdust particles and keep the flying until they fall out in the collection container. Your hose has a connector in the end that reduce the internal diameter. That would cause an increase in velocity from the Venturi Effect. Your premise is that some of that air is coming from behind the opening or at least not being draw across the work piece and into the hose. The hood would expand the opening and slow down the air flow across the face of the opening simply because it is ten (?) times larger. Perhaps less are would come from behind the hood, but why? What you want is an airstream across the work piece toward the hose. Perhaps laminar flow. How about going a step further and set up a hood that is big enough to set the work inside and sand in the enclosed space such tat all the air MUST come from the opposite side of the work piece? A cardboard box would do. And further, how about getting a helping hand from gravity and set up a down draft table?

I am working on one. I had the base for my DC that I was not using. Started out to make a cabinet that would ride on the base with a furnace fan or two in it that would suck an enormous amount of air down through a slotted top, filter it and return it to the shop. (No loss of heat and ac.) My shop is small and I nixed that plan for an empty base that will serve as scrap storage and a slotted top with a sloping bottom that leads to a port for my DC. This setup rolls out of the way and parks under the wing on my RAS. Next step is to make a folding hood to cover the top to help confine the dust and keep the air moving in the right direction. They use devices vaguely like this in laboratories to carry out fumes. Some sites suggest you don't really need the top, just the sides on the box need to be tall enough to let the dust settle back toward the port. I need to get this going because my son hates the hose connected to the ROS and goes down there and sands without any DC and turns the shop into a giant dust bowl. I bought one of those magic duster things, but it ran away screaming.

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#6

the problem with large chips

Bill Tindall

Large chips, like from a lathe or drill press, have a large amount of kinetic energy if they are moving very fast. They are from a lathe, less so from a drill press. So, if they are launched away from the collection port it takes a massive air flow to put enough energy into them to reverse their direction and get them going toward the collection pipe. In so many words I was told by Oneida that I couldn't afford enough blower to collect lathe chips.

Large chips are easy to sweep us so I don't get bothered by them.

Note I avoided attempting to answer your question because I don't have an answer except to try it.

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#7

note what I actually said.......

Bill Tindall

Ideally the end of the pipe should be shaped like a trumpet. Mine isn't because you can only buy gold plated trumpets from Oneida, not plastic ones from Lee Valley. I wouldn't "buy it" either if what is ideal could be bought for $5 instead of $75.

Foolishly I thought the reduced air velocity from arrangement #2 would be useless, or certainly vastly less useful than arrangement 1, and hence never tried it till attending the lecture. I was wrong. There area all sorts of things not idea about arrangement #2, such as the connections, and I didn't claim otherwise. But it is what I had to work with.

There is a Myth Buster episode where they go to FL to the place the government makes hurricanes. Sure enough, the intakes for the blowers are shaped like trumpets.

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#8

thanks for clarification

Bill Tindall

It should be apparent that neither spelling nor fluid mechanics is a strong suit. But a lot more dust is going up the pipe than ever before in spite of these limitations.

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#9

Venturi effect

John in NM

Isn't Bill's trumpet just setting up a more efficient venturi?

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#10

A source for dust hoods

wilbur

Woodcraft has this 4" x 10" hood for $15.


Alternatively, you could get this for $5 from Woodcraft, and it would be trivial to take some plywood, glue, and screws, and custom make a hood for your needs.


I used one of the $5 fittings and some scrap pine to make a custom dust collector for my Walker-Turner bandsaw. This bandsaw is from the 1940's, when dust collection wasn't an afterthought, it was a no-thought. It works really well.


Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#11

not ideal

Bill Tindall

Among the avalanche of data in the meeting was something about the style in picture 1. All I recall is that this shape is not as good as trumpets and maybe not much better than just the pipe when the coupling is considered.

We need plastic trumpets. PVC pipe can be softened and bent. I wonder if it can be softened and flanged?

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#12

Penn State Industries - Big Gulp $15.95 *LINK*

Craig Daymon

Penn State sells one, currently on sale for $15.95. Seems reasonable.


Penn State Big Gulp Dust Hood

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#13

Re: Venturi effect

AZ in Colorado Springs

I'm kind of a backyard mechanic (certainly not an engineer), but I don't think this is analagous to a venturi. A venturi, as used on a carburetor, introduces a relatively narrower opening into a space where the air is already flowing. The increase in velocity results in a decrease in pressure, and so fuel is drawn in through jets or metering rods to provide fuel for the engine. Some spray guns (and lawn fertilizer sprayers that attach to a garden hose) use this principle, as well.

Airplanes also generate lift using this principle -- shaping the airfoil so that the increase in speed of the fluid (air) takes place on top of the wing. But that's not a venturi. The airplane is thrust forward to move through the air, rather than pushing the air. (A propellor generates thrust this way -- the propellor blades are airfoils oriented vertically.)

In the dust collection analysis, the change is moving the fluid from a state of relatively static air in a large plenum (the shop) and inducing it to move into the dust collector's duct or hose. I think the problem is that the movement of static air takes the path of least resistance, and that often means a result different than you want.

In the drill press example, I've found that a shop vac hose, clamped or taped to the drill press table pretty close to the drilling point, works OK. It seems to create enough air flow to suck in even most of the chips that get flung to the far side of the bit. The farther away you secure the end of the shop vac hose from the drilling point, the more chips are left on the far side of the drilling point from the hose.

Re: Dust collection and fluid mechanics

#14

Not quite....

John in NM

Aerodynamic lift is due to Bernoulli's principle, as is the venturi effect, but lift is not due to the venturi effect. That dust is carried through the pipe at all is another aspect of Bernoulli's principle.

My point was that any air flowing through a reducing orifice would provide a venturi effect, and that basically the reason Bill's improved set up works is because the venturi is a little better. Just because the pressure drop is not being used to siphon does not mean it is not a venturi.