Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Thoughts on routers for table mounting

Posts

Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#1

Thoughts on routers for table mounting

Stephen Kirk

I'm getting ready to convert the extension wing of my table saw into a router table. Fine Woodworking just published a table upgrade I like.

Right now, I'm thinking about adding the Triton 3 1/4 HP router with a Woodpecker 7518 Plate. The Triton has built in dust collection and is reviewed as working well without a router lift. It also features above the table height adjustment and above table one wrench bit changes. The Woodpecker plate is advertised as fitting the Triton, has holes for height adjustment and it's 3/8" thick to support that extra weight.

Any thoughts an anything else I should consider? I want good dust collection and a nice powerful router with easy bit/height changes.

Steve

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#2

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

Henry Higginbotham

Unless you're really pressed for space, I'd recommend that you consider a dedicated router table. I tried the router-on-the-tablesaw-wing setup for a while, and found that the one was always in the way of the other.

The Triton is nice, once you get past that unfortunate color choice that makes it look like something from Horror Freight.

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#3

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

Dave Paine

I second the recommendation of a dedicated router table.

A table mounted router spins anti-clockwise and so the stock should be fed right to left.

I doubt the table saw fence will prove useful.

My router table has a split MDF "wearable" sub-fence mounted to the alumiunum solid fence. This would not have been practical to add to my table saw fence.

If you want good dust collection, a router table is best. I get zero dust. I built an enclosure for the router.

The Triton certainly has a lot of power. I have not found my Bosch 1617EVS to be under powered for my needs. I normally take small cuts in order to minimize tearout, so I have not felt the need for more power.

The Triton and several other models have above the table height adjustment.

I went with a router lift since I already had the router which was to be dedicated to the router table duty. I would look at how the router height is locked. Highly recommended to have a good locking mechanism. Some cuts will cause vibration. Happened to me once. Scary when the router starts to lower all by itself. Good way to create new scrap wood.

If you do go with dedicated router table, I recommend an Incra or Jess-em fence. These enable fast and very accurate fence settings. No more "nudging". Also allows for repeatable settings.

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#4

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

Chuck Jurvelin

I disagree with those who do not like extension table router mounting. I have two table saws that both have routers mounted in the extension tables and have used them extensively for many years. I also have a individual router table that I used to use, but is now dedicated to my dovetail jig and Kreg Jig. I have a homemade router fence with dust collection that is attached to each of my table saw fences with an Incra jig. This gives me a lot of varibles with adjustment and the mass of the table saws adds considerably to the stability and lack of vibration in the routers. I have made thousands of feet of moldings and raised panels and would never consider going back to my dedicated router table.

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#5

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

Stephen Kirk

I have a dedicated table at the moment. A few months ago I upgraded to a 52" Jet Xacta. So, now I have this big extension table acting as a place to put stuff. I'd like to make it more useable. I'm in a 1 car garage, so space is definitely tight. I'd like to add a bandsaw soon, and that kinda means I have to consolidate elsewhere to free up space.

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#6

ts fence

Jerry Gibbs

I stopped using the ts fence with the router because I would need it for a cut when the fence was set up for the router. Made the router fence clamp to the wing separately. Otherwise I like it. I have an older Triton with only a 1/2" collet. The collet reducer slipping has been an issue.

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#7

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

Jim Dillon

Stephen,

I can't offer any advice on the newer routers or lifts, but I love my PC 7518 mounted in my TS extension table. Have used it for 15 plus years and have no complaints whatsoever. Dust collection is built into my homemade fence so that is no problem. Even if I had the room for a separate router bench, I would would take the extension table route again. However, I do have to keep my router bits in a separate drawer. If I had to do molding or boards longer than 8 feet or so, I would be in trouble because of my TS placement. In that case a separate router bench would be handy. From time-to-time I toy with the idea of making the cute portable router bench (for my PC 690) described in Bill Hylton's "Router Magic" book, but have never gotten around to it. Anyway, my two cents.

Jim

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#8

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Stephen,

I've gone the opposite route with a dedicated shop made router table, P+C 7518 router, and a Jess-Em Mast-R-Lift. Before the lift, I had my PC-690 under the table. I gave careful consideration to shop space and the incorporation of the router station within the table saw. I saw no objection to that idea, except for the fence. I believe a seperate router fence designed for router table work is essential. The router table came as a matter of course, and I really like my set-up from both an operational and bit/accessory storage standpoint. I don't have a big beautiful cabinet saw, so there is room for my hybrid table saw and router table. I believe your saw size dictates an integral router station, provided you can employ a dedicated router fence.

George

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#9

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

Jim

I have the Triton 3 1/4 and it doesn't have the above table lift on it, only the 2 1/2. They may have redesigned it but last year the above table lift was not available.

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#10

Dale Lenz

Re: For the one man shop

Dale Lenz

A TS router table has worked great for me for over 25 yrs.

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

#11

Re: Thoughts on routers for table mounting

Mark Salomon

I had an MDF router table/table saw extension for awhile until one of the kids spilled their soda on it and it swelled up rendering it useless. I now have a cast iron router table as an extension on the right side and it works just great (and the kids have grown up solving that problem also).