Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Where to start with carving?

Posts

Where to start with carving?

#1

Where to start with carving?

dlf901

Hi all,

Now that I'm selling more of my boxes, canes, small turned boxes on my drill press, hard maple spinner dominos with box, mirrors, furniture,etc... I like to begin adding some carvings to some of other my work. I've done some wave patterns on boxes with a 3/8" carbide burr and a die grinder , but that's the extents of my experience carving.

These are some of the things I need to know:

1. What carving tools will I need? I'm not looking to buy a lot of tools to start. A small set and with a mallet to get started with. Before my father passed on, he gave me a german made set of palm carving tools and a set of italian rifflers. He said they were worth quite a bit, but I'm a tool hog. I'm sure they'll get a lot of use from them as soon as I learn to sharpen. I did buy a set of 3 FlexCut knives. They cut very well. So that is a start. I own 134 router bits. I bought them over many years. I figured the same would be true for carving tools.

2. Which are the most essential carving tools for all projects?

3. Do I buy High Speed Steel or Tempered High Carbon Steel? I know high carbon steel takes a great edge, but it doesn't last very long. Especially on hard woods.

4. What type of sharpening system will I have to invest in, or is it possible for me to build it myself?

5. What book, books, or DVD's should I start with? About 90% of these materials are at my local library.

I'd would be grateful for your input. Just remember this is my first attempt at this type of art.

Sincerely and Respectly,

David Frame

Re: Where to start with carving?

#2

Re: Where to start with carving?

john lucas

Well it sort of depends both on what you want to carve and second, on your attitude. My first serious carving was a pair of baby legs attached to a clock. (it's called the biological clock) I used a cabinetmakers rasp, a whitler type pocket knife, jewelers saw (to get inbetween the toes) and sandpaper glued to sticks. If the desire is there you will find a way to do it. You also need the patience to sneak up on it.

May years later I still don't consider myself a carver even though I make a lot of stuff. I use a combination of tools from rotary grinders to powered chisels. I think I'm pretty proficient with the rotary tools, not so with the edged tools.

I do most of my work with my original set of General brand palm tools, my Dremel with various burrs, A foredom with burrs, and some high quality wood rasps. For me it's all about the final project, not how I got there.

I am trying to learn to use the edge tools better. Less noise, less dust, there's a feeling of skill and accomplishment and pride. However they are expensive, it takes time to get them properly honed after buying one, and of course takes time to keep them sharp.

My suggestion is to just start carving with what you have. When you can see a need for a particular tool pick one up. I pick up Dremels at flea mkts and pawn shops. You can get them really cheap. I have 5 now so I don't have to change collets so much.

Re: Where to start with carving?

#3

limited advice

Bill Tindall

The carving gene is missing from my DNA. Once I realized this fact I have put aside any thought of ever carving anything. But I know plenty of carvers and have been peripheral participant of classes and demos. The one piece of advice these people have advocated is , "don't buy a carving tool set". Apparently the tools you will need depends strongly on the details of what you intend to carve, and how.

None of the carvers I know of use anything but the typical carbon steel carving tools. "High Speed Steel" covers a lot of compositions some of which may be more abrasion resistant, and some of which will not be able to be sharpened with typical abrasives. BTW, the myth that tools steels, including high speed steel, can't be sharpened to the same degree as carbon steel has been debunked long ago, but it may take diamond abrasives to achieve equivalence.

It seems that taking a class would be your best means of rocketing up the learning curve.

Re: Where to start with carving?

#4

Re: Where to start with carving?

Doug Ridley

David, Ellis asked me to answer this but it is difficult as there are so many different carving avenues. My first suggestion would be to try and locate a carving club in your area and try to attend a meeting. If you can take a class with a good carver it would be tremendously helpful as he could steer you toward the type of carving you are interested in. If you would go to a good bookstore and find a copy of Woodcarving Illustrated magazine there will be ads in there for carving classes that will be helpful. If we knew a little more about exactly what you want to carve we might be more helpful here on this forum as there are several excellent carvers who post here often.

I'm sending you an email separately which I hope helps.

Doug

Re: Where to start with carving?

#5

Re: Where to start with carving?

Tony - Memphis

I second the Woodcarving magazine. They have some really good step by step articles. Pick a project that is inline with your interests and buy the tools listed for that project. That's how I got started. I use the Pfeil tools (check the Canadian sources for good deals). I use oil stones to sharpen them. There are lots of good articles and videos out there on the subject. Learn how to sharpen first! It is a big part of carving. I'm no expert, btw, maybe a decent rookie?!? As for particular tools, that is really relative to what you want to carve.

After I posted this, I found a pic of a project right out of the magazine I did a few years ago...this is about 9" tall and it was gold leafed to use as a centerpiece for soem Christmas garland around our front door. I used basswood.

Tony