answer to drawer fitting question
Bill Tindall
Background:
A tight fitting drawer can be closed by pushing one corner with your finger and it will slide closed without binding . It is a most satisfying achievement. A too tight fitting drawer can't be closed(or opened) and the owner of the piece will throw it away. Hence, err on the too loose.
Wood doesn't expand long grain and a typical drawer will have long grain running horizontal (drawer width). Wood will change dimension cross grain (drawer height) so this dimension varies with season.
When I rough cut a drawer I make the front to just fit the opening. This task is done by sawing the drawer approximately correct and then planing to get a fit. A shooting board is useful for the end grain planing. The back of the drawer is make a little less wide, 1/16" of less. In other words in the rough fit drawer I want a slight taper front to back. I make the sides about 1/16" less tall than the drawer opening or even less tall if the drawer is being assembled in low humidity or it is an exceptionally tall drawer.
After the drawer is glued up I plane down the sides so that there is about 1/32" reveal on each side of the drawer front and about 1/16" at the top. It is hard to give exact numbers but the goal is: taking into account the imperfections of the case and everything else, plane till the drawer slides in smoothly and the reveal in the front is pleasing. It is less risky making something for yourself because you can always adjust if it is too tight later in the drawer life. (make the bottom removable as is traditionally done so adjustments can be done later if necessary)
Then I shellac, lightly sand and wax the drawer and case sides and wax the runners. A well fit drawer can be effortlessly closed when it all goes well. It is most satisfying.
Sources of failure: While the drawer width will not change with humidity changes(enabling a tight fitting width) if the case bows the drawer may bind on its sides. Hence, I put a slight taper on the drawer width, front to back, so it fits a bit looser in the back than the crisp 1/32 reveal I want to achieve in the front that shows.
The height of the drawer will change with humidity. How much depends on the lumber you used, both species and how it was sawed and dried and how tall the drawer is. I use KD quarter sawed poplar and shoot for about 1/16"-3/32 on the height.
Drawers in modern factory furniture are not fit, but they were in antique furniture. Every time you get to see an old piece examine the drawer reveals and come to your own conclusion of what works and what looks good. I was amazed how small the reveal could be on the sides, and how well it looked, so over time my drawers have become tighter in this dimension. Again I can get by with risking too tight because I can correct the problem if it shows up in a wet season. If you are selling stuff, I am not a source of useful advice.