We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
We have three sections of maple butcher block in our kitchen, that we need to improve or replace to put the house on the market. The dry counters are in fair condition with one or two strands starting to delaminate. The wet counter is deteriorated / discolored around the stainless sink.
How can I find out out taking these down to good wood and then how to refinish them ?
Working back from the intended result, you want to end up with clean, dry wood, with no visible seams or cracks, protected under a serviceable finish. To get there, you'll need to take the sink out and let the butcher block dry out as completely as possible. Then, prepare the surface with a belt sander, hand planes, orbital sanders or whatever else it takes to get down to clean, sound maple.
In preparing the wood for finishing, it's critical that you clean and scrape all the inside edges around the sink cutout, particularly the endgrain areas, and seal them with at least one solid coating of epoxy. I like Gougeon Brothers "West System" epoxy, available at any boat dealer or by mail order from many sources (particularly our advertisers . It wouldn't hurt to extend the epoxy up and onto the top surface of the butcher block for several inches around the sink rim as added protection from future moisture. If there are any cracks or discoloration remaining after you sand the top, I suggest bleaching them with oxalic acid bleach (available at paint stores in crystal form, labeled "wood bleach"). Again make sure that the wood has dried out before proceeding with the epoxy. If the cracks are large enough to get a business card into, you might want to fill them with some fine wood dust mixed with epoxy, and then sand them flush to the bare wood before proceeding with the epoxy step.
After the epoxy cures hard, the next step is to apply a finish. Here you have a choice: Either coat the entire surface with two or three coats of gloss polyurethane or use a softer oil-based varnish such as Waterlox or one of the boat varnishes. The downside of polyurethane is that you really shouldn't use the counter as a cutting surface, because, once you cut into the polyurethane, moisture can get in there and it is difficult to repair. Spar varnish and other marine varnishes are considerably softer and less abrasion resistant but they're easier to repair. Your call.
After the final coat of varnish, rub it down lightly with fine (320-grit) stearated sandpaper if you want a matte surface. When you reinstall the sink use a bead of plumbers putty under the rim of the sink to prevent any moisture from wicking in there. Make sure you get a thorough squeeze of putty around the rim and trim away the excess with a stick or something that won't cut into the finish.
My 2�. Hope it helps.
Ellis
PS Or, as Bill suggests, if the tops aren't inextricably attached, consider taking them out and getting them surfaced by someone with a wide-belt sander. Then proceed with the sealing and finishing steps I mentioned.
I just went through this excerzise - stave laminated beech counter. The sink and faucet was removed and all the old finish removed with an ROS. Mostly with 100 grit and finished with 180 grit.
The discoloration around the old, leaking faucet was not bleeched - I just did not consider this would come out looking any better, and the discoloration is small enough that I will be the only one noticing.
As a finish, I chose a nitrocellulose flat laquer, inteded for hard use flooring. Biggest draw-back is the stench during curing, but the resulting surface should be very durable and easy to keep clean. I picked the flat surface, as a high gloss will show every little imperfection, and the laminations do have a lot of small imperfections.
Presumably, you do not really mean true butcher block, which has an end grain surface. If this presumption is wrong, I would not know how to go about the renovation.
It's hard to say without actually seeing the damage or discoloration of your Maple countertops but these are suggestions based on actual experience installing many Kitchens with Maple tops , all of which were made by John Boos and company, the leader in Hardwood countertops.
None of the tops had a film finish, they were sealed with a proprietary oil by the company, the company recommends strongly that the appearance and utility of the tops be maintained by using a oil, such as their Magic Mountain oil .
We use Howard's Feed and Wax preparation on ours and reccomend it to clients and none have been less then satisfied with the product.
It is a mixture of Orange Oil , Bees Wax and Carnauba Wax applied twice a year.
Film finishes have a place , but not on wood Kitchen countertops, they create problems rather then solve them in use , which a poster mentioned the most prominent one.
IF you remove the top , do not run it though a planer, rather have a shop use a wide belt thickness sander to remove a 64th to a 1/32" , which should give you a new appearance without the tearout you will get from a planer , unless your lucky enough to find someone with a Helical cutter head that will accommodate a 25" wide top.
Also if you remove it hoping the underside looks better, you will discover that the best side was up and the bottom side probably would not lend itself to take the place of the top side.
If I were doing it and the top was a quality one to start with ,rather then a Econno Block , which many lumber yards sell , I would use a freshly burred card scraper to
remove the top layer of grime , until I like the look and then seal it with Howard's product.
Maple countertops are a relatively high maintenance item and extra care is given them for appearance's , you wouldn't live long enough to wear one out.
Addressing the open joints may be as easy as using a wood crack filler such as TimberMate in the Maple color, I use this product for nail holes and cracks and it is the best I have seen for that purpose.
It accepts the oil finish , so it will not be noticeable.
If the top was a quality manufacture, it should not be opening along the gluelines in normal use , so find out what is causing it before you decide on the fix.
Around the sink needs to kept clean and dry and is far easier to do with a top mounted cast iron sink rather then a sheetmetal one, but this may be more of a cost increase then you want to deal with, the Stainless steel will work , but no offense intended , in my personal opinion, one on a Maple countertop looks like mud flaps on a Cadillac if you will pardon the expression.
If you opt for the cast iron sink , choose one that has had the flats underneath the edges milled straight and level, so a steel yard stick will not show bumps or valleys in the milling.
I use clear PolySealSeal which is a Adhesive caulk with unbelievable strength in the bonding of the Iron to the wood top.
Dap brand Kitchen and Bath caulk is similar.
Take it slow and you should do okay especially if you keep a card scraper well tuned.
Run it by me anytime you want to in emails or here .
I'm a fan, actually, more a fanatic, about protecting wood that will be subjected to moisture before the final coat goes on. This means using a penetrating finish compatible with the final finish. This can be as simple as thinning, up to fifty percent, a poly finish, so that it penetrates, rather than leaving a finish coat.
If you want it to have more flex, so it will shift with changes in the wood, you can add a little hardening oil, like tung oil or boiled linseed oil. That is the essential difference between a nautical oil based finish and an interior finish. As noted, they tend to be softer, or they couldn't flex with changes in the wood dimensions.
One of the big advantages of treating the wood before your final finish is you can use oil to swell wood which has shrunk from drying (resulting in cracks). Non hardening oil seems to work best for this, since it doesn't harden, it can soak into and swell the wood. I've had very good luck doing this to severely cracked butcher blocks.
Were I to treat a window sill or area around a sink before applying a final finish, I'd keep applying a thinned oil based polyurethane product. I'd, over the course of a day, apply more of the thinned mix each time I walked by and noticed the previous application had soaked in, until the wood was saturated. Once saturated, wipe off the excess and let it harden. This could even be done after a straight oil treatment.
I bought several maple table tops from School Surplus sales that I have cleaned up to use in my kitchen. The ones that came from woodshops only required some aggressive sanding with the ROS. But I got one 12' top from an HVAC shop. I ended up using a 3 1/2 hand planer to take about 3/16 off the top to get down to clean wood. The wood was so hard I did 4 passes to take that much off. Then used an 8" orbital sander to level it out, and then a ROS to clean it up and smooth it out. It might not be perfectly flat, but it's pretty close, and it looks really nice.
I have had butcher block tops in some,but not all, areas of the kitchen since 1970. They were/are used for cutting up stuff, kneading bread, and other work tasks, ie they are worked on. Some suggested applying a cured finish ("varnish") to the tops under discussion. This suggestion implied to me that these tops are not used for cutting upon.?. Instead of a butcher block work area of the kitchen these tops are everywhere, even the sink? Given the durability comparison of typical counter top material -rock, Formica, Corian, tile- and a "varnished" surface I don't see what could be done on such a top other than admire it.
I wouldn't spend much effort on these tops beyond making them look presentable because the new owners will probably remove them in short order and replace with something durable.
Every 15 years or so I plane about 1/32" off mine to renew. There is too much oil absorbed to successfully sand them. They get periodic scraping with a pastry scraper for cleaning.
As correctly observed by Jesper of Denmark, these "butcher blocks" that I asked about are laminated maple with the side grain as the working surface - not the true butcher block with end grain up.
Thank you gentlemen, your generousity with your knowledge has really helped me. Bill