Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

Posts

My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#1

My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

Rich Pearson in Mill Creek, WA

Rockler should be very embarrassed by their offer of "Curly Maple Lumber .. Reg. $8.00 /sq.ft Sale $4.49 / sq.ft. " as offered in their latest 2011 sales ad. It gave a whole new definition to the term "Curly" as in curly shaped lumber, curly (bark included) edges, no straight edges anywhere, and NO curl in the grain!. In addition, most of the boards were only "skip" planed.

I went through the whole stack and, even though I primarily use short lengths for gluing up segmented bowl pieces, the wastage of both time and material would have been significant, raising the already ludicrous price for grade #3 or #4 lumber.

NO WAY was this lumber ever worth the claimed original price of 8 bucks. It isn't even worth the $4.49 they were asking.

Since Rockler is 23 miles from where I live, I will not be spending any money there anymore. I will drive 6 miles further to patronize the South Seattle lumber dealers who actually have quality lumber in stock.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#2

Defending Rockler

Bartstar

I am sorry you were disappointed in your experience in buying lumber from Rockler. In general, I do not purchase lumber from places that are tool and equipment companies - including Woodcraft. There are much better and cheaper suppliers of lumber around that are focused on just lumber.

My most recent experience in dealing with Rockler was regarding the return of a gallon of General Finishes Water Based Poly. I sent the gallon back via US Parcel Post. A month later, Rockler had still not received the package, so they are sending me a Rockler gift certificate for the amount of my original purchase. I think that this is above and beyond what I would have expected from any supplier. I remain a fan of this company.

Regards

Bart

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#3

JL

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

JL

Ditto what Bartstar said. I would never buy lumber from a tool and equipment dealer.

I deal with Rockler for tools and hardware. They have reasonably priced router bits and reasonably priced clamps. If you have a sale coupon, they are a good source for saw blades.

Lumber - I get from a lumber dealer or a saw mill operation.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#4

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

Howard Norman

I agree, I never buy lumber from either Rockler or Woodcraft. The selection is very limited and the price is high. I buy tools and hardware from both but never lumber.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#5

Re: Have to agree on the lumber

Larry Clinton Sr.

However I have bought some small pieces of "exotic" imported lumber at Rockler, Woodcraft and similar places (for small boxes, inserts etc.) as the sawmill where I do purchase odds and end lumber has a very limited supply of such wood. The majority of his stock (probably over 98%) is local wood or decking etc. Most of my wood supply has been purchased from local estate sales - mostly Amish families. I have several thousand feet of Cherry, Walnut, Oak and other local woods purchased at these sales - The Amish seem to be able to find some remaining old growth trees as some of the wood has very fine grain and is quite wide and long. The prices for this air dried wood has been very low - well under $.50 a BF. Around here (central Indiana), at the auctions the rough sawn lumber has few bidders, however any planed lumber goes quite high - usually close to the price at retail outlets.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#6

Re: Have to agree on the lumber

Mark_in_Michigan

I agree with the others, Rockler (or Woodcraft) would not be my first choice to buy wood, but I don't know your situation. Have you looked for other local sawmills? I used Woodfinder and found a sawmill about 35 miles away I make a trip to every Fall and stock up. I can look through every board he has if I want to and pick out the best. Even though I don't have him do it because I have the equipment, he does offer planing services for a modest fee to clean it up.

If they didn't have a piece of wood that appealed to me I would be disappointed but it wouldn't stop me from going back. I don't think even calling and asking them about the wood would help since beauty is definitely in the eye of the beholder.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#7

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

Robert R. Clough

I have purchased "goods" from Rockler in Wauwatosa, WI, for over 20 years - well in Wauwatosa since they moved there - and shall continue to. It is abouit 20 miles from Muskego. I do not purchase wood there, except occasionally and usually plywood for a project, but I do get hardware and some tools there. I prefer to get my wood either at Green Man or Kettle Moraine or perhaps from a neighbor if he has something like Cherry cut down.

I have never been disappointed with Rockler quality. Perhaps it is our local store. I know many of the clerks by name as well as the Mgr. I also assume that everyone, including Rockler Hq in Minn., are human and therefore subject to error (which, of course, I am not!). Prices are perhaps a bit higher than at Elliotts Ace or Home Depot, but Rockler has item not found elsewhere except at Lee Valley which is also excellent.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#8

Clint Searl

Missing the point

Clint Searl

The point has nothing to do with where one "should" buy lumber, and has everything to do with how a business presents itself to potential customers. Claiming a product is of a certain quality when it obviously isn't is fundamentally dishonest, and justifiably reason to shun that business.

Clint

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#9

Exactly!

DavesNotHere

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#10

Other places in Seattle/Tacoma

Ed Beck

Hi Rich,

I go to Crosscut Hardwoods on 1st Ave S.

4100 1st Ave South

Seattle WA, 98134

206-623-0334

800-756-0334

Monday - Friday 7:30 - 6 pm Saturday 9 - 5 pm

They seem to have a good selection. What do you think of them?

I'm curious about other lumber places you and others have been to in the Seattle/Tacoma area.

I've also been to Engineered Lumber in Tacoma but I think they moved their locaiton. I thought the way that they brought the lumber out to you on a pallet for you to pick over was interesting, but I like having it stacked up more.

Ed

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#11

Re: Maybe, Clint

Larry Clinton Sr.

But it is also possible that the Rockler Store in question did have some great boards - prior to his visit. It may well be that the stock was "picked over" and only the scrub lumber left. Personally, I have went to many retail outlets and been very disappointed in the merchandise available at the time due to items being picked over and the "best of the lot" gone. Usually it's my fault for going too late after the sale started. I like the local Rockler (Indianapolis, IN) store and have found the personnel quite helpful at times. I do realize that the store is normally going to charge more for the items available as they are a specialty store and probably have a lot more overhead per sales dollar than say an Ace hardware, HD, Lowes or Menards type store. You find the same pricing issues with independent clothing stores, Gourmet groceries and Starbucks coffee. As many of the items found at Rockler and Woodcraft stores are only locally available at those stores, I wouldn't quit buying there just due to the fact the lumber didn't suit me, any more than I would quit shopping at a men's clothing store because the selection of jewelery didn't please me. Each to his own -

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#12

Re: Maybe, Clint

Robert R. Clough

Precisely, Larry. Considering the relatively large number of stores Rockler has, I'd be surprised if each one received the same quality of so called Curly Maple as part of a sale. And as most of us have said, why purchase wood at Rockler. I have looked through boards there, on sale, and never found anything I'd buy. Perhaps that is why Rockler scheduled the sale, to get rid of a not too good batch. One must also decide where to purchase what. I'd not look for quality meats or produce at Pick and Save (Roundy's) but I would at Sendik.

Oh yes, I said so called Curly Maple. Generally most CM is what I'd call Tiger Maple. We have a small sewing chest made of old fashioned CM - made probably about 1850 t0 1860 - a family piece.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#13

Clint Searl

So you're saying.....

Clint Searl

that it's O.K. for a business to employ deceptive advertising.

Clint

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#14

Re: So you're saying.....

mike

I have paid as much as $40.00 a board ft fro curly maple. It just depends on how highly curly or how it is "marked". If I saw a sale on curly maple at a low price, you just got to know that it most likly will not be "museum" quality. I am sure that Rockler never intended to trick or mis-guide anyone.

In life it has always been another human being that has hurt me the most, saying that you will never shop at a store because of the quality of the "Sale-priced curly maple": Is like saying that one will never talk with another human being as long as they live.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#15

I made THAT trip . . .

steve mackay

(mail order) a LONG time ago. It was about the time they TOLD me what coat hook they were GONNA send me regardless of what I had ordered. Unlike my favorite store that actually KNOWS what they have in da house, the store in question actually makes nothing, stocks nothing in-house nor cares if they get my money or not. They have plenty. And have plenty of folks lined up outside their door.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#16

Re: So you're saying.....

Robert R. Clough

What is deceptive? From what we have read here, no one knows how many boards were CM. Perhaps they were all sold. Perhaps they were not highly marked. Perhaps that store got fewer than another store. Perhaps, perhaps, perhaps. To prove deception , one must prove it was deliberate.

All we know is that one particular purchaser is dis-satisfied.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#17

Clint Searl

You deserve what you tolerate

Clint Searl

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#18

Interesting responses. I lived in Portland, OR

Rich Pearson in Mill Creek, WA

for 25 years before moving to Seattle. I too found the eye candy and top notch quality at Gilmer's to be irresistable. I still stop there on trips south. I also found good quality lumber at Woodcrafters in Portland at a competitive price.

For the record, I arrived at the Rockler store 3 hours after opening on the first day of the sale. It was not busy and I picked through quite a pile of the afore-mentioned "curly" maple without finding anything usable. Keep in mind that I no longer build furniture (My home is full) so long, wide boards are not a requirement. I have full milling capabilities and can work around defects when constructing segmented turning bowl blanks. I just didn't find anything good enough to warrant the considerable millwork required. The issue was the lack of quality.

I DO frequent all of the alternate sources mentioned as well as several not yet mentioned (Midway Plywood in Lynnwood, Compton Lumber and Blackstock Lumber. They will be my primary sources, even though most of them are further from home, as the quality is always there.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#19

Bypass The Middleman

David Yoho

There is a local Woodcraft store here that sells lumber. I don't buy from them unless it's a one-board emergency. Most of the time I buy from a local millwork and lumber company or even more times I go straight to Woodcraft's source. They are about 1-hour away versus 25 minutes to the store but I usually buy enough to make the trip worth it.

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#20

Re: Bypass The Middleman

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

Unfortunately out here in the PNW there are very few small mills and even less "fancy" hardwood. Just for grins I did a woodfinder search with my zip code, on-site sawing and White oak. Got two hits at less than 200 miles, 1 at 477 and on up to # 10 at 1800 miles.

not much hardwood

Re: My FINAL trip to Rockler....ever!

#21

Re: Interesting responses. I lived in Portland, OR

Xavier Salazar

Rich,

I understand you're frustrating experiance with not finding any usable boards, but had you talked to the Manager you would understand why. If you were there 3 hours after the store opened on the day the sale started which was Jan 1st.than you never saw the Curly Maple that was in the ad. I was there on the same day and found out the Maple that was in the ad had not even arrived at the store yet due to snow conditions several states away. The Maple was being trucked in from the East and was delayed a few days. When it did show up there were alot of nice boards which has been picked through pretty well by now. The Maple you saw was the leftover pieces from the previous sale several months earlier. I have never had any problem finding really nice material at Rockler. I do shop at the other lumber suppliers when I need bulk quanties or rough sawn material.