We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I usually orient door panels so that the grain runs vertically. I usually orient drawer fronts so that the grain runs horizontally. I usually orient aprons so that the grain runs horizontally. For chests and boxes, I have the sides with a horizontal grain orientation and the top with the grain running along the long axis. I don't really use veneer and I haven't done any marquetry - so I haven't really considered them and their grain orientation possibilities.
I saw the back picture of FWW with the "Old Growth Splendor" with the end grain drawer fronts and I thought that they looked really good.
I realized then that I should really consider other orientation possibilities. What works and what doesn't work, so to speak. How do ya'll incorporate grain orientation into the design of your workpiece. Would anyone care to share their experiences?
I won't get into aesthetics since I'm not sure that I have enough expertise beyond asking myself "does this look better or does this look better" when thinking through a design. I will side with form following function every time. For example, if one is putting an apron on a table it is almost invariably for strength -- making a long table apron anything but long-grain would remove virtually all strength from it.
Doesn't make it RIGHT. At first glance, I thought he used veneer, and did a very good job of matching the edges. But then on down, saw that they were actually end-grain through the whole thickness.
This may look great for a photo when the piece is just finished, but I hope the wood was at a perfect EMC for the atmosphere where it will reside FOREVER.
But once the relative humidity takes a big swing either up or down for a week or less, those fronts will likely self destruct.
As for using the term "old growth", I think the term here might also be in question. I am fairly certain that at 62, I am older than the ring count of those wafers, and would estimate there were probably no more than 30 more to the pith. Just being old wood, doesn't keep it from moving due to MC changes.
I think 'Old Growth' is more accurate describing a forest track rather than individual trees. It is accepted as being undisturbed for 150 years. If you harvested a 75 year old tree from an OG tract, does this make it OG?
I will echo John's point about surface decoration -- in this case, the use of endgrain pieces for the drawer fronts -- being a subjective matter. James Krenov was one well-known proponent of parquetry, and many of his later pieces are decorated in that way. Aesthetically, there are no absolutes. I suppose it is a mark of your graphic design skills if you are able to compose with the grain in a way that is appealing to a lot of people. On a given piece, though, it's only important that you satisfy your customer, whether that be you or someone else. And, one of the key criteria for satisfaction is that the piece be soundly built and functional, regardless of how the visual components are arranged.
Regarding the piece on the back cover of Fine Woodworking, I wonder how the endgrain drawer fronts are attached. The text says they are screwed to the drawer box. It would seem there are many design variables at play there. For one, the endgrain fronts are only about 1/2" thick and therefore prone to splitting, so the screwing method would be very critical. I'm guessing that there are quite a few screws, with two or three in the neighborhood of the drawer pulls to counteract whatever pulling forces might be exerted there. I can't imagine slotted holes in the drawer boxes, so I'd guess the clearance holes are oversize or flared to allow for some deflection in the event of differential movement between the box and front. Also, the fronts overlay the cabinet, so they are cantilevered off the drawer boxes, exposing them to possible breakage if they are ever bumped or snagged. Also, the pulls themselves are levers that are likely to pry out the wood at the top edges of the drawers if pulled upwards too enthusiastically. I'm not sure how those decisions were reconciled. Clearly a piece of this refinement is likely to be treated very well, but risks were taken with the structural design.
As for aesthetics, you be the judge. A top, with a reveal similar to the one at the base, would have helped balance the composition while providing some protection for the top drawer edges. To me, the difference in overall hue between the endgrain fronts and the other fronts is somewhat distracting. I'd probably have toned the whole piece to smooth over those differences. And, I'm not sure the endgrain of the front-to-back stretchers adds to the composition.
From a visual/graphic design standpoint, grain and color composition are part of the design equation. Consider the visual effect vis a vis your aesthetic intent and also the cost and functional/structural consequences. The trick is to solve all these problems simultaneously.
A simple table needs the aprons for it's structure but there is a whole world out there in which the aprons are done differently. This is a photo of a vertical grain apron I did as a commission to match existing furniture. It's maple and the apron is sawn from 8/4 stock, I can assure it's a very strong design. The vertical orientation does create other engineering issues due to wood movement but overcome fairly easily.
While this table (below) has horizontal grain the apron is not structural, the structure is concealed and rests almost entirely on the center base leaving the ends light enough to open and close the table easily.
In some ways the essence of design is does this look better than that so you do have the skills. I find that I get a lot of inspiration by looking at pictures of furniture, sometimes I will see a piece that I don't really like but it has a really great detail I can incorporate into something.
One other thing that can help improve design sense is when you see a piece of furniture you don't like is to figure out what it is about it that you don't like about it. I find this much harder than figuring out why I like something.
For massive amounts of furniture pictures I would recommend the books by Lark Press like "500 Cabinets" or "500 Tables". Lots of variation in the work and a lot of interesting stuff, they might also have a chair book out but I'm not sure.
Old Growth refers to a virgin timber stand that has not been cut and there is a distinct difference in the wood that comes from it compared to second and third growth which is what you get when you replant a clearcut..
Some old growth like Redwood is nearly priceless now and a lot of our other hardwoods are headed that way.
Speaking of old growth wood, several years ago I brought home a few boards from a remodeling job. They were cedar, 20 inches wide, quarter sawn. I counted the growth rings as over 500. These were from siding on a house built in the 1940's.