Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

Posts

OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#1

OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We're preparing to insulate the cathedral ceiling of our shed conversion with 3" of polyiso sheet foam. Each rafter bay will be ventilated with a large soffit vent and continuous ridge vent.

Polyiso foam comes standard with aluminum foil on each face. Our son has heard from some roofers he's talked with that this construction detail creates problems with condensation on the upper face of the foam, running down to the lower edge where it drips off to start rotting the wall.

Is this in fact an issue? A local supply house can get me tarpaper-faced polyiso, but this doesn't serve as a vapor barrier (may not be an issue anyway; I will probably install a vapor barrier or use vapor barrier primer).

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#2

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

Barry Irby

This is a "standard" detail and used in many houses. Locally there are more houses that have fiberglass than foam. It is important that the fiberglass not touch the underside of the sheathing. If it does, it interrupts the airflow and condensation may soak into the sheathing and cause it to rot or delaminate. For that to happen, the conditions have to be correct (or exactly wrong).

In your case, it will be easy to maintain a clear path for the ventilation. I doubt there will be a problem, but you should assure there is an open path for air to pass through the trough and out the top. You might also extend the top piece of foam past the wall and let any condensation that runs off drip into the soffit. At least you would have a chance to catch it before it rots the walls. (Ice Cycles hanging out of he soffit vents might be your clue.)

The issue of venting the rafter spaces is very complex and opinions are changing and very much related to local climate. I think the current best practice is to spray the inside of each cavity with a non hygroscopic foam (Does not absorb water) and do not install ventilation. By thoroughly sealing each cavity there is no air flow. Most of the water we are discussing is air transported moisture vapor. That it, the air carries it in and deposits it on the "first condensing surface". By limiting the air slow, you limit the vapor. This is a much better system. In your case, you have to go to great pains to make sure the air does not leak in and flow under the insulation, negating the value of the insulation.

Check out Joe Lstiburek Building Science site. An overwhelming amount of info available.

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#3

Thanks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The inspector is insisting on ventilation, and retrofitting an airsealed cavity would be very difficult anyway.

I appreciate the suggestions.

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#4

I would guess....

John in NM

That any problems are associated more with installation errors than the product itself. Proper ventilation is something that varies widely by location, though most codes are written assuming you live in Seattle or Boston. In warm humid climates, condensation can form on the inside of the insulation, or on the outside face of the insulation rather than on the sheathing. The problem comes when the venting air is too humid to effectively evaporate the condensation, and short of what Barry suggested, there is really no way around this. About the only thing you could do is try to protect the wall with some tar paper on top and give any condensation a way to get out rather than sitting there and damaging the wall.

The easiest way to avoid problems is to keep the AC only a little cooler than the outside air - that will keep the insulation from getting cold enough to have condensation forming on the humid side, maybe. This is all assuming of course that the problems you've heard about occur when the outside air is hot and very humid, and the AC inside is set on 68 :D

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#5

Air conditioning?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've heard of that stuff. Old houses here on the CA North Coast don't have air conditioning much, and we're not installing it in this workshop project.

And moist air is more a winter than a summer issue here, with the condensation occurring on a cold inside surface in a heated environment (like a single-pane window). Summer humidity, while not desert-like, is relatively low - which is why I periodically write letters to the editors of the woodworking mags about articles written by folks in the Midwest or on the East coast that assume their humidity patterns are everyone's.

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#6

Ok, that's clearer...

John in NM

You shouldn't have anything to worry about. :D

Usually in a cold climate you get some moisture passing through the skin of the house, and condensing on the first cold surface, often the roof sheathing. The flip side is when you are in Florida or somewhere, and have hot humid air outside, then a cold skin on the inside of the house.

From what the roofer's seemed to be talking about, it sounded like the latter condition, but it's always possible the roofers didn't much know what they were talking about (don't get me started on roofers :D)

I'd forgotten that this was a shop.... no source of moisture inside, unless you boil water for tea incessantly, or have a bath tub and a cleanliness fetish :D

So yeah, no worries at all. Insulate, vent to keep the inspector happy, then forget about it all and make some shavings :D

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#7

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

FredD

Barry is right about using a sealed rather then a vented air space between the rafters, but you may have a hard time convincing the Inspector.

The vapor barrier ideally should be on top of the roof sheathing under the shingles to stop water vapor from moving through the roof and condensing on the inside of the the roof on the vapor barrier your planning to install.

This isexactly the reason vapor barriers are wrapped around the outside of the framing of a wall , they stop the water vapor from entering and condensing on the first warm surface.

If your rafter bays are 16 or 24 inch O.C. I think venting a enclosed soffit every third rafter bay is plenty coupled with a foam standoff in the rafter bay that keeps the airflow going to the ridge vent.

The standoff comes in four foot lengths and is ridged so the air flow is not impinged on by what ever insulation your going to install.

Lastly , maintaining a warm interior in the shop 23/7 will do wonders for preventing problems with cold surfaces.

FredD

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#8

Thanks, Fred, and thanks, all

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It sounds like I'll be OK. The foam will go up as tight as we can manage it, and then get foamed in place; and I'm sealing the electrical boxes against air leakage (I've gotten really fond of the aluminum tape they're selling for duct sealing these days). So air leakage from the building into the rafter bays should be minimal to non-existent.

John, it'll be dirt, not sawdust, getting made - this is my potter wife's shop.

And, Fred, "...maintaining a warm interior in the shop 23/7..."? Is that leftover hour in the day so the heating system can catch its breath? ;)

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#9

Re: Thanks, Fred, and thanks, all

FredD

Aren't the days shorter out there Bill ??

FredD

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#10

This time of year, the days may be shorter

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but the nights are sure danged long.

Waiting for the light to come back...

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT - condensation on sheet foam insulation

Jesper, Denmark

Hi Bill,

With presumably a SanFran type of climate and no AC, the choice seems to be clear: Vapor barrier betwen the insulation and the living/shop space and venting between the roof surface and the insulation.

Effectively sealing the insulation is dang near impossible.

Think of it this way: Water vapor will migrate through just about everything - even the plastic vapor barrier. The point of the vapor barrier is that the water vapor migrates very little through it and the the venting can transport much more vapor than the barrier lets through.