Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

vacuum veneering question

Posts

vacuum veneering question

#1

vacuum veneering question

Bill Tindall

How long do I need to leave the drawer front under vacuum? "White" glue used.

On the one hand if I was making an edge joint one hour would do. But this is veneer on one side with less capacity to soak up water than a full sized chunk of wood like in an edge joint. Hence, water will only be removed in the direction of the substrate so joint cure could be longer.?.

I have 5 drawers ready to do so I don't want to leave a piece in the bag any longer than I have to. And, given my inexperience I am not going to try more than one at a time in the bag, even though the bag I borrowed is huge.

Re: vacuum veneering question

#2

IIRC

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The vac guys leave it "on" overnight [12 to 24 hours]. They use vacuum reservoirs so that the pumps can run intermittently to hold the pressure.

Re: vacuum veneering question

#3

I'd be curious...

John in NM

To know the answer as well. In theory if the vacuum is at all strong, like +29"Hg, the glue should lose water more rapidly, but in practice, there is that wood in the way :D

Of course you don't need anywhere close to that kind of vacuum for veneering, but give the price tag on most of the pumps I've seen, you're probably getting it anyhow.

I haven't used a vacuum bag in years, I recall though that too much vacuum was actually a problem using plastic resin glue. If there was a place the bag could form a little vacuum pocket, like a corner where there is empty space, the atmospheric pressure outside isn't strong enough to squash the bubbles where the glue boils. So anywhere there was glue froth, I remember the joint being weak.

Might have just mixed too much water in the glue, that stuff is known to be a bit tricky. :D

Re: vacuum veneering question

#4

Re: vacuum veneering question

Jesse Cloud

Hope you get a definitive answer from someone. I've held off looking for one, but since we all seem a little tentative, here's my two cents worth.

In a flat, simple glue-up, I leave it in the bag for two hours if I need the bag for something else. Atmospheric pressure varies with altitude. I am at 5,500 ft and draw about 21 inches of pressure on the vacuum, you will draw more if you are lower.

In a stressed glue-up, with tight curves, I always leave it in overnight to allow the glue to come close to full cured strength.

The curves on your drawer fronts seem gentle, so I would suspect that a couple of hours would be enough.

The other, and maybe safer option: put a glue-up in for a couple of hours, examine it to make sure its reasonably secure. If not, back to the bag. If it is, push it back to the back of the bag, prepare the next workpiece (or two) and add them to the bag. When done, leave the whole thing in the bag overnight.

If you have a helper available, having another set of hands to hold the bag open is a great idea. I have also held it open with a clip hanging on a string from the ceiling.

Let us know how it comes out!

Re: vacuum veneering question

#5

Some weird discovery through experience

Hikmet C. Sakman

Hi Bill,

I am sure you all know about veneering one side of a substrate leads to warpage due to uneven moisture exchange on the faces of the one face veneered panel.

The issue is actually the "introduced" moisture by the glue, since wood absorbs much less moisture through its face, not to mention the glue line under the first panel.

Long story short, when I leave the veneered one face panel in the press for a day or two, warpage is usually eliminated due to cured glue and taken away moisture from the bag, or rather the glued up panel. This is contrary to the common blief and I really don't want to get into an argument because I still do not know a constant factor about this issue other than what I just mentioned. Perhaps ambient humidity and temperature are also factors.

But, to answer your question, if you glued both sides, it is safe to take it out in and hour or so at 80F or 20C. Temperature has an enormous effect in waterbased glues drying times. Longer if the glue up done in colder places, but no more than 2 hours unless you are below 45~50 degrees and below that temperature, I suggest you glue up somewhere warmer.

Good luck.

Chico

Re: vacuum veneering question

#6

Correction

Hikmet C. Sakman

The issue is actually the "introduced" moisture by the glue, since wood absorbs much less moisture through its face, not to mention the glue line under the first PLY....... not panel. Referring to a plywood panel.

Re: vacuum veneering question

#7

Good to see your name again.....

Barry Irby

I have not done any vacuum veneering, and I was waiting on the Pro's to see the answer. I would have bet on somewhere between about two hours and "forever". My thinking was that the bag would slow things down, sort of like putting the glue back into a really big bottle. (glue lasts a LOONNG time in the bottle. So, either double my usual one hour or overnight. We all know that something mystical happens during the night, thus we leave many things over night.

Re: vacuum veneering question

#8

Re: Good to see your name again.....

Hikmet C. Sakman

Thanks Barry. Although I understand your logic, glue dries surprisingly fast in the vacuum press due to constant suction of air and of course moisture with it.

Re: vacuum veneering question

#9

Re: vacuum veneering question

Thomas S Stockton

Bill

What Chico said is pretty much what I do an hour or so at 80 degrees is good. I use an electric blanket to keep my press warm. I also wired an outlet/extension cord with a 12 hour timer so I just set and it turns on the press and blanket. Anything stressed like a bent lamination needs to be in much longer like 6 to 8 hours depending on the glue.

Tom

Re: vacuum veneering question

#10

thanks all

Bill Tindall

I left each drawer front in about 2 hours and then just added another to the bag (huge borrowed bag) then set a timer so the last was in 4 hours. Very gentle curve so that just the tape held the veneer down. Will de-bag shortly and get on with the last task of applying cock bead.

I spent lots of time making arrows with chalk to get the veneer pieces oriented properly on the drawer fronts.

While at Winterthur we noticed a chest of drawers where a drawer was veneered upside down . It kind of interrupted the flow of the veneer pattern. It is easy to loose track of drawer front/veneer orientation.

Re: vacuum veneering question

#11

Re: thanks all

Sgian Dubh

As others have said Bill about an hour is all you need for veneering with PVA in an unheated bagpress at 'room temperature': this is the time we allow, although if we are in a hurry we sometimes pull the panel out after about half an hour or forty five minutes. Add heat, eg, about 55-60�C and you can pull the panel out in less than two or three minutes.

Four hours is generally needed if you are using the common form of urea formaldehyde glue at 'room temperature' for veneering. The common form of this glue is the one-pack powder to which you add water to activate the catalyst and then mix up prior to application. This glue also cures fast if heated-- about 2 or 3 minutes at 55-60�C, and heat is a real time saver if you are veneering or laminating with urea formaldehyde. However the heat has to get all the way through a thick lamination to speed up the cure, so the general rule is to allow 2 minutes per millimetre of thickness, eg, if you are gluing up laminates that add up to 20 mm thick, allow 40 minutes in the press.

Incidentally, someone mentioned 80�F and 20�C in the same sentence, which sort of inferred to me that they are the same temperature. 80�F is about the same as 26.7�C, and 20�C (the 'room temperature' I cited above) is 68�F. The sum for close conversions from Celsius to Fahrenheit is (�C X 1.8) + 32 = �F, eg, (20�C X 1.8) + 32 = 68�F. Of course the calculation is relatively easily rearranged to convert from �F to �C. Slainte.

Re: vacuum veneering question

#12

Good info, one question...

John in NM

How do you get it all that hot? Too hot to heat the whole room :D

Those times, both heated and un-heated, were more in line with what I was expecting based on the degree of vacuum usually achieved. The warping problems Chico mentioned make me wonder though if even under vacuum the moisture moves out of the wood fairly slowly, a couple days is more what I would expect at atmospheric pressure.

Re: vacuum veneering question

#13

Re: Good info, one question...

Sgian Dubh

John, there are some vacuum presses that have heated platens, and hoods you either fold down or slide across over the glue up, whether it be a veneering job or a laminating job. Of course, if the bent lamination is tall you may not be able to get the hood in place. These vac presses are not the same as the better known 'vac bag', which are probably more common because they are relatively inexpensive and work effectively enough. The heated vacuum presses may cost something in the region of �5000 or more, which is about 7750 US dollars.

I know of some furniture businesses that use electric blankets, as used to warm beds in winter, to help speed up gluing in their unheated vacuum presses. Anecdotal reports that I hear indicate these blankets are reasonable effective, but I've no primary empirical research of my own to give figures.

Vacuum drying of wood is one method of seasoning of course, so vacuum veneering probably speeds up the rate at which water from water based glue used in veneering is removed from the panel. However, the veneer job seldom stays in the press for more than an hour or so, so the likelihood of the method to significantly affect the outcome seems very small to me. I can't see this having much beneficial effect in relation to warping, particularly if only one side of a panel is veneered. In my experience veneering just one side of a large panel (significantly more often than not) leads to warping. Where drawer fronts are veneered (small panels) the warping is held in check by the small size, and the fact that the part is often jointed at either end to drawer sides using dovetails or other drawer box joints. Slainte.

Re: vacuum veneering question

#14

Of course....

John in NM

It would be an actual press :D I don't imagine our vinyl bags would stand up to heat very well.